Shamima Begum was cruel enforcer in Isil's morality police, say Syrian witnesses

Information from that area is so shaky, though. Will need to have more confirmation.

Surely the fact she thought it was a good idea to join a group of people who set pilots on fire for fun, is confirmation enough? She's a vile human being and is now reaping what was sown.

Because she joined Isis, she must have been a member of the religious police? No, that simply does not follow.

The anti-Isis groups are not very pro-Begum and professing witnessing her do ghastly things helps their cause and gives them retribution. The source, at the very least, is biased.

Because she joined Isis, she must have been a member of the religious police? No, that simply does not follow.

The anti-Isis groups are not very pro-Begum and professing witnessing her do ghastly things helps their cause and gives them retribution. The source, at the very least, is biased.

Surely the fact she thought it was a good idea to join a group of people who set pilots on fire for fun, is confirmation enough? She's a vile human being and is now reaping what was sown.

A lot of them were members of the morality police.The only evidence you have that she didn't do anything wrong is that she happens to be a woman.If she were a man this debate wouldn't even be a thing.And I didn't say that it follows that she is a member just that it's surely enough evidence to not let her back in.

The source might be biased but we dont need to know that to make a decision.We know Isis are a group who do horrible things.We know that they advertised their atrocities all over the news such that you'd have to be living under a rock to not hear about it.We know she thought it was a good idea to join them.We know she's unfazed by severed heads and thinks the Manchester bombing was a good thing.All in all we know quite enough about her to revoke her citizenship.

You're inventing an argument I simply did not present. I in no way said she did nothing wrong. I was against her being permitted to come back to the UK and you'll see me say this in several threads previously.

This story is adding a new angle -- that she was active in Isis, rather than passive as had been previously alleged. I am merely questioning the veracity of that by looking at the reliability of these new sources. Being analytical and using my brain doesn't mean I must support Begum! And I don't suggest it's impossible that she was active.

I think its quite obvious she was active.If she wanted to be a housewife then she could easily have stayed here.The housewife thing is just a ploy to gain sympathy.

I'm saying you don't even need to know she was active.Its enough that she supports their ideology.And she did commit a crime anyway, you can't just join genocidal groups and not expect to go to prison.

Superfluous comments from you.

Irony