The Student Room Group

Unpopular opinion: The USSR was a good country

Scroll to see replies

Original post by lastlullabyy
Poland actually.

I know many people from Bulgaria and not a single one of them holds this view. Great life, where free speech could land you in jail, you couldn’t access anything, whether you worked or not you were getting a wage... not being able to leave your country, being FORCED to learn Russian at school... I guess all of my relatives and other who fought and protested did it because they were bored :wink:

And read up a bit. 1989 was the fall of communism. Solidarity in Poland fought against authoritative communist government.

Nice world you live in where there were no communist countries.

Not even going to go into eg Katyn - and how USSR denies to this day a massacre of Polish intelligence.


Lech Walesa was a truly great and brave man.
Original post by kali8603
I'm not talking necessarily about Stalin's USSR, but the USSR had free healthcare, one of the best education systems and literacy rates in the world, guaranteed jobs, whilst maintaining a massively strong army that challenged the US. Without the USSR, there is no one to hold the US to account, and means that the US is now the only dominant power in reality, meaning war is actually more likely. I think the world overall was a better place with the Soviet Union. Many countries are now much poorer after the Soviet Union, such as Moldova, Tajikistan etc. Whilst some have benefited, for every success story there is a faliure. I know the USSR is often negatively portrayed but in reality, I don't think it was as bad as it was made out to be. Also, I don't see why socialism is so often associated with Stalin's atrocities. It's just as bad as associating religions such as Islam with terror. Just because someone does something bad in the name of an ideology or religion, doesn't mean that ideology or religion is bad.

Thoughts on Fascism?
Oh and don’t you even get me started on Stalin and helping to defeat Hitler...

17 September 1939. Soviets invaded Poland from the East. 16 days after Nazi Germans invaded from the West.

I guess they don’t make enough international movies about it... But I believe that Katyn is available with English subtitles. 22,000 people were brutally killed and buried in mass graves.

Great Soviet Union...
(edited 4 years ago)
Original post by ColinDent
Lech Walesa was a truly great and brave man.


Still is, I believe he’s in his early 70s now...
My grandfather worked in Gdansk shipyard and was there during 1980 protests.
Original post by lastlullabyy
Still is, I believe he’s in his early 70s now...
My grandfather worked in Gdansk shipyard and was there during 1980 protests.


I'd not checked if he was still alive, seems so long ago now! I remember those protests back in the day, that was the start of the revolution.
Original post by Alt Tankie
Completely agree OP

To any liberal that wants to play a numbers game fine - but I include

-Western sanctions against regimes
- illegal wars
- coups


And excuse my laughter, but what wars would you class as “legal”? 😂 if you say “illegal wars” then surely that stipulates that some wars ARE legal... curious, how does that work?

Illegal war is like an oxymoron.
Reply 26
Original post by ColinDent
Not wanting to play down the USSR's part in fighting Hitler but let's also not forget whose side they were on at the start of the war, it was only because Germany tried to screw the USSR over that they ended up fighting them.


Woah woah woah. They weren't "on their side". They signed a non aggression pact. That was mostly for the Germans who didn't want to fight a two front war. And of course, the Soviets did get their sphere of influence, but their ideologies were completely different.
Reply 27
Original post by EagleKingdom
Thoughts on Fascism?


Every fascist has practically been bad, whereas most Muslims are peace abiding, as most socialists are also not stalinists.
Reply 28
Original post by 999tigger
What is your definition of good and bad?
Which USSR are you talking about?
If it was so good then why did it collapase?
If it was so good then why dont Russians revert to the USSR and communism?
What was the standard of living for the average russian?
What about all the countries it occupied?
Why is war more likely and war between who?
Which are the countries in which communism works and people are better off?
You dont have to pay reference to Stalin but its not something you should ignore either . Twenty million of your own people is a large number.
None of the above questions need or actually relate to Stalin.

etc etc.

