Girls rank in order of importance for dating a guy?

Three people that most stand out in my dating history:

Girl 1 - super-academic, emotionally fragile, geeky appearance, quite quiet
Girl 2 - 'underground' culture, smoked, not particularly academic, wanted to travel etc, very cold outer shell and not needy at all, physically cute
Girl 3 - emotionally demanding/controlling, career-focused, physically attractive, really chatty

The one thing they all have in common is that they're quite serious during conversation - which is not a personality trait I'd have said I'd look for - but in terms of intelligence, appearance and other personality variables they were totally different.

All these girls lying tbh...
Im a guy but I know how girls think

Money
Height/Looks
Personality
Inteligence

Why do you think they were all serious in conversation?
There's a reason.

Yeah, their personalities. I'm talking about people with whom I had an ongoing relationship, not just a bad date or two.

If your reason could add something interesting then feel free to share it.

When i look for a girl. I only look for a couple of things. Intelligence, Above average looks and Good personality.

The most probable answer i can think of is.
They took their relationship with you seriously.
This reflects in serious conversations.

From my experience, this is what i have observed. Putting myself into a women's shoes, i would be doing the same.
Women are always questioning their choice of mate, so in order to confirm whether her choice was the right choice, she has to have serious conversations. That's the only way to get serious answers.

When someone is intelligent, their life is more interesting, they are more interesting and also you'll be safer in their company.

How so? Being intelligent doesn't mean you lead an interesting life and you might be terrible at conversation. I don't see how you'd be safer in their company either?

Right but you're going to look for all 3 as opposed to one thing over the other two, no?

lol not like you know anything about that.

All you girls putting money last aren't being honest

All these girls lying tbh...
Im a guy but I know how girls think

Money
Height/Looks
Personality
Inteligence

Everyone has looks, intelligence, height, money and personaility.
Ive associated with each of these a threshold. That is the point which is acceptable for me. For each trait, i have associated a different weighting. This reflects the importance to me. The accumulation of these must be higher than another threshold. All these thresholds are just based upon my own judgement.

Looks, intelligence and personality have a higher weighting than money and height.
The value of 5 on the looks scale is higher than the value of 6 on the height scale.

Say im looking for:
Looks: 7
Intelligence: 9
Personality: 10

Person A has:
Looks: 6
Intelligence: 10
Personaility: 10

Then this is acceptable for me. The accumulating is still the same.
The scale is defined according to my own judgement.

Its complex but this is how my brain works.

Two of them did take the relationship seriously, one of them was totally casual. Nonetheless, I don't mean serious as in serious conversations about the relationship. I only mean they weren't big on small talk and they weren't 'silly' (with me or with other friends), they would talk about something meaningful most of the time. And they didn't play emotional games or show obvious childishness.