The Student Room Group

Is medicine the best option for me?

While I'm certain I'll love the scientific aspect of the course, and after going to open days etc I'd like to think I'd very much enjoy the clinical stuff too, I worry I'm not the right type of person to become a doctor. I am quite shy and awkward which is obviously not good in a profession where you have to communicate all the time. Sometimes I think that maybe uni will bring me out of my shell but I'm not sure. Some people say they could imagine me in that sort of profession whereas others say that they couldn't and I'd imagine its because of my shyness. I'm not too bad, but I'm not very confident. It is a job that I would absolutely love to do but fear I am not the type of person unis are looking for.

I have been trying to increase my confidence but I'm not sure that it is working. I will apply for head girl and If I get chosen, hopefully I will become less shy. I know that communication skills and confidence are imperative for the role of a doctor so this is worrying me.

In terms of interviews, this presents a problem too as when nervous I am even more shy and struggle to formulate my thoughts. Do you think It's worth me trying for this - will I be able to overcome my awkwardness? Or am I frankly just not the type of person that is ideal for this profession. Any advice would be greatly appreciated :smile: Also any tips on how to become less shy would be very much appreciated too :biggrin:
(edited 5 years ago)

Scroll to see replies

Original post by xxNoodlezxx
While I'm certain I'll love the scientific aspect of the course, and after going to open days etc I'd like to think I'd very much enjoy the clinical stuff too, I worry I'm not the right type of person to become a doctor. I am quite shy and awkward which is obviously not good in a profession where you have to communicate all the time. Sometimes I think that maybe uni will bring me out of my shell but I'm not sure. Some people say they could imagine me in that sort of profession whereas others say that they couldn't and I'd imagine its because of my shyness. I'm not too bad, but I'm not very confident. It is a job that I would absolutely love to do but fear I am not the type of person unis are looking for.

I have been trying to increase my confidence but I'm not sure that it is working. I will apply for head girl and If I get chosen, hopefully I will become less shy. I know that communication skills and confidence are imperative for the role of a doctor so this is worrying me.

In terms of interviews, this presents a problem too as when nervous I am even more shy and struggle to formulate my thoughts. Do you think It's worth me trying for this - will I be able to overcome my awkwardness? Or am I frankly just not the type of person that is ideal for this profession. Any advice would be greatly appreciated :smile: Also any tips on how to become less shy would be very much appreciated too :biggrin:


Communication as a doctor is a specific skill set - that's why it's formally taught at medical school and why you have five years to learn it. Some people have more of a natural flair for it than others, but that's true of any skill.

Being a good communicator as a doctor doesn't mean the same thing as being extroverted or outgoing, and becoming confident at talking to patients, relatives, other staff members etc is something which takes time and experience.

In a similar way, how you communicate in interviews is something that can be worked on and improved - you can read books, attend mock interviews and so on.

I wouldn't let any of this put you off if medicine is what you want to do. If you're polite, clear, and honest in how you communicate you'll be okay.
Original post by Democracy
Communication as a doctor is a specific skill set - that's why it's formally taught at medical school and why you have five years to learn it. Some people have more of a natural flair for it than others, but that's true of any skill.

Being a good communicator as a doctor doesn't mean the same thing as being extroverted or outgoing, and becoming confident at talking to patients, relatives, other staff members etc is something which takes time and experience.

In a similar way, how you communicate in interviews is something that can be worked on and improved - you can read books, attend mock interviews and so on.

I wouldn't let any of this put you off if medicine is what you want to do. If you're polite, clear, and honest in how you communicate you'll be okay.


Thank you so much! I appreciate the response :biggrin: I shall work hard to improve my confidence. I have seen courses (e.g. the ISC medical one) for med interview practice. These are quite expensive, but would you say they are worth it?
Thanks for the response! I like the analogy used! :smile: I suck at driving and will take a very long time to pass though haha :redface: In all seriousness, thank you for the help. I am definitely going to pursue medicine.
Original post by xxNoodlezxx
Thank you so much! I appreciate the response :biggrin: I shall work hard to improve my confidence. I have seen courses (e.g. the ISC medical one) for med interview practice. These are quite expensive, but would you say they are worth it?


