The Student Room Group

Cambridge students cancel theme party over 'cultural appropriation' fears

Scroll to see replies

Original post by Good bloke
:toofunny:

Just how marginalised do you think Queen-bee is? She is the daughter of rich cosmopolitans, in medical school, able to jet around the Mediterranean and the western world generally while living and being educated in the UK, without a financial care in the world?

Yet by the Newspeak rules of behaviour she, as a minority member, can appropriate others' cultures to her heart's delight while spuriously claiming to be simultaneously ancient Egyptian-Macedonian-Greek (becasue theri incestuous culture is identical to hers, she has told us), Italian, Levantine, Arab (purely on the grounds of speaking the language), Christian, Moslem (as she knows a lot of Moslems and is vocal about Islamophobia), British and very knowledgeable, if not an expert, about Californian culture (because of her weekend trip to New York).

Someone is pulling someone else's plonker. And I think it is both of you.


How has this got anything to do with Queen-bee? That comment was me trying to explain cultural appropriation. I never said she was in a marginalised group.

And talking of backgrounds, I'm a working-class Irish Catholic socialist. Marginalised? I think so.
Original post by DMcGovern
How has this got anything to do with Queen-bee? That comment was me trying to explain cultural appropriation. I never said she was in a marginalised group.

And talking of backgrounds, I'm a working-class Irish Catholic socialist. Marginalised? I think so.


You need to have a word with the Irish government. It should do better for its majorities.

Queen-bee, a firm supporter of this silly concept, claims she is on the OK side in this debate, and can do what she likes with impunity.
Original post by Good bloke
You need to have a word with the Irish government. It should do better for its majorities.

Queen-bee, a firm supporter of this silly concept, claims she is on the OK side in this debate, and can do what she likes with impunity.


I don't live in the Republic. I'm of a minority in the UK.

Meh. Nothing to do with me.
Original post by DMcGovern
I don't live in the Republic. I'm of a minority in the UK.

Meh. Nothing to do with me.


So, do you live in the mainland, where noone cares a stuff if you are Irish and will readily join in and congratulate you on St Patrick's day, and even less about you being an RC, or do you live in NI, where your political laws are protected by law (the only place in the UK where this is so)?
Original post by Good bloke
So, do you live in the mainland, where noone cares a stuff if you are Irish and will readily join in and congratulate you on St Patrick's day, and even less about you being an RC, or do you live in NI, where your political laws are protected by law (the only place in the UK where this is so)?


As much as I enjoy your casual racism towards little bogmen like me, you've proved my point about people like me being marginalised.
Original post by DMcGovern
As much as I enjoy your casual racism towards little bogmen like me, you've proved my point about people like me being marginalised.


How?
Original post by Good bloke
hehe. Of course, I would ask my non-white daughter-in-law for her permission to attend a fancy dress party in ethnic dress. I would then not be guilty of cultural appropriation. If she doesn't have the authority to allow me to do so, who does?


I don't think SJWs would risk undermining her marginalisation and systematic oppression™ by challenging her authority as the official appropriation permission giver, so you should be safe. Otherwise they would be acting like racist bigots, and I'm sure no SJWs would want to judge people racially and hold different races to different standards...

Original post by Good bloke
In fact, I have already asked her to allow me to eat foreign food, wear foreign clothes, read foreign books, sing foreign songs and to undertake many other cultural activities. She has subjected me to rigorous examination and granted me enduring permission to carry out all of them for the remainder of my life.



I can, therefore, never be accused of cultural appropriation without it resulting in a suit for slander or libel.


I guess that's what freedom feels like? Although integration, assimilation and not judging people by race could be thought to be MRA, patriarchal, white-supremacist, neo-nazi code for oppression if it doesn't comply with SJW dogma.



Posted from TSR Mobile
Original post by DMcGovern
I don't live in the Republic. I'm of a minority in the UK.


