The Student Room Group

Why are there no notable anti-Islam feminist movements?

???

Scroll to see replies

Reply 1
Modern feminism isn't completely about women anymore, they are now operating on a victim basis and they see Muslims as the biggest victims so much they have girls apologising for being raped and defend it from those who think it is unacceptable.
Original post by RobML
???


The same reason british people are up in arms when a british person gets killed in a terrorist attack abroad, but would not give two chits if it had been a native.

Like a lot of things, western feminism is only concerned with its own plight, and doesnt actually care too much about the plight of those in other cultures and countries, despite their plight being more severe. As an example of this, there are a number of articles online that discuss how western feminism is quite ethnocentric, and doesnt give much consideration to the plight that ethnic minority women in these countries face.

Thus any feminism movement against islam is actually most likely to come from muslim countries, but feminism in the middle east has always been strongly clamped down and repressed.

Posted from TSR Mobile
(edited 8 years ago)
I am sure we will be hearing a lot more from them over the next few years.
Original post by Death Grips
The same reason british people are up in arms when a british person gets killed in a terrorist attack abroad, but would not give two chits if it had been a native.

Like a lot of things, western feminism is only concerned with its own plight, and doesnt actually care too much about the plight of those in other cultures and countries, despite their plight being more severe. As an example of this, there are a number of articles online that discuss how western feminism is quite ethnocentric, and doesnt give much consideration to the plight that ethnic minority women in these countries face.

Thus any feminism movement against islam is actually most likely to come from muslim countries, but feminism in the middle east has always been strongly clamped down and repressed.

Posted from TSR Mobile


Basically this. But I've said before when it comes to these types of issues it does to some extent fall on the identity group to fight their own battle in the first instance. It is hard to represent a group when you have little understanding of the realities of living within that 'group'.

Western feminism tackles the issues that remain in western society. Some of it has become entitled and a bit too positive discriminatory for my liking but most feminists do seek equality in a system that favours men simply because men built the system.

The issues facing women in other parts of the world including the Middle East are a lot worse but it shouldn't be a reason to judge western feminists who have an entirely different situation. Any group fighting for equality should be applauded especially as they are actually doing something about it.

What we should be doing, instead of saying oh why aren't western feminists helping out all these poor women, is giving the women in these situations the tools and empowerment to start fighting their own battle themselves. (Acknowledged it is not that simple)
Dön't rëlee nö.
Reply 6
It doesn't fit their narrative of oppressing cis white men.
Reply 7
Because modern day feminism is backed and supported by regressive leftists that completely have no problem offending the majority, with deluded false fake narratives like the wage-gap myth but will go silent when trying to offend minorities in real oppressive societies like in muslim majority countries where Women are really persecuted for just being women.
(edited 8 years ago)
Original post by Josb
It doesn't fit their narrative of oppressing cis white men.


This.

Posted from TSR Mobile
Original post by Josb
It doesn't fit their narrative of oppressing cis white men.


Lols actually this to an extent.

If feminists tried to attack muslim men, then they would have a sh*tstorm on their hands about white privilege and white oppression of the world (which is an argument they would not win).

Better to stay on a court where they can reach the hoop, so to speak.

Posted from TSR Mobile
Reply 10
Well, anything that would ACTUALLY help women would be completely useless, I mean that non existent wage gap is far more important
Reply 11
Original post by IAmNero
Well, anything that would ACTUALLY help women would be completely useless, I mean that non existent wage gap is far more important




LMAO.
Reply 12
Glad to be of service :wink:
It's because a so called anti-discrimination group then can't go and attack another group that claims it is a victim of discrimination.

Basically feminism just picks easy targets that don't threaten to 'tar' it's public image. If feminist's actually targeted islam, or more specifically muslim men, it would start to highlight the western centric nature of the movement and many of its hypocrisies regarding it's current goals.

It would actually do the feminist movement good to target more realistic plights affecting women, but alas I doubt it will happen any time soon. Potentially it may happen after the feminist movement eventually looses legitimacy in the mainstream media.
Reply 15
Original post by leavingthecity
I am sure we will be hearing a lot more from them over the next few years.


This, wait for the rape numbers to sky rocket or the oppression of women to become reality, or when women are restricted from certain areas or certain bars.

Then they'll make a big noise.

Feminism right now is all about power, it's about how to make the right middle class women richer by running social "justice" organisations.
Original post by TheNote
This, wait for the rape numbers to sky rocket or the oppression of women to become reality, or when women are restricted from certain areas or certain bars.

Then they'll make a big noise.

Feminism right now is all about power, it's about how to make the right middle class women richer by running social "justice" organisations.


Well there was that news the other day about Swedish women being told to stay indoors. Maybe this is an opportunity for western feminism that has gone astray to have relevance again and make a difference in a wider situation?
Reply 17
Original post by leavingthecity
Well there was that news the other day about Swedish women being told to stay indoors. Maybe this is an opportunity for western feminism that has gone astray to have relevance again and make a difference in a wider situation?


Maybe, as someone who hates modern feminism, i just wish feminism would go back to it's more liberal, less authoritarian stance and allow women to chose what they want to do while fighting against actual real oppression of women.
Reply 18
Original post by RobML
???


Because the type of people who are feminists are also deeply committed to political correctness.
Most individual feminists are anti-Islam, or at least against the bits of Islam that are bad for women. Indeed I have a friend who identifies triply an apostate, feminist and scientist: she is anti-Islam in the Quilliam mould, individualist, radical liberal, hyper-rationalist.

The reason feminist organisations don't speak out against Islam is because they are used to playing the dance of identity politics in order to get funding. They are slow to abandon "Muslims" as their allies in that. Especially seeing as Muslim organisations are all at least outwardly against radical Islam and Islamism.

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending