The Student Room Group

differentiation confused?

Scroll to see replies

Original post by kiiten
Then i subbed in 3 and 1 separately then took them away to get 25? :dontknow:

So 14 x 3 - 1/3 × 3^2 + 9 × 3^-1 for the first term (3)


for 3 it should be 14(3)333+9×31 \displaystyle 14(3) - \frac{3^3}{3} + 9 \times 3^{-1}
Reply 41
Original post by DylanJ42
for 3 it should be 14(3)333+9×31 \displaystyle 14(3) - \frac{3^3}{3} + 9 \times 3^{-1}


Thanks, careless mistake :sigh:

Posted from TSR Mobile
Original post by kiiten
Thanks, careless mistake :sigh:

Posted from TSR Mobile


dw we all make them :tongue:
Reply 43
Original post by DylanJ42
dw we all make them :tongue:


Wait, that was a typo. I still get 36 then 11 when i sub in 1? (Answer: 25) :s

Posted from TSR Mobile
Original post by kiiten
Wait, that was a typo. I still get 36 then 11 when i sub in 1? (Answer: 25) :s

Posted from TSR Mobile


What seems to be the problem? Sorry I wasn't part of the conversation so I don't know what's going on!

Also: it would be good if you could post your working out, that way we may be able to pinpoint where you're making mistakes!
Furthermore, I sometimes find it helpful that when a question is getting out of hand and messy, start it again on a new piece of paper

This is where I think we've gotten up to so far:

So you need to find 1314x29x2 dx\displaystyle \int^{3}_{1} 14-x^{2}-9x^{-2} \ \mathrm{d}x

Your integration is correct, we now have 1314x29x2 dx=[14x13x3+9x1]13\displaystyle \int_1^3 14-x^{2}-9x^{-2} \ \mathrm{d}x = \left[ 14x - \dfrac{1}{3}x^{3} + 9x^{-1} \right]_1^3

First you substitute in the limits (3 and 1), then you subtract what you get for the lower limit from what you get with the upper limit, so you have

= [14(3)333+93 ][1413+9]=\ \left[14(3)-\dfrac{3^{3}}{3}+\dfrac{9}{3}\ \right] - \left[14-\dfrac{1}{3}+9\right]

Which is the area enclosed between x=1x= 1 and x=3x= 3 :

When x=3    [14x13x3+9x1]=36x=3\ \ \rightarrow\ \ \left[ 14x - \dfrac{1}{3}x^{3} + 9x^{-1} \right] = 36

This is correct, however:

When x=1    [14x13x3+9x1]11x=1\ \ \rightarrow\ \ \left[ 14x - \dfrac{1}{3}x^{3} + 9x^{-1} \right] \not= 11

As [14+913]=683\left[ 14 + 9 - \dfrac{1}{3} \right] = \dfrac{68}{3}
(edited 8 years ago)
Reply 45
Original post by edothero
What seems to be the problem? Sorry I wasn't part of the conversation so I don't know what's going on!

Also: it would be good if you could post your working out, that way we may be able to pinpoint where you're making mistakes!
Furthermore, I sometimes find it helpful that when a question is getting out of hand and messy, start it again on a new piece of paper

This is where I think we've gotten up to so far:

So you need to find 1314x29x2 dx\displaystyle \int^{3}_{1} 14-x^{2}-9x^{-2} \ \mathrm{d}x

Your integration is correct, we now have 1314x29x2 dx=[14x13x3+9x1]13\displaystyle \int_1^3 14-x^{2}-9x^{-2} \ \mathrm{d}x = \left[ 14x - \dfrac{1}{3}x^{3} + 9x^{-1} \right]_1^3

First you substitute in the limits (3 and 1), then you subtract what you get for the lower limit from what you get with the upper limit, so you have

= [14(3)333+93 ][1413+9]=\ \left[14(3)-\dfrac{3^{3}}{3}+\dfrac{9}{3}\ \right] - \left[14-\dfrac{1}{3}+9\right]

Which is the area enclosed between x=1x= 1 and x=3x= 3 :

When x=3    [14x13x3+9x1]=36x=3\ \ \rightarrow\ \ \left[ 14x - \dfrac{1}{3}x^{3} + 9x^{-1} \right] = 36

This is correct, however:

When x=1    [14x13x3+9x1]11x=1\ \ \rightarrow\ \ \left[ 14x - \dfrac{1}{3}x^{3} + 9x^{-1} \right] \not= 11

As [14+913]=683\left[ 14 + 9 - \dfrac{1}{3} \right] = \dfrac{68}{3}


Yeah, i must have typed it wrong into my calculator. So i got 40/3 and the area has to = 5 1/3 so you have to minus (4x2). But where does the 2 come from?
Original post by kiiten
Yeah, i must have typed it wrong into my calculator. So i got 40/3 and the area has to = 5 1/3 so you have to minus (4x2). But where does the 2 come from?


Sorry I'm really busy right now. Look at the graph. Area under the curve from x= 1 to 3 is a rectangle + curve.
@Zacken can help you here. Sorry again.
Reply 47
Original post by kiiten
Yeah, i must have typed it wrong into my calculator. So i got 40/3 and the area has to = 5 1/3 so you have to minus (4x2). But where does the 2 come from?


As edothehero said, the area you've found using integration is the area under the curve. But you want the shaded area so you want to subtract the area of that rectangle.
Reply 48
Original post by Zacken
As edothehero said, the area you've found using integration is the area under the curve. But you want the shaded area so you want to subtract the area of that rectangle.


As i said before you have to minus 8 (4x2) from 40/3 to get 5 1/3. But, where does the 2 come from?

Posted from TSR Mobile
Reply 49
Original post by kiiten
As i said before you have to minus 8 (4x2) from 40/3 to get 5 1/3. But, where does the 2 come from?

Posted from TSR Mobile


What's the area of the rectangle? Width * height, no...?
Reply 50
Original post by Zacken
What's the area of the rectangle? Width * height, no...?


Height is 4 and i dont know about the width - maybe 3? The question says that the shaded area has to equal 5 1/3 so i did 40/3 - 5 1/3 to get 8. Thats why i thought the width might be 2?
Reply 51
Original post by kiiten
Height is 4 and i dont know about the width - maybe 3? The question says that the shaded area has to equal 5 1/3 so i did 40/3 - 5 1/3 to get 8. Thats why i thought the width might be 2?


You're integrating from 1 to 3, the rectangle has width 3-1 = 2.
Reply 52
Original post by Zacken
You're integrating from 1 to 3, the rectangle has width 3-1 = 2.


Oh, i must have got confused from the diagram because the curve goes inwards at the top so i thought it would be less. But, i see what you mean. Thanks :smile:
Reply 53
Original post by kiiten
Oh, i must have got confused from the diagram because the curve goes inwards at the top so i thought it would be less. But, i see what you mean. Thanks :smile:


The curve is, the rectangle isn't.

Quick Reply

Latest