Competition - post a photo you've taken of nature >>

I think it's time for fundamentalist Muslims, and Islamophobes too, to hear this!

Scroll to see replies

Wow awesome do you play the piano by chance?

Yeah I wished everyone did aswell, I was get a strange look from people everytime I say I listen to classical music. Then I'm automatically branded boring or a snob :angry:

Posted from OtherWorld

I don't play any instruments. I started the guitar then realised how limited it is. I will be starting playing bass soon. Hopefully by the time I go to university I will be able to switch to Contrabass. Who's your favourite composer?

Reply 21

oShahpo

Original post by JohnGreek

thank you OP for solving the question of Islam and terrorism in one fell swoop

To be frank Classical music is the solution to any problem.

Reply 22

username1539513

Original post by oShahpo

Yea I do

Original post by AlifunArnab

تمام , و هل تعلم ان الموسيقى حرام ؟

When you trying to follow an argument but you can only understand one side of it.

[video="youtube;VSZSn5uzK4I"]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VSZSn5uzK4I[/video]

Reply 23

oShahpo

Lol :P the guy is basically telling me that music is haram..

Reply 24

username1539513

Original post by oShahpo

Lol :P the guy is basically telling me that music is haram..

All classical music? Why?

Reply 25

Mr T 999

Original post by oShahpo

I love Beathoven,Mozart, Chopin, tchaikovsky, Vivaldi, Schubert, Bach etc....the list goes on

What about you, who's your favourite?

Posted from OtherWorld

Reply 26

oShahpo

Well I don't think it is, but you know how some people just detest everything western.

Reply 27

oShahpo

Original post by mr T 999

I love Beathoven,Mozart, Chopin, tchaikovsky, Vivaldi, Schubert, Bach etc....the list goes on

What about you, who's your favourite?

Posted from OtherWorld

Possibly Mahler or Brahms, I love everything classical though so I don't have a clear favourite.

Reply 28

HAnwar

Original post by oShahpo

In their defence very few actually do believe that, music is very popular in Muslim countries generally speaking.

Even if it is, it doesn't make it permissible to listen to.

Posted from TSR Mobile

Reply 29

oShahpo

Original post by HAnwar

Even if it is, it doesn't make it permissible to listen to.

Posted from TSR Mobile

What do you mean? Do you think it's haram? If so why do you think this beautiful, truly moving piece of music is forbidden?

Reply 30

champ_mc99

Original post by oShahpo

What do you mean? Do you think it's haram? If so why do you think this beautiful, truly moving piece of music is forbidden?

There are actually loads of nasheed artists out there that use the piano. They must have gotten a fatwa (legal opinion) from somewhere.

Reply 31

HAnwar

Original post by oShahpo

What do you mean? Do you think it's haram? If so why do you think this beautiful, truly moving piece of music is forbidden?

Yes I do.
I haven't listened to it and I'm not going to.

Posted from TSR Mobile

Reply 32

oShahpo

Original post by HAnwar

Yes I do.
I haven't listened to it and I'm not going to.

Posted from TSR Mobile

What about vocal music? Do you not listen to those too?

Reply 33

HAnwar

Original post by oShahpo

What about vocal music? Do you not listen to those too?

Idk about that. I'm not a music person so no.

Posted from TSR Mobile

Reply 34

Legendary Quest

Original post by HAnwar

Idk about that. I'm not a music person so no.

Posted from TSR Mobile

Do you consider the Adhan and the way people recite the Quran to be a form of music? It isn't different to nasheeds and nasheeds are music.

Reply 35

terry4009

Theres two ways of making music, Islam condemns one. The first is vocal; the second is instrumental which is not allowed in Islam

Reply 36

HAnwar

Original post by Legendary Quest

Do you consider the Adhan and the way people recite the Quran to be a form of music? It isn't different to nasheeds and nasheeds are music.

Bit of a silly question since no musical instruments are used when reciting either.

Posted from TSR Mobile

Reply 37

oShahpo

Original post by terry4009

Theres two ways of making music, Islam condemns one. The first is vocal; the second is instrumental which is not allowed in Islam

Let's not turn this into a debate please.
I am sorry you can't enjoy this.

Reply 38

Legendary Quest

Original post by HAnwar

Bit of a silly question since no musical instruments are used when reciting either.

Posted from TSR Mobile

You don't need instruments to make a piece of music... Do you not consider accapella to be a form of music?

Reply 39

HAnwar

Original post by Legendary Quest

You don't need instruments to make a piece of music... Do you not consider accapella to be a form of music?

There is a different ruling on singing and a different ruling on music.
Music using instruments isn't allowed.
Singing is not haram but it depends on the content etc.

Posted from TSR Mobile