The Student Room Group

Why does PASSIVE diffusion occur only in inactive organisms?

The only answer that I can formulate:
Passive diffusion only occurs in very small organisms as they have a very large surface area to volume ratio.
Inactive organisms have a low metabolic rate, and therefore respiration rate is also lower. Therefore they need less oxygen.

Based on these two facts, I can conclude that passive diffusion does not bring in as much oxygen into the body as compared with a specialised exchange surface in larger organisms.

Is this right? Anything missing?
Original post by ps1265A
The only answer that I can formulate:
Passive diffusion only occurs in very small organisms as they have a very large surface area to volume ratio.
Inactive organisms have a low metabolic rate, and therefore respiration rate is also lower. Therefore they need less oxygen.

Based on these two facts, I can conclude that passive diffusion does not bring in as much oxygen into the body as compared with a specialised exchange surface in larger organisms.

Is this right? Anything missing?


I wouldn't say it only occurs in inactive organisms, but I'm willing to overlook this.

Your first sentence is partly true. The organism should have a large SA/Vol ratio is all it relies on is passive uptake of nutrients. It doesn't necessarily have to be a very small organism. I also think that they don't need less oxygen, but rather can survive on less oxygen as opposed to your active counterpart.

Your last sentence is true. I think you should also point out that passive diffusion will not get nutrients/oxygen quickly enough or in large quantities which is required for active organisms, as they most likely have higher metabolic rates and are actively reproducing/replicating and will require specialised transport systems.

Hope this helps :smile:
Reply 2
Original post by Eloades11
I wouldn't say it only occurs in inactive organisms, but I'm willing to overlook this.

Your first sentence is partly true. The organism should have a large SA/Vol ratio is all it relies on is passive uptake of nutrients. It doesn't necessarily have to be a very small organism. I also think that they don't need less oxygen, but rather can survive on less oxygen as opposed to your active counterpart.

Your last sentence is true. I think you should also point out that passive diffusion will not get nutrients/oxygen quickly enough or in large quantities which is required for active organisms, as they most likely have higher metabolic rates and are actively reproducing/replicating and will require specialised transport systems.

Hope this helps :smile:



thanks!

im a little confused because my book also states that "the smaller the Sa/v, the more active an organism, the greater the need for an active transport system"

why does a small Sa/v mean a more active organism? Or is just one of those thing to accept?
Original post by ps1265A
thanks!

im a little confused because my book also states that "the smaller the Sa/v, the more active an organism, the greater the need for an active transport system"

why does a small Sa/v mean a more active organism? Or is just one of those thing to accept?


The smaller the SA/V, the lesser the amount of exchange via diffusion. Therefore, to compensate for this, the organism will have to have an active transport system, for an efficient exchange of substances. Also, a smaller SA/V may or may not mean an active organism.
Reply 4
Original post by Dynamo123
The smaller the SA/V, the lesser the amount of exchange via diffusion. Therefore, to compensate for this, the organism will have to have an active transport system, for an efficient exchange of substances. Also, a smaller SA/V may or may not mean an active organism.


I've somehow managed to link these ideas together:

Inactive means lower metabolic rate which means less oxygen taken up by cells which means a lower volume which means a large surface to volume ratio which allows inactive organisms to allow exchange over their surfaces

Active organisms like mammals who need to maintain a high body temperature have a high metabolic rate which means a lot of oxygen is transported into cells, and also they have a lot more cells because of their size, and therefore the volume is large compared to their surface area and so passive diffusion cannot occur in them

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending