The Student Room Group

Use of > & <

OCR Jan 2008 Q 9 last part has the answer that k lies outside of the range between root 3 -2 and root 3 + 2.
It is tempting to write 3+2<k<32\sqrt 3+2< k < \sqrt 3-2 rather than separately saying
k>3+2k>\sqrt 3+2 or k<32 k < \sqrt 3-2.

In the mark scheme, the former case loses at least one mark. Whilst I agree it is a bit unclear, why is it wrong?

Is it because the notation implies that k can be in both domains at the same time or is it something else?
Original post by nerak99
OCR Jan 2008 Q 9 last part has the answer that k lies outside of the range between root 3 -2 and root 3 + 2.
It is tempting to write 3+2<k<32\sqrt 3+2< k < \sqrt 3-2 rather than separately saying
k>3+2k>\sqrt 3+2 or k<32 k < \sqrt 3-2.

In the mark scheme, the former case loses at least one mark. Whilst I agree it is a bit unclear, why is it wrong?

Is it because the notation implies that k can be in both domains at the same time or is it something else?

The first doesn't make any sense. With your explanation I know what you're trying to do but this use of the notation is just wrong. Use the second method.
The first implies that 32>3+2\sqrt 3 - 2 > \sqrt 3 + 2.
(edited 8 years ago)
Reply 2
Thanks. I just did not look at the wider picture.

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending