The Student Room Group

Do you think uni is value for money?

Scroll to see replies

Oxbridge, Imperial, (some subjects at) UCL/LSE, Warwick and a few others: yes it is value for money.


Media Studies from Southampton Solent, or Gender studies from the unversity of CuckoLand... No.
Hell no I don't! Which is why I went into an apprenticeship.

Ended up earning instead of paying anything and I'm doing the same job on the same as people who are in much more debt than I am.
It depends on what University you go to, and what you study. Everything is relative.
Original post by Loyota
No one is forcing you to go. If you say no, DON'T GO - simple solution people.


Perhaps they dont realise till they have experienced it?
Perhaps it isnt the same experience for everyone?
Tuition fees are too much plus accomadating living and sometimes your not even guaranteed a job...
No one should even be paying for their education. Isn't education an automatic entitlement as a civil right? So why are we paying.
Original post by 0to100
No one should even be paying for their education. Isn't education an automatic entitlement as a civil right? So why are we paying.


Higher education isn't a civil right, because it's not necessary to survive or succeed in any industry. You could potentially gain employment in any industry at all, without going to uni, if you work hard enough.

School education is a civil right because it provides you with skills that you actually need to survive in the modern world, and to find employment.
Original post by Jazzyboy
Higher education isn't a civil right, because it's not necessary to survive or succeed in any industry. You could potentially gain employment in any industry at all, without going to uni, if you work hard enough.

School education is a civil right because it provides you with skills that you actually need to survive in the modern world, and to find employment.


I rest my case. And it is necessary to get and keep a proper job, which is necessary to survive, my good fellow.
Original post by 0to100
I rest my case. And it is necessary to get and keep a proper job, which is necessary to survive, my good fellow.


Plenty of people work their way up the ladder from jobs in cleaning or retail, and eventually get and keep 'proper jobs'. Also, apprenticeships exist. So no, uni is not necessary to get and keep a 'proper job'.

I rest my case :P
I think my degree is 'worth it'

All of my modules from second - third year are training in the skillsets required for employment. Depending on what modules you choose, it's a well thought out degree program and my lecturers are (mostly) brilliant.
Original post by Elivercury
This is of course correct, however realistically how many people earn 65k a year at any stage of their salary? 1/20 people? 1/50?

Also, a lot of the more profitable courses such as engineering, law, medicine all take longer than three years so the amount they need to earn is even higher. I would honestly be surprised if more than 1-2% of students are able to pay back their loans assuming they take the maximum available to them.

I mean, sure they get written off, but it's clearly a ludicrous system. There is also no guarantee they won't suddenly decide that they DON'T get written off at 50 and people take them to retirement. Unlikely, but it wouldn't be the first significant change against what they promised.


As I say again, £65k is very much an example of the fact that incomes will not remain static for an individual over thier working life. Granted, very few people will be lucky enough to recieve that much income, but just because they enter into an entry-level job at a certain salary doesn't mean that they will be at the salary forever. Often many would aspire to earn more as they grow with experience so they can afford luxuries that would be out of reach for a graduate salary, such as mortgages, for example.

In general, Those who study subjects like Medicine and engineering will acquire higher statring salaries than thier peers. This could be for many reasons, such as time commitments and demand for a certain Specialism/skill. That's not to stop anyone studying any other subject from landing themselves a good job out of university, its just that subjects like those which you have mentioned above will attract higher starting salaries.

You are very much correct in saying that there is much uncertainity in the future about whether student debt would be cleared after 30 years, but the government has to provide some incentive to get as many people as possible to continue on to higher eduction in order to increase the general skill level of our country's labour force. Be it that they continue to implement policies to eradicate student debt after 30 years, or even simply making it so that student debt does not factor in to our credit rating and hence not affect our chances of getting a mortgage.
Original post by iEthan
+ 4 year degree :emo:)


What course is 4 year?
Original post by govandpolitics
What course is 4 year?


Languages/MfL :smile:
Original post by Elivercury
This is of course correct, however realistically how many people earn 65k a year at any stage of their salary? 1/20 people? 1/50?

Also, a lot of the more profitable courses such as engineering, law, medicine all take longer than three years so the amount they need to earn is even higher. I would honestly be surprised if more than 1-2% of students are able to pay back their loans assuming they take the maximum available to them.

I mean, sure they get written off, but it's clearly a ludicrous system. There is also no guarantee they won't suddenly decide that they DON'T get written off at 50 and people take them to retirement. Unlikely, but it wouldn't be the first significant change against what they promised.


65k isn't even that much, i know a lot of people who didn't go to uni and earn that or more.
Original post by Jazzyboy
Plenty of people work their way up the ladder from jobs in cleaning or retail, and eventually get and keep 'proper jobs'. Also, apprenticeships exist. So no, uni is not necessary to get and keep a 'proper job'.