Soviet union fell because of bourgeousis nationalism in the republics, and Gorbachev liberalising everything. The countries it occupied were occupied before by the Nazis. I don't support either in that sense. Standard of living for the average russian wasn't as good as western standards, but east has always been behind west. There was no industrial revolution in eastern europe. Living conditions to this day in eastern europe, now all capitalist, is still behind the west.
ah the joys of queing up for hours just to get basic products from shops, as experienced by my parents
Reply 30
Ah, yes, Poland. Poland, the country that hates communism, but now is run by a borderline fascist government that along with Nazi Ukraine celebrates Nazi collaborators, and has been listed as one of the most antisemitic countries in this world, still after all these years. The Nazis are reveired there. There's a Polish joke, I'm sure you're aware of it: "What's worse than being occupied by the Nazis? Being rescued by the Soviets".

Poland is now becoming an Arthurian capitalist government which is anti immigration, (and still is anti free speech). So don't get me started on Poland. The only reason why you're against communism is because Poland's economy has become great, as has the Czech Republic. But not many other countries.
Original post by lastlullabyy
Poland actually.

I know many people from Bulgaria and not a single one of them holds this view. Great life, where free speech could land you in jail, you couldn’t access anything, whether you worked or not you were getting a wage... not being able to leave your country, being FORCED to learn Russian at school... I guess all of my relatives and other who fought and protested did it because they were bored :wink: People were living in constant fear of being arrested. Censorship was terrible - still is in Russia to this day. I could go on and on all day...

And read up a bit. 1989 was the fall of communism. Solidarity in Poland fought against authoritative communist government.

Nice world you live in where there were no communist countries.

Not even going to go into eg Katyn - and how Soviets denied responsibility for it until 1990 and blamed Germans. Russia STILL refuses to call it what it was: a war crime and a mass murder.
Original post by kali8603
Woah woah woah. They weren't "on their side". They signed a non aggression pact. That was mostly for the Germans who didn't want to fight a two front war. And of course, the Soviets did get their sphere of influence, but their ideologies were completely different.


Sure. Completely different ideologies. Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact - rings a bell?

You know what Soviets did to prisoners who were deemed “too hardened and uncompromising” and would not conform to pro-Soviet ideologies? They were killed. Amazing ideology. Propaganda, lies and no regard for the life and well-being of people, that what can sum up Soviet Union.
Reply 32
Original post by 999tigger
When do people ignore the fact of the USSR contribution to defeating the Nazis? They always get due recognition in all Histories that I have read or people I have spoken to.

Your idea that people think its black and white and they are like the Nazis is rather simplistic and incorrect in any History I have ever come across or been associated with. Even the Nazis arent a simple case.

It's just in general. In the d -day celebrations, Russia was not invited despite contributing the most deaths (as did China). Yet literal Nazi puppets at the time such as Slovakia and Greece were.
Reply 33
Bulgaria has lost 2 million people since the fall of socialism there. It was the silicon valley of the USSR. To be frank, now it is a sh*thole. I've spoken and know many Bulgarians, many are in this country. Just like nearby Russia, after the USSR it became a corrupt, obligarch state. To this day, Bulgaria and neighbouring Romania are the most corrupt countries in Europe. Romania actually legalised corruption. There's censorship in UK now. RT, the russian broadcaster, was going to be banned for presenting a pro Russian opinion. George Galloway, Talk Radio host, silenced for being anti Israel.

Original post by lastlullabyy
Poland actually.

I know many people from Bulgaria and not a single one of them holds this view. Great life, where free speech could land you in jail, you couldn’t access anything, whether you worked or not you were getting a wage... not being able to leave your country, being FORCED to learn Russian at school... I guess all of my relatives and other who fought and protested did it because they were bored :wink: People were living in constant fear of being arrested. Censorship was terrible - still is in Russia to this day. I could go on and on all day...

And read up a bit. 1989 was the fall of communism. Solidarity in Poland fought against authoritative communist government.

Nice world you live in where there were no communist countries.

Not even going to go into eg Katyn - and how Soviets denied responsibility for it until 1990 and blamed Germans. Russia STILL refuses to call it what it was: a war crime and a mass murder.
Original post by kali8603
Ah, yes, Poland. Poland, the country that hates communism, but now is run by a borderline fascist government that along with Nazi Ukraine celebrates Nazi collaborators, and has been listed as one of the most antisemitic countries in this world, still after all these years. The Nazis are reveired there. There's a Polish joke, I'm sure you're aware of it: "What's worse than being occupied by the Nazis? Being rescued by the Soviets".

