I think it's time for fundamentalist Muslims, and Islamophobes too, to hear this!

Scroll to see replies

Reply 40

JabaDaba12

Lol at music being haram, clerics need to get a life

Reply 41

Legendary Quest

Original post by HAnwar

There is a different ruling on singing and a different ruling on music.
Music using instruments isn't allowed.
Singing is not haram but it depends on the content etc.

Posted from TSR Mobile

So do you agree that people sing when they read the Quran?

What are your thoughts on people singing nasheeds (using instruments) and using Allah's name? It seems pretty popular lately but I understand people have various opinions on this.

Reply 42

HAnwar

Original post by Legendary Quest

Not really. It's recited in accordance to the rules of Tajweed.

Against that.

Posted from TSR Mobile

Reply 43

terry4009

Original post by Legendary Quest

Muslims recite the Quran and sometimes apply a slight singing touch to it and that is acceptable but singing in the context of rockstars and most songs sang today and also rap is generally unheard of as that is not considered acceptable.

Singing nasheeds however is acceptable just as long as musical instruments are not applied.

Reply 44

RobML

Are Muslims allowed to listen to Merzbow?

[video="youtube;pGzrL8J0t-c"]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pGzrL8J0t-c[/video]

Reply 45

Legendary Quest

Original post by HAnwar

Not really. It's recited in accordance to the rules of Tajweed.

Against that.

Posted from TSR Mobile

In what way would you consider that to be different to singing? Are you not essentially being told how to sing the Quran?

Original post by terry4009

Muslims recite the Quran and sometimes apply a slight singing touch to it and that is acceptable but singing in the context of rockstars and most songs sang today and also rap is generally unheard of as that is not considered acceptable. Singing nasheeds however is acceptable just as long as musical instruments are not applied.

Fair enough. I understand that some believe that certain drums are permitted. Do you agree with that?

-

@oShahpo It looks like I've hijacked your thread, sorry. I'll stop after this one and enjoy the music. :colondollar:

Reply 46

terry4009

Original post by RobML

Are Muslims allowed to listen to Merzbow?

[video="youtube;pGzrL8J0t-c"]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pGzrL8J0t-c[/video]

lol is that even music

Reply 47

RobML

Original post by HAnwar

Bit of a silly question since no musical instruments are used when reciting either.

Posted from TSR Mobile

Oh, so can you listen to Bjork's Medulla album since it's made entirely of vocal samples?

[video="youtube;wxqMyyuAhyo"]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wxqMyyuAhyo[/video]

Original post by terry4009

lol is that even music

That's the joke :tongue:

(edited 7 years ago)

Reply 48

terry4009

Original post by Legendary Quest

In what way would you consider that to be different to singing? Are you not essentially being told how to sing the Quran?

Fair enough. I understand that some believe that certain drums are permitted. Do you agree with that?

-

@oShahpo It looks like I've hijacked your thread, sorry. I'll stop after this one and enjoy the music. :colondollar:

There are a difference of opinions but drum beating for entertainment is considered by most scholars as impermissible. Some scholars say that if you are beating it to warn of an impending nikah (wedding) then in those such cases beating drums are allowed

Reply 49

Legendary Quest

Original post by RobML

Are Muslims allowed to listen to Merzbow?

[video="youtube;pGzrL8J0t-c"]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pGzrL8J0t-c[/video]

I had to check to make sure my headphones were working properly. :colonhash:

Reply 50

HAnwar

Original post by Legendary Quest

No we're being told how to recite it.

Original post by RobML

Oh, so can you listen to Bjork's Medulla album since it's made entirely of vocal samples?

[video="youtube;wxqMyyuAhyo"]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wxqMyyuAhyo[/video]

That's the joke :tongue: