Hello, I'm
animelover123, but I've lost my login details, which is why I have created a new account. With regards to what I have said in that post that you have quoted, I still feel what I have said has got reason to it.
Though, I do admit that i have exaggerated a few of the points, making out that Strathclyde is heads and shoulders above everywhere else. Yet, I still think that as a choice between Glasgow and Strathclyde for Business, Strathclyde has got the upper hand.
What I said about the Triple accreditation I still think is very important, only 1% of Business Schools in the world have it, and Strathclyde is the only one in Scotland to do so,holding accreditation from 3 really respectable accreditation bodies. The metaphor that I used may have been a bit out of hand though, I do admit that....
With the greatest of respect, this whole 'accreditation' thing is a non-issue. These things are more for marketing the University than they are about providing a good education. It should also be pointed out this is particularly the case when it comes to undergraduate study (in a business sense) - it matters much more at postgraduate level. Unless you need a course accredited by the one body Strathclyde has that Glasgow doesn't (unsure what this is by the way - maybe you could fill me in?), it's irrelevant - and no, you won't need your course to be accredited by that anyway!
(Here is a list of the Adam Smith Business School's accreditations by the for prospective students. Plenty there: http://www.gla.ac.uk/schools/business/aboutus/accreditations/) Regarding the Strathclyde has 10 options and Glasgow has 2, I think I need to elaborate more. You are correct in staying that you do study various business areas like Marketing, HR and so on (subjects that Strathy offers) in their Business and Management programme, but you fail to point out the depth that you get you study them at. For Marketing in the first year module you only do half a semester of at Glasgow, covering only the bare basics of marketing. For someone who would want to follow a marketing career in Marketing I think they would be more satisfied with Strathclyde who offers loads of classes including B2B Marketing,Social Marketing, International Marketing, Brand Management,Sports Marketing, Digital Marketing, Consumer Marketing, etc. as standalone full semester classes, so you would be able to studying specific areas in more depth and more comprehensively the subject areas that concern you. And this is the same for other functions like HR, Finance and Enterprise.... You get almost 9-12 classes in a subject area to chose from whereas in Glasgow , I would be surprised if you could get more than 5 to choose from. All in all, I think the bottom line is that Strathclyde offers you more Choice.
This is wrong - you don't study half a semester of anything. The depth you study at wasn't mentioned because as I said, you can pick up modules in these courses in years one and two, then 'specialize' in years three and four - you will not miss out on any main business function at all. As for your different marketing classes, you'd touch on them then specialize moving on to honours. It makes no sense to focus solely on them in years one and two, the whole point in the modular system is that you pick and choose 'tasters' if you like, then move on to your degree/honours when you do go in to much more depth.
To imply Strathclyde offers relevant/core business modules Glasgow doesn't in years one and two (out with daft things like your Travel and Tourism) is silly. About the study abroad programme, I am not sure about Glasgow but at Strath they let you Study abroad and get credits equivalent to Strathclyde credits so you won't be doing an extra year. So say i wanted to go abroad and study, at Strath the degree would still take 4 years. For Glasgow i think it may be an extra year added on, so 5 years. (Not 100% sure on this)
At Glasgow the credits are transferred too and you complete your degree in the four years - not five.Regarding Group work, not sure about Group work at Glasgow as I have not studied there. However, for Business students at strathclyde, we do a compulsory module called Management Development Programme, for years 1-3. This focuses heavily on goup work and in a business context. Also, from what I have heard employers really support this idea, again not 100% sure, so don't quote me on this.
Glasgow places a big emphasis on team work for the modules that require it. This again is a null point really. Overall, I do have to stress that I agree on you on the point that Glasgow has a better reputation overall, after all they are a Russel Group Uni.However, for certain subjects Strathclyde excel more at than Glasgow by quite a margin, and that's because Strathclyde invests heavily in these subject areas. (One of which is Business) Admittedly, To the extent that other departments at the uni do suffer from.
'By quite a margin'? Again I'd have to say this is nonsense. There's very little between the business schools in terms of league tables (which again can be poor, in that some measure really stupid things that don't indicate how good the education is). In the end its the op's choice which university they chose and i'm just trying my hardest to give them a good overview on what Strathclyde offers as a package. Something which is unique to any other Business degree in Scotland, in my honest opinion. (except from St Andrews, but that's also debatable)
I do appreciate your coming on here and defending your statements and what not but you simply cannot say Strathclyde are the only Uni (out with St. Andrews) to offer the 'package' in terms of a business degree in Scotland - it makes you sound silly?
I think you're misinformed which is leading to silly assumptions like this. You think we study marketing for half a semester and in no depth for example. When in actual fact, In that semester you'd study only marketing (B2B, strategy, PPPP, digital marketin etc. etc. the list goes on) alongside two other subjects (mines was economics & politics).
In years one and two you'll cover managing people, marketing, operations and financial decision making, and Organization & Management (in enough depth to either fall in love with the course or not) then in years three and four it's a free run - do what you like. The course structure is here: http://www.gla.ac.uk/undergraduate/degrees/businessmanagement/courses/ you should have a look at it.