£175 is a lot of money - I think buying the ISC interview book and using it to organise mock interviews with friends and fellow applicants can be just as effective.
(edited 5 years ago)
Original post by Democracy
£175 is a lot of money - I think buying the ISC interview book and using it to organise mock interviews with friends and fellow applicants can be just as effective.


Ahh okay, thank you :smile:
Reply 6
Medicine is the best option for everyone but it is hard and expensive
Original post by Kevin70
Medicine is the best option for everyone but it is hard and expensive


haha true :redface:
Original post by xxNoodlezxx
While I'm certain I'll love the scientific aspect of the course, and after going to open days etc I'd like to think I'd very much enjoy the clinical stuff too, I worry I'm not the right type of person to become a doctor. I am quite shy and awkward which is obviously not good in a profession where you have to communicate all the time. Sometimes I think that maybe uni will bring me out of my shell but I'm not sure. Some people say they could imagine me in that sort of profession whereas others say that they couldn't and I'd imagine its because of my shyness. I'm not too bad, but I'm not very confident. It is a job that I would absolutely love to do but fear I am not the type of person unis are looking for.

I have been trying to increase my confidence but I'm not sure that it is working. I will apply for head girl and If I get chosen, hopefully I will become less shy. I know that communication skills and confidence are imperative for the role of a doctor so this is worrying me.

In terms of interviews, this presents a problem too as when nervous I am even more shy and struggle to formulate my thoughts. Do you think It's worth me trying for this - will I be able to overcome my awkwardness? Or am I frankly just not the type of person that is ideal for this profession. Any advice would be greatly appreciated :smile: Also any tips on how to become less shy would be very much appreciated too :biggrin:


just like to let you know that i feel the exact same! medicine as a subject massively fascinates me but i’m not sure about the clinical side yet :dontknow:

i’ve been considering medical research or like biomedical sciences or something but yeah, i’m not sure yet
Original post by clouddbubbles
just like to let you know that i feel the exact same! medicine as a subject massively fascinates me but i’m not sure about the clinical side yet :dontknow:

i’ve been considering medical research or like biomedical sciences or something but yeah, i’m not sure yet


Same here! :smile: For the longest time I just thought I was going to do biomed or biochem at university. But while the facts and knowledge learned in those degrees interest me, I'm not keen on the job prospects - e.g working in the NHS labs. I feel lab work would get monotonous pretty quickly. I'm not entirely sure I'll enjoy the clinical side of medicine though. From what I've seen on open days, it looks interesting. I like the job prospects that come from a medical degree, I feel like it would be a lot more thrilling and fulfilling for me than doing lab work.
A friend of mine became a dentist a few years ago and later became a periodonthist. He is currently making around half a million pounds a year. Rarely does any non-medical subject yields such a princely salary.
Original post by Kevin70
Medicine is the best option for everyone but it is hard and expensive


Lol, it really isn't.
Reply 12
Fake it til you make it.
That's how everyone does it.
Original post by Kevin70
Medicine is the best option for everyone but it is hard and expensive


Don't think that's how it works. Medicine in a lot of cases probably isn't the right course for people.


However, if communication skills is one thing you're concerned about and the only factor affecting your choice to pursue medicine, then I wouldn't be too concerned.

One way which naturally improves communication skills which helped me a whole lot before applying for is volunteering. Even though I am a social person, I had issues when facing new environments which may be unfamiliar eg a hospice or a hospital. After doing volunteering for a few months, I already saw that I am much more comfortable communicating in new situations without much worries about what it's like.

If you're considering applying for medicine, I have no doubt you already have done/planned some volunteering placements. If so, how are they going for you? I'd really recommend doing some volunteering in the summer holidays if you have the time.