I rest my case :P


You again. Maybe you've never been job hunting (not that I care, and please don't quote me with your biography; also refrain from antagonising me with your :P as well) but the jobs I go for, require higher education. They require non-entry level skills, and job training is often a time consuming expensive thing. So having someone come in who already knows those things from their education is beneficial more so.

I'm not talking about going for bartending or burger flipping and then becoming manager and general manager. That must be what you're talking about. And lmao at you wanting the whole society and world to "work their up from cleaning."

People have ambitions and goals to be physicians, neurologists, scientists, engineers, entrepreneurs, administrators, educators, politicians, all these great things that unfortunately but understandably require higher education that is now very expensive, disproportionately so. And you quote me to say some foolishness about "working your way up from cleaning?" How do you work your way up to be an engineer? Not everyone wants to be sat on dole for years working in the garage, til they "work their way up" as one to finally become...? Yea exactly. Go "rest your case" elsehwere.
Original post by govandpolitics
What course is 4 year?


MEng, MMath etc.

Integrated Masters programs. Or courses with a year in industry/placement year OR even ones with just a year abroad :smile:
Original post by Killerpenguin15
As I say again, £65k is very much an example of the fact that incomes will not remain static for an individual over thier working life. Granted, very few people will be lucky enough to recieve that much income, but just because they enter into an entry-level job at a certain salary doesn't mean that they will be at the salary forever. Often many would aspire to earn more as they grow with experience so they can afford luxuries that would be out of reach for a graduate salary, such as mortgages, for example.

In general, Those who study subjects like Medicine and engineering will acquire higher statring salaries than thier peers. This could be for many reasons, such as time commitments and demand for a certain Specialism/skill. That's not to stop anyone studying any other subject from landing themselves a good job out of university, its just that subjects like those which you have mentioned above will attract higher starting salaries.

You are very much correct in saying that there is much uncertainity in the future about whether student debt would be cleared after 30 years, but the government has to provide some incentive to get as many people as possible to continue on to higher eduction in order to increase the general skill level of our country's labour force. Be it that they continue to implement policies to eradicate student debt after 30 years, or even simply making it so that student debt does not factor in to our credit rating and hence not affect our chances of getting a mortgage.


Sure, I get the point you're making that while starting on 40-50k is a pipe dream, just because you start on 20k doesn't mean you can't have a larger salary later in life. On the other hand though, the lower you start and longer you spend on it, the more you need to earn later (as with your 65k example).

I don't believe that engineers are excluded from the problem however. To take my own education, a 5 year engineering course. I would have approx £68k debt. This would require me to pay back approx 95k over 26 years, requiring me to have an average salary of ~£61k per year.

Even going by the higher end salaries for engineering (starting on 30k+ and ending up around £65-70k after ~10 years) I don't think I would be able to pay this off.

Of course many people won't pay it off and this is anticipated, but it just seems like a daft system to me and I wouldn't feel especially comfortable having that level of debt hanging over my head. I mean 95k is more than some homes cost in the UK (not London obviously!).

Personally given few to no degrees will actually pay for themselves, I struggle to say they are good value.

It is worth noting though (as others have) that there is more to gain from going to university than just a degree!
Depends on course tbh
Original post by iEthan
Value for money? No way! £9,000 a year for limited contact hours and treatment as if we're naughty children when we even email lecturers to ask a question (source: other people that aren't me, bit biased, shhhh). It's shameful. Considering just how much I'll be paying for Uni, I will make sure to squeeze every last drop of value out of my £48,000 student loan (plus maintenance loan + 4 year degree :emo:) nobody is going to deny me that or they'll face my wrath of me sending them passive-aggressive emails every few days. :h: <— featuring the passive-aggressive smiley faces in odd places too…

I do appreciate however that lecturers will be very pressed for time and will have to manage many students, however… that is at the fault of the University and their management unfortunately. That's how I see it.

Woah, that was pretty ferocious. :lol: *exhale*

Spoiler



you sound like you do not actually want to go to uni tbh
Original post by 0to100
You again. Maybe you've never been job hunting (not that I care, and please don't quote me with your biography; also refrain from antagonising me with your :P as well) but the jobs I go for, require higher education. They require non-entry level skills, and job training is often a time consuming expensive thing. So having someone come in who already knows those things from their education is beneficial more so.

I'm not talking about going for bartending or burger flipping and then becoming manager and general manager. That must be what you're talking about. And lmao at you wanting the whole society and world to "work their up from cleaning."

People have ambitions and goals to be physicians, neurologists, scientists, engineers, entrepreneurs, administrators, educators, politicians, all these great things that unfortunately but understandably require higher education that is now very expensive, disproportionately so. And you quote me to say some foolishness about "working your way up from cleaning?" How do you work your way up to be an engineer? Not everyone wants to be sat on dole for years working in the garage, til they "work their way up" as one to finally become...? Yea exactly. Go "rest your case" elsehwere.


what course did you study at uni?

You can work your way up to be an engineer through apprenticeships. Takes a hell of a lot longer though
(edited 7 years ago)

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending