The Manchester United Thread XXII

Learn the offside rule and use your eyes/common sense.

Thought he went under the radar a bit but Martial was a positive yesterday. First of all Jose started him, on the left, in a massive game. Not his most offensive performance but no doubt he had an eye on fulfilling the defensive duties Jose will have required. Did well to put Sanchez in for what should have been a better quality shot, and got his assist for Lukaku's goal. Although the goal was a bit scrappy I though for a player who at times has risked settling too much in that left wing role of the 4-2-3-1, just like Arsenal and Watford being the games springing to mind he can play well infield as more of a forward.

I really prefer the 4-3-3 and I think it benefits nearly all the players in our team. Although I still do think the 4-2-3-1 has its place especially when we're playing Mata.

Must say as likeable as they are after all these years, our fullback situation is dire. They have never been able to defend properly as converted wingers but even offensively, nothing compared to what Spurs or City are getting out of theirs.

So Pogba ill, Matic carrying, Herrera injured, Fellaini injured. We're looking at Carrick and McTominay.

We really are going to need to go on a midfielder buying spree in summer. We're losing two of them, one doesn't get games and the others are kids. Basically just Pogba and Matic come end of the season.

Thought he went under the radar a bit but Martial was a positive yesterday. First of all Jose started him, on the left, in a massive game. Not his most offensive performance but no doubt he had an eye on fulfilling the defensive duties Jose will have required. Did well to put Sanchez in for what should have been a better quality shot, and got his assist for Lukaku's goal. Although the goal was a bit scrappy I though for a player who at times has risked settling too much in that left wing role of the 4-2-3-1, just like Arsenal and Watford being the games springing to mind he can play well infield as more of a forward.

I really prefer the 4-3-3 and I think it benefits nearly all the players in our team. Although I still do think the 4-2-3-1 has its place especially when we're playing Mata.

Must say as likeable as they are after all these years, our fullback situation is dire. They have never been able to defend properly as converted wingers but even offensively, nothing compared to what Spurs or City are getting out of theirs.

have you heard that neymar is now leaving psg to go to real madrid

Common sense never applies when interpreting the offside rule - the whole "give the attacker the advantage" just doesn't exisy

He's not offside, thats what I meant for you to figure out

He's not offside, thats what I meant for you to figure out

His shoulder was offside.

These guys won the game and are still arguing about an offside decision they've fluked. Weird morons.

These guys won the game and are still arguing about an offside decision they've fluked. Weird morons.

Let's be honest he only put the ball in the net because everyone saw the flag. It would have ended up in the away end otherwise.

These guys won the game and are still arguing about an offside decision they've fluked. Weird morons.

You're on another teams thread about an interesting decision and yet you offer nothing to the debate except - "look at it".

Let's be honest he only put the ball in the net because everyone saw the flag. It would have ended up in the away end otherwise.

Man's telling us Morata only scored from a tight angle against 'the best goalkeeper who ever lived' because he knew it was offside and just wanted to show off a little.

**** me