Poland is now becoming an Arthurian capitalist government which is anti immigration, (and still is anti free speech). So don't get me started on Poland. The only reason why you're against communism is because Poland's economy has become great, as has the Czech Republic. But not many other countries.

I’ve never said that I agree with current Polish government or its policies. On the contrary - one of the reasons why I don’t live there, as I’m strongly against such ideology. But we were talking about USSR.

And no, as I don’t personally know or surround myself with facists I’ve not heard that joke.

Don’t make me laugh though - Poland would’ve been much better off if communisn never happened.
Original post by kali8603
Woah woah woah. They weren't "on their side". They signed a non aggression pact. That was mostly for the Germans who didn't want to fight a two front war. And of course, the Soviets did get their sphere of influence, but their ideologies were completely different.

They were attacking allied Balkan countries
Original post by kali8603
Bulgaria has lost 2 million people since the fall of socialism there. It was the silicon valley of the USSR. To be frank, now it is a sh*thole. I've spoken and know many Bulgarians, many are in this country. Just like nearby Russia, after the USSR it became a corrupt, obligarch state. To this day, Bulgaria and neighbouring Romania are the most corrupt countries in Europe. Romania actually legalised corruption. There's censorship in UK now. RT, the russian broadcaster, was going to be banned for presenting a pro Russian opinion. George Galloway, Talk Radio host, silenced for being anti Israel.


To be fair George Galloway should be silenced for being a ****.
For clarification when I say silenced I mean not given time in the press or media to express his ridiculous opinions.
(edited 4 years ago)
Reply 37
Original post by lastlullabyy
Sure. Completely different ideologies. Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact - rings a bell?

You know what Soviets did to prisoners who were deemed “too hardened and uncompromising” and would not conform to pro-Soviet ideologies? They were killed. Amazing ideology. Propaganda, lies and no regard for the life and well-being of people, that what can sum up Soviet Union.

You're too simplistic. As someone who has studied WW2 history extensively, I am fully aware of the Molotov-Ribbentrop pact. As said, it was a non agression pact in which both Germany and the Soviets got their own spheres of influence. I do think the USSR shouldn't have annexed parts of Poland, and TBH I'm surprised they weren't made to return them after the war, given that they were aquired with Germany's blessing. But as said, Hitler hated the Soviets. He only liked Stalin for his brutality. I never said the soviet union was perfect. Do you think Britain is a good country? I do. But Britain has committed genocides, has opened concentration camps in the past. Churchill, the war hero we all love so much, gassed Iraqis when they rebelled, refused to give food to people suffering in the Bengali famine, as well as being borderline racist.
Original post by kali8603
Bulgaria has lost 2 million people since the fall of socialism there. It was the silicon valley of the USSR. To be frank, now it is a sh*thole. I've spoken and know many Bulgarians, many are in this country. Just like nearby Russia, after the USSR it became a corrupt, obligarch state. To this day, Bulgaria and neighbouring Romania are the most corrupt countries in Europe. Romania actually legalised corruption. There's censorship in UK now. RT, the russian broadcaster, was going to be banned for presenting a pro Russian opinion. George Galloway, Talk Radio host, silenced for being anti Israel.


And USSR was not a corrupt state at all... :wink: where it only mattered not what you knew but WHO you knew.

I’m going to leave it there as seems like we have completely opposite views.
Reply 39
Original post by lastlullabyy
And USSR was not a corrupt state at all... :wink: where it only mattered not what you knew but WHO you knew.

I’m going to leave it there as seems like we have completely opposite views.

We do. Your country really isn't about free speech though after the Soviets, considering you've literally banned the Hammer and Sickle. Can you actually tell me about your experiences under the Polish Socialist Republic though, because all you've referenced so far is the Solidarity movement in 89', which of course was part of wider dissent in that year.

The problem is, is that there was no actual revolution in Poland, east germany, hungary etc which led to them becoming communist. these countries were effectively occupied by the soviet union. That's never a good idea. And so whilst i support the soviet union as a country, I don't support how they continued to occupy these countries.

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending