Opening this discussion back up because this question seems to be the big one! It seems that Loreto is perceived to be the 'better' college but I feel this is because a) it tells you this at the open day and b) because it gets better results by only allowing good achieving students to continue into upper sixth. Of course, all colleges chuck out under performing students but it seems Loreto do this more than most (I feel, cynically, to maintain their great results so they can boast about these at the open day. They really lay it on thick). On the plus side, they will really push you so that this doesn't happen. If you are the type of person who needs more of a 'school like' feel then I guess Loreto is better. Xaverian is perceived to be the more relaxed and friendly college, and it certainly comes across as this. There were no swipes at neighbouring colleges during its open days and information days. The college ethos seems to be one of developing the whole person and fostering independence and although they also have high expectations of hard work, they expect students to do a lot of this independently alongside a very good pastoral support system. There is also a good supportive pastoral system at Loreto. Both colleges are 'Outstanding'. Both colleges get good results and both colleges are in the same area. It really comes down to personal preference and how you feel the college will suit you and your way of working. They are both excellent academic institutions. I have spoken to students at both. I have had mixed reviews of Loreto. Some love it, some are unhappy. Everyone loved Xaverian. The choice is yours..