Also another thing to note is that you'll have a chance to hone communication skills at university itself as it's an integral part of being a doctor. You'll find that after you ease yourself into medical school, you may find a lot of your worries about shyness may go away as you complete hospital placements and work with peers.

It is natural to feel stressed and timid when entering new circumstances. But it's an extremely rewarding experience. This is especially the case in medicine as once you overcome those fears because you've overcome a small barrier to a thoroughly enjoyable profession. If you believe you enjoy the other aspects of the course, I would advise you to not let that be an obstacle to applying because being successful in medicine involves showing an active interest in the subject as awhole. It is very holistic.

Good luck with your applications, have a good think about your choices and I hope you still continue to go for it! :smile:
(edited 5 years ago)
Original post by xxNoodlezxx
While I'm certain I'll love the scientific aspect of the course, and after going to open days etc I'd like to think I'd very much enjoy the clinical stuff too, I worry I'm not the right type of person to become a doctor. I am quite shy and awkward which is obviously not good in a profession where you have to communicate all the time. Sometimes I think that maybe uni will bring me out of my shell but I'm not sure. Some people say they could imagine me in that sort of profession whereas others say that they couldn't and I'd imagine its because of my shyness. I'm not too bad, but I'm not very confident. It is a job that I would absolutely love to do but fear I am not the type of person unis are looking for.

I have been trying to increase my confidence but I'm not sure that it is working. I will apply for head girl and If I get chosen, hopefully I will become less shy. I know that communication skills and confidence are imperative for the role of a doctor so this is worrying me.

In terms of interviews, this presents a problem too as when nervous I am even more shy and struggle to formulate my thoughts. Do you think It's worth me trying for this - will I be able to overcome my awkwardness? Or am I frankly just not the type of person that is ideal for this profession. Any advice would be greatly appreciated :smile: Also any tips on how to become less shy would be very much appreciated too :biggrin:


Don’t worry too much about it, my dad is very shy and awkward but is now quite high up in his hospital, you’ll get used to it and learn how to communicate better along the way :smile:
Original post by MezmorisedPotato
Don't think that's how it works. Medicine in a lot of cases probably isn't the right course for people.


However, if communication skills is one thing you're concerned about and the only factor affecting your choice to pursue medicine, then I wouldn't be too concerned.

One way which naturally improves communication skills which helped me a whole lot before applying for is volunteering. Even though I am a social person, I had issues when facing new environments which may be unfamiliar eg a hospice or a hospital. After doing volunteering for a few months, I already saw that I am much more comfortable communicating in new situations without much worries about what it's like.

If you're considering applying for medicine, I have no doubt you already have done/planned some volunteering placements. If so, how are they going for you? I'd really recommend doing some volunteering in the summer holidays if you have the time.

Also another thing to note is that you'll have a chance to hone communication skills at university itself as it's an integral part of being a doctor. You'll find that after you ease yourself into medical school, you may find a lot of your worries about shyness may go away as you complete hospital placements and work with peers.

It is natural to feel stressed and timid when entering new circumstances. But it's an extremely rewarding experience. This is especially the case in medicine as once you overcome those fears because you've overcome a small barrier to a thoroughly enjoyable profession. If you believe you enjoy the other aspects of the course, I would advise you to not let that be an obstacle to applying because being successful in medicine involves showing an active interest in the subject as awhole. It is very holistic.

Good luck with your applications, have a good think about your choices and I hope you still continue to go for it! :smile:


Thank you so much for the great advice!! :biggrin: I have only quite recently (about a month ago) been seriously considering medicine over biomed - terrible ik! But I have had a meeting with my local carehome and I'm sorting the paperwork so shall be beginning to volunteer there soon. I'm very lucky to have got a week placement at a GP, a week at a pharmacy and a week at a hospital planned now too so I'm going to have a very busy 6 weeks holiday :redface:. It's my own fault for not considering my options earlier though. Ive always just thought I'll do something science-y at uni and never really considered anything else but as I'm reaching the end of year 12, I've given much more thought to it. I'm slightly worried though because don't unis like to see long term volunteering? by the time applications have to be in, I'll only have 3 or 4 months done then about 6 for interview - is this something that will hinder my chances?

