General essay plan for part B:
Intro
• Focus on Q
• Link interpretations to the sources directly
• Establish LOA
P1 – weak
• TS – focus on Q and introduce argument
• Link to source and quote
• Support with own knowledge
• Support with x-ref
• …however…
• Critique with own knowledge
• Critique with x-ref
• Mini-judgement with evaluation of the argument/sources
P2 – weak
• TS – focus on Q and introduce argument
• Link to source and quote
• Support with own knowledge
• Support with x-ref
• …however…
• Critique with own knowledge
• Critique with x-ref
• Mini-judgement with evaluation of the argument/sources
P3 – strong
• TS – focus on Q and introduce argument
• Link to source and quote
• Support with own knowledge
• Support with x-ref
• …however…
• Critique with x-ref
• Dismiss x-ref with own knowledge
• Critique with x-ref
• Dismiss x-ref with own knowledge
• Mini-judgement with evaluation of the argument/sources – following your LOA
Conclusion
• Focus on Q
• Set out overall argument in reference to the sources
• Go over the other two sources briefly & why their arguments are not as strong
• Finish with clear statement on why preferred source is the strongest argument and link back to the question