Is Scottish independence a &#x27;good or bad&#x27; thing?

Original post by MatureStudent36

Kosovans were being ethnically cleansed and persecuted. Please don't align us to people who have suffered such horrors. You just confirm my opinion that Nats live in a different reality.

if you denna think Scotland deserves a country vote no.Scotland canna get independence by itself

Reply 3702

Original post by Tigers

if you denna think Scotland deserves a country vote no.Scotland canna get independence by itself

You're comment makes no sense. We could vote yes to separate by ourselves, but all indications are that we won't.....that still doesn't stop is being Scottish or being proud of that fact.

People such as you and Maths Tutor do your cause no favours. Between you you've likened our present situation as being oppressed militarily by another nation. Alex Salmond and the YeSNP campaign have been caught out luring too many times.

Reply 3703

Original post by MatureStudent36

You're comment makes no sense. We could vote yes to separate by ourselves, but all indications are that we won't.....that still doesn't stop is being Scottish or being proud of that fact.

People such as you and Maths Tutor do your cause no favours. Between you you've likened our present situation as being oppressed militarily by another nation. Alex Salmond and the YeSNP campaign have been caught out luring too many times.

being proud with words and with actions is different.People who vote no should be honest and admit that they vote no for their personal finance and they don't care about Scotland.

Reply 3704

Quady

20

Original post by Tigers

if you denna think Scotland deserves a country vote no.Scotland canna get independence by itself

Deserves?

The SNP doesn't think that Scotland 'deserves' its own currency.

For some of us, its not about ideology, whether or not Scotland 'deserves' a country, just whether we'd be better off or not.

Reply 3705

Original post by Quady

Deserves?

The SNP doesn't think that Scotland 'deserves' its own currency.

For some of us, its not about ideology, whether or not Scotland 'deserves' a country, just whether we'd be better off or not.

personal finance then

Reply 3706

Quady

20

Original post by Tigers

being proud with words and with actions is different.People who vote no should be honest and admit that they vote no for their personal finance and they don't care about Scotland.

The two things aren't mutually exclusive.

Seeing everyones standard of living get worse is not what I'd call a better Scotland.

Reply 3707

I don't see why these lads don't deserve a country for their own and always have to be a province of London
[video="youtube;lofNXF-UMe0"]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lofNXF-UMe0[/video]

Reply 3708

Original post by Tigers

being proud with words and with actions is different.People who vote no should be honest and admit that they vote no for their personal finance and they don't care about Scotland.

I'd argue the opposite. Many people I know who intend to vote yes are doing so not because of a pride in Scotland, but because somebody has sold them the myth that they're receive several thousand pounds of oil money each year. That sounds like greed to me.

I want a sound sustainable future fur me and my children. Not a crazy unsustainable pipe dream that will negatively impact the most vulnerable in society.

As the SNP has now lost the economic argument has SNP HQ to you to start on the emotional arguments again?

Reply 3709

Original post by Quady

The two things aren't mutually exclusive.

Seeing everyones standard of living get worse is not what I'd call a better Scotland.

the birth of Scotland may require some sacrifice

Reply 3710

English audience suggests to dump nuclear waste in Scotland
[video="youtube;7iXRcs-oS0E"]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7iXRcs-oS0E[/video]

Reply 3711

Original post by Tigers

the birth of Scotland may require some sacrifice

People like you really worry me. You worry me because comments like that lead me to believe that you may start doing silly things when you loose.

Reply 3712

Original post by Tigers

English audience suggests to dump nuclear waste in Scotland
[video="youtube;7iXRcs-oS0E"]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7iXRcs-oS0E[/video]

We have Scottish members of the public violently attacking people because they're from England. What point are you trying to make? We should let idiots decide our future?

Reply 3713

Original post by MatureStudent36

People like you really worry me. You worry me because comments like that lead me to believe that you may start doing silly things when you loose.

yes I can run and live
[video="youtube;WLrrBs8JBQo"]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WLrrBs8JBQo[/video]

Reply 3714

Original post by MatureStudent36

We have Scottish members of the public violently attacking people because they're from England. What point are you trying to make? We should let idiots decide our future?

let Scotland have its own future

Reply 3715

Original post by Tigers

let Scotland have its own future

We have our own future. I have a future now.

It worries me that a nationalist is promoting socialist views and self sacrifice for the country.

Now where have we heard of a national socialist organisation promoting self sacrifice for a country?

Reply 3716

Hectic

Are there any useful links in describing pros and cons of independence?

Reply 3717