Cry me a river.
Original post by DiddyDec
Cry me a river.
Taking a comment out of context to make it an easy target?I think so.

Original post by Good bloke
Were they? Do you marry your siblings then?


I don't think modern day greek and Macedonians do such a thing and I am an only child
Original post by Good bloke
OK. Now tell me why it is OK for you to do that, but not OK for the British to appropriate your culture (which is your argument)?


Because I'm a minority living within British culture and I must be able to speak English for me to get by,get a good job or education. There is no need for you to be appropriating Levantine/Italian culture now is there?
(edited 8 years ago)
Original post by queen-bee
Because I'm a minority living writhing British culture and I must be able to speak English for me to get by,get a good job or education. There is no need for you to be appropriating Levantine/Italian culture now is there?


How else am I going to eat pizza and bet on the Palio?
Original post by Good bloke
:toofunny:

Just how marginalised do you think Queen-bee is? She is the daughter of rich cosmopolitans, in medical school, able to jet around the Mediterranean and the western world generally while living and being educated in the UK, without a financial care in the world?

Yet by the Newspeak rules of behaviour she, as a minority member, can appropriate others' cultures to her heart's delight while spuriously claiming to be simultaneously ancient Egyptian-Macedonian-Greek (becasue theri incestuous culture is identical to hers, she has told us), Italian, Levantine, Arab (purely on the grounds of speaking the language), Christian, Moslem (as she knows a lot of Moslems and is vocal about Islamophobia), British and very knowledgeable, if not an expert, about Californian culture (because of her weekend trip to New York).

Someone is pulling someone else's plonker. And I think it is both of you.


My parents have always provided for me,I haven't complained about that

Modern day medittaranean cultures do not practice incest,so I don't know what you're talking about my dear. I speak out about islamophibia,but where have I mentioned that I'm a Muslim or do I need to educate you and tell you not all those from the Middle East are Muslims? I'm a Coptic Christian. You're right,I am British and very knowledge and I am no expert in Californian culture seeing as I've only been once with my mother but I'm an expert on New York,I've been to visit her several times during my long summer break during my time at KCL. I also used to visit my father alot in Zurich,so I guess that also makes me an expert on all things Swiss?
Original post by DiddyDec
How else am I going to eat pizza and bet on the Palio?


You don't have to do such a thing,you choose to want to do it
Original post by DMcGovern
How has this got anything to do with Queen-bee? That comment was me trying to explain cultural appropriation. I never said she was in a marginalised group.

And talking of backgrounds, I'm a working-class Irish Catholic socialist. Marginalised? I think so.


Seriously? :erm:
Original post by queen-bee
You don't have to do such a thing,you choose to want to do it


Does it harm anyone? No. Therefore it doesn't fit your definition of bad appropriation.

I am actually a minority in the UK.

Posted from TSR Mobile
Original post by DMcGovern
As much as I enjoy your casual racism towards little bogmen like me, you've proved my point about people like me being marginalised.


Nothing he said was racist. It's as if being a professional victim is part of your identity.
(edited 8 years ago)
Original post by DiddyDec
Does it harm anyone? No. Therefore it doesn't fit your definition of bad appropriation.

I am actually a minority in the UK.

Posted from TSR Mobile


No,it doesn't but you're exploiting Italians :tongue:

Yes,you've said before. Where are you from exactly?
Original post by queen-bee
No,it doesn't but you're exploiting Italians :tongue:

Yes,you've said before. Where are you from exactly?


How is it exploiting Italians? The pizza wasn't made there and they are going to hold the Palio regardless of me.

Ireland.

Posted from TSR Mobile
Original post by DiddyDec
How is it exploiting Italians? The pizza wasn't made there and they are going to hold the Palio regardless of me.

Ireland.

Posted from TSR Mobile


But it's an Italian dish? And also why do you feel the need to bet on horses in Italy when you have the same thing here within the UK? Ascot?

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending