The Student Room Group

Calculating the limit of

f(x)=x+1x1x21f(x)= \dfrac{|x+1||x-1|}{x^2 -1}

Calculating the limit as x1,1+,1,1+x\Rightarrow -1^-, -1^+, 1^-, 1^+

So mod mean you can do x+1 and 1-x cus that's how mod works.

So you can get the answers 1 and -1 only out f(x) ensuring that the original f(x) is exactly the same as 1 or -1

however i'm not sure as how to determine the limits.
Original post by will'o'wisp2
f(x)=x+1x1x21f(x)= \dfrac{|x+1||x-1|}{x^2 -1}

Calculating the limit as x1,1+,1,1+x\Rightarrow -1^-, -1^+, 1^-, 1^+

So mod mean you can do x+1 and 1-x cus that's how mod works.

So you can get the answers 1 and -1 only out f(x) ensuring that the original f(x) is exactly the same as 1 or -1

however i'm not sure as how to determine the limits.


You can split the range into 3 sections; (,1)(1,1)(1,)(-\infty,-1) \cup (-1,1) \cup (1, \infty)

Then for (,1)(-\infty, -1) you have f(x)=(x+1)(x1)x21f(x)=\frac{(x+1)(x-1)}{x^2-1}

Then for (1,1)(-1,1) you have ... ?

etc...

Then you can determine the limits quite simply.
Original post by RDKGames
You can split the range into 3 sections; (,1)(1,1)(1,)(-\infty,-1) \cup (-1,1) \cup (1, \infty)

Then for (,1)(-\infty, -1) you have f(x)=(x+1)(x1)x21f(x)=\frac{(x+1)(x-1)}{x^2-1}

Then for (1,1)(-1,1) you have ... ?

etc...

Then you can determine the limits quite simply.


how do you get f(x)=(x+1)(x1)x21f(x)=\frac{(x+1)(x-1)}{x^2-1} for (,1)(-\infty, -1) i'm not even sure what you do to the modulus because i dont' know what to do for -1 and 1

so far there's 3 different things i can do for the modulused terms

for |x+1||x-1|

you can have the variations of
positive, positive
positive, negative(swapping the order doesn't matter since they multiplied together then you can take the factor of -1 out)
negative, negative

now all i gotta do is piece it together so it seems to me that simply leaving them as is as you have done for the example you gave me is the positive one

so for negative infinity to -1 you can simply rearrange f(x) as 1 which appears to be the positive positive pattern

so for the negative negative that seems to be the 1 to infinity which is then 1 (cus -1x-1 is jus 1)

so the last must be -1 and 1 which is the positive negative pattern so i should get -1 (-1x1=-1)

other than that i don't really know how to work these out "properly"
Original post by will'o'wisp2
how do you get f(x)=(x+1)(x1)x21f(x)=\frac{(x+1)(x-1)}{x^2-1} for (,1)(-\infty, -1) i'm not even sure what you do to the modulus because i dont' know what to do for -1 and 1


Your values for the domains at the end are correct.

For the one I worked out, it's quite simply the case of taking x+1|x+1| and x1|x-1| individually, and seeing what equation without the modulus they are equivalent to on the domain x(,1)x \in (-\infty, -1). Clearly, you (should) know that x+1=(x+1)|x+1|=-(x+1) and x1=(x+1)|x-1|=-(x+1), and so the product of the two must just be x+1x1=(x+1)(x1)|x+1||x-1|=(x+1)(x-1), and that's the numerator for that domain. Then just repeat similarly for the other two to deduce the answers you found.
(edited 6 years ago)
Original post by RDKGames
Your values for the domains at the end are correct.

For the one I worked out, it's quite simply the case of taking x+1|x+1| and x1|x-1| individually, and seeing what equation without the modulus they are equivalent to on the domain x(,1)x \in (-\infty, -1). Clearly, you (should) know that x+1=(x+1)|x+1|=-(x+1) and x1=(x+1)|x-1|=-(x+1), and so the product of the two must just be x+1x1=(x+1)(x1)|x+1||x-1|=(x+1)(x-1), and that's the numerator for that domain. Then just repeat similarly for the other two to deduce the answers you found.


so whatever sign the 2 defined ranges of where x can be that's what sign i stick in front?
Original post by will'o'wisp2
so whatever sign the 2 defined ranges of where x can be that's what sign i stick in front?


No... do you know how the graphs of x+1|x+1| and x1|x-1| look like? You must've sketched them at A-Level at least.
Original post by RDKGames
No... do you know how the graphs of x+1|x+1| and x1|x-1| look like? You must've sketched them at A-Level at least.


yup, they look like V and the x-1 is a V a bit more to the right
Original post by will'o'wisp2
yup, they look like V and the x-1 is a V a bit more to the right


Yeah but you do realise that xa|x-a| is the same thing as saying xax-a for xax\geq a, and (xa)-(x-a) for x<ax<a?

Same thing applied here.
Original post by RDKGames
Yeah but you do realise that xa|x-a| is the same thing as saying xax-a for xax\geq a, and (xa)-(x-a) for x<ax<a?

Same thing applied here.


Yup ok so how the -1,1 work?
Original post by will'o'wisp2
Yup ok so how the -1,1 work?


Well.. what's is the function x+1|x+1| equivalent to on this interval? What about x1|x-1|..?
Original post by RDKGames
Well.. what's is the function x+1|x+1| equivalent to on this interval? What about x1|x-1|..?


0 and 0 if i stick -1 and 1 in?
Original post by will'o'wisp2
0 and 0 if i stick -1 and 1 in?


OK... not quite... Got absolutely NO idea why you're sticking -1 and 1 in there... (unless I misunderstood what you've asked)

On (1,1)(-1,1) we have x+1=x+1|x+1|=x+1 and x1=(x1)|x-1|=-(x-1)

So f(x)=(x1)(x+1)x21=1f(x)=\frac{-(x-1)(x+1)}{x^2-1}=-1 on x(1,1)x \in (-1,1) as you found.

Honestly don't know how much more basic I can go on this.

Having that, you can clearly see what the limits of x(1)x \rightarrow (-1)_- and x(1)+x\rightarrow (-1)_+ are already.
(edited 6 years ago)
Original post by RDKGames
OK... not quite... Got absolutely NO idea why you're sticking -1 and 1 in there... (unless I misunderstood what you've asked)

On (1,1)(-1,1) we have x+1=x+1|x+1|=x+1 and x1=(x1)|x-1|=-(x-1)

So f(x)=(x1)(x+1)x21=1f(x)=\frac{-(x-1)(x+1)}{x^2-1}=-1 on x(1,1)x \in (-1,1) as you found.

Honestly don't know how much more basic I can go on this.


It's just this line which i don't get.
Do i need to like look at a graph of it or something?
the graph of |x+1| between -1 and 1 is oh i see?

so if i make whatevers inside || and make it 0 then i can see what the equation is?
Original post by will'o'wisp2
It's just this line which i don't get.
Do i need to like look at a graph of it or something?
the graph of |x+1| between -1 and 1 is oh i see?

so if i make whatevers inside || and make it 0 then i can see what the equation is?


A graph would help understand, yes.

Also going back to the definition of the modulus; you have x+1={x+1,x(1,)(x+1),x(,1]\displaystyle |x+1|= \begin{cases}x+1, & x \in (-1, \infty) \\ -(x+1), & x \in (-\infty,-1] \end{cases}

Since x(1,1)(1,)x \in (-1,1) \subset (-1,\infty), you have x+1=x+1|x+1|=x+1 in this interval.

Get it?
(edited 6 years ago)
Original post by RDKGames
A graph would help understand, yes.

Also going back to the definition of the modulus; you have x+1={x+1,x(1,)(x+1),x(,1]\displaystyle |x+1|= \begin{cases}x+1, & x \in (-1, \infty) \\ -(x+1), & x \in (-\infty,-1] \end{cases}

Since x(1,1)(1,)x \in (-1,1) \subset (-1,\infty), you have x+1=x+1|x+1|=x+1 in this interval.

Get it?


Ye thanks man
Original post by RDKGames
Your values for the domains at the end are correct.

For the one I worked out, it's quite simply the case of taking x+1|x+1| and x1|x-1| individually, and seeing what equation without the modulus they are equivalent to on the domain x(,1)x \in (-\infty, -1). Clearly, you (should) know that x+1=(x+1)|x+1|=-(x+1) and x1=(x+1)|x-1|=-(x+1), and so the product of the two must just be x+1x1=(x+1)(x1)|x+1||x-1|=(x+1)(x-1), and that's the numerator for that domain. Then just repeat similarly for the other two to deduce the answers you found.


hol on a sec how come the |x+1||x-1| in the interval -infinity and -1 are both the same thing? wouldn't it be -(x-1) and -(x+1) ??
Original post by will'o'wisp2
hol on a sec how come the |x+1||x-1| in the interval -infinity and -1 are both the same thing? wouldn't it be -(x-1) and -(x+1) ??


Sorry, my mistake, x1=(x1)|x-1|=-(x-1) in that interval, as you say. Their product still remains positive as stated.
Original post by RDKGames
Sorry, my mistake, x1=(x1)|x-1|=-(x-1) in that interval, as you say. Their product still remains positive as stated.


https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/322819040059850757/379037087078416395/unknown.png

so these notes from the teacher wrong too?


Yes, that highlighted part with x+1|x+1| is incorrect. I recommend dropping them an email about it so they can amend it as required. The rest looks fine.
Original post by RDKGames
Yes, that highlighted part with x+1|x+1| is incorrect. I recommend dropping them an email about it so they can amend it as required. The rest looks fine.


Ok thanks for helping as always :smile:

Quick Reply

Latest