With some friends and family who I know that've gone to uni, they've seemed to come out of their shell & as you say - I'll have a chance to improve my communication skills there hopefully.

I did make a personal pro con list for studying medicine about a month ago, and upon going to open days and doing lots of research, a lot of the cons don't seem like an issue anymore. I had things on there like my poor communication skills being an issue, but after this thread - I feel more optimistic. I also had things like its long and stressful, but I believe that it is definitely worth it and shall be extremely rewarding if I'm successful. But I also put on there that 60% of people get rejected from all 4 choices which is really worrying me. It is imperative that I have a detailed backup plan in case this happens. I'd feel like I'd take a gap yera and do lots of work and volunteering rather than take my 5th option, but I really don't know. Also the UKCAT is stressing me out too haha.

Sorry for the essay :redface:
Original post by Princessalfie
Don’t worry too much about it, my dad is very shy and awkward but is now quite high up in his hospital, you’ll get used to it and learn how to communicate better along the way :smile:


Thank you so much, that is very reassuring to hear! :h:
Problem with medicine is it is not only a very hard and expensive subject to study but also in order to enter medical school you need to be almost perfect in science and maths and with a high IQ. The title of Doctor is not easy to gain at all! However, not everyone is a genius or can afford the high tuition fees of going to medical school in that case they can try to justify other subjects but then again it is important that they consider the job market reality before they embark on any course. Most postgraduate degrees in other subjects do not yield more than 25-30 K per annum which is hand to mouth living in this time and age of economic crisis.
Original post by xxNoodlezxx
Thank you so much for the great advice!! :biggrin: I have only quite recently (about a month ago) been seriously considering medicine over biomed - terrible ik! But I have had a meeting with my local carehome and I'm sorting the paperwork so shall be beginning to volunteer there soon. I'm very lucky to have got a week placement at a GP, a week at a pharmacy and a week at a hospital planned now too so I'm going to have a very busy 6 weeks holiday :redface:. It's my own fault for not considering my options earlier though. Ive always just thought I'll do something science-y at uni and never really considered anything else but as I'm reaching the end of year 12, I've given much more thought to it. I'm slightly worried though because don't unis like to see long term volunteering? by the time applications have to be in, I'll only have 3 or 4 months done then about 6 for interview - is this something that will hinder my chances?

With some friends and family who I know that've gone to uni, they've seemed to come out of their shell & as you say - I'll have a chance to improve my communication skills there hopefully.

I did make a personal pro con list for studying medicine about a month ago, and upon going to open days and doing lots of research, a lot of the cons don't seem like an issue anymore. I had things on there like my poor communication skills being an issue, but after this thread - I feel more optimistic. I also had things like its long and stressful, but I believe that it is definitely worth it and shall be extremely rewarding if I'm successful. But I also put on there that 60% of people get rejected from all 4 choices which is really worrying me. It is imperative that I have a detailed backup plan in case this happens. I'd feel like I'd take a gap yera and do lots of work and volunteering rather than take my 5th option, but I really don't know. Also the UKCAT is stressing me out too haha.

Sorry for the essay :redface:


It's good you've gained some placements, it'll definitely aid your application if you explain it correctly.

To answer all your questions, let me number them for each question.

1. Whilst for volunteering placements longer time shows committment, for medical school applications I believe around 4-6 months should suffice. Essentially however, it isn't about how long or how many you have. It's about what you have learned from each placement and your reflections from it. So no, I don't think it will hinder your application, you just have the explain your reflections in a unique way.

