When he was a Swansea he was a brilliant manager. Then moved to Liverpool I heard him described as a 'snake oil salesman'. Then last season he was tactical genius. Now he's back to being average. I'd say he's 2nd tier, not a SAF, Mou or a Pep, but he's as good as Wenger or Pellegrini.
Thought you guys would be inoculated from frustration with team selection after Rafa and his rotation.