2. A lot rejections for medical school comes from not meeting the intital entry requirements hence they are rejected pre-interview. Once you enter the interview stage, provided you have prepared and done some further reading, you have a real shot at getting an offer. However this doesn't rule out the case where people are rejected after interview. But with the right preparation, you will be more than prepared to get at least one offer. Also apply strategically to your strengths to maximise the chances of getting an interview and then potentially an offer.

3. The UKCAT for me was one of the most stressful tests I have done. But that's not because of the difficulty of the questions, rather the strict timing. With practise using resources such as Medify and TMP, I found I improved a lot even though I initially found the experience daunting. My scores intially wasn't wonderful to say the least but by the time I done the test, I'm glad I obtained a decent score which enabled to get interviews from universities. If I hadn't gone on holiday two weeks before, I might have done a bit better too, who knows! 😂 But the key is to once again apply strategically and if by chance your UKCAT score isn't great, then apply to universities that don't weigh UKCAT heavily. You'll be surprised at how many there are!

It's really good you've done a pros and cons list, I think it'll help clear your mind of any problems you may think you have and help ease yourself. Just relax now holidays are coming up, try and start the volunteering you've mentioned and do some preparation for the UKCAT and I assure you everything will be alright!

Good luck!
Original post by MezmorisedPotato
It's good you've gained some placements, it'll definitely aid your application if you explain it correctly.

To answer all your questions, let me number them for each question.

1. Whilst for volunteering placements longer time shows committment, for medical school applications I believe around 4-6 months should suffice. Essentially however, it isn't about how long or how many you have. It's about what you have learned from each placement and your reflections from it. So no, I don't think it will hinder your application, you just have the explain your reflections in a unique way.

2. A lot rejections for medical school comes from not meeting the intital entry requirements hence they are rejected pre-interview. Once you enter the interview stage, provided you have prepared and done some further reading, you have a real shot at getting an offer. However this doesn't rule out the case where people are rejected after interview. But with the right preparation, you will be more than prepared to get at least one offer. Also apply strategically to your strengths to maximise the chances of getting an interview and then potentially an offer.

3. The UKCAT for me was one of the most stressful tests I have done. But that's not because of the difficulty of the questions, rather the strict timing. With practise using resources such as Medify and TMP, I found I improved a lot even though I initially found the experience daunting. My scores intially wasn't wonderful to say the least but by the time I done the test, I'm glad I obtained a decent score which enabled to get interviews from universities. If I hadn't gone on holiday two weeks before, I might have done a bit better too, who knows! 😂 But the key is to once again apply strategically and if by chance your UKCAT score isn't great, then apply to universities that don't weigh UKCAT heavily. You'll be surprised at how many there are!

It's really good you've done a pros and cons list, I think it'll help clear your mind of any problems you may think you have and help ease yourself. Just relax now holidays are coming up, try and start the volunteering you've mentioned and do some preparation for the UKCAT and I assure you everything will be alright!

Good luck!


Thank you! :biggrin: Where have you applied if you don't mind me asking?
I know I shouldn't be pessimistic, but I know I probably won't get the best of UKCAT scores (I will try my hardest though) so I'm generally looking at GCSE heavy places like Birmingham. I went to their open day and I absolutely love it there. The only issue is my work experience and ECs as I've read the criteria on their website and it says this:

"We recognise that extracurricular activity in areas outside of healthcare can supplement the development of the broader qualities required of a potential doctor. These aspects (e.g. an ability to make rational decisions and to communicate these with compassion) will also be relevant to successful performance at interview. The types of non-academic experiences that may assist in your personal development include a job in a customer-focused role or a voluntary role giving you responsibility for a group of individuals (such as a leader for one of the youth organisations like the scouts or guides or a sports coaching role). In general, these activities should be long-term, on-going and involve significant interactions with a broad range of people in a responsible capacity"

I don't really have any ECs and I don't have a part-time job. I satisfy their requirement to have at least 2 weeks WEX in a healthcare environment, but the EC criteria is worrying me as I don't do anything outside of school. Ive taken on many roles within school like senior prefect, peer mentor etc but nothing outside :s-smilie:

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending