Hey, I’ve just finished my second year of A Levels, including English language. My response is based on the assumption you would do the AQA exam board like I did, both from what you’ve mentioned about content and most centres do AQA anyway.
1. I’ve enjoyed it massively, but this, like every subject, also depends on your class and lecturer/teacher of course. A wide range of abilities take language, more so than lit I’d say, having done both. It’s got a rep of being a ‘softer’ option and I did choose it to balance out my other two more intense subjects, so I did find it a little easier/more laid back than Lit (although lit is a facilitating subject and this isn’t, so it’s a widely held view). Course wise, it’s actually quite interesting and covers a broad range of topics (which I’ll give in 2. ) in both years, again making it enjoyable and varied too. Last thought, I much preferred language at A Level to language at GCSE and a few people in my class are taking it further, if that acts in its favour!
2. So the way I’d describe the difference is that GCSE language for me felt more like literature- analysing a text for meaning, not a lot else. A Level language is more like looking in depth at the grammatical use of language (sort of a scientific look at language use), perhaps identifying what purpose the producer/writer writes to meet and the positioning of the audience/reader. Grab a look at the website for the exam board you would be using and have a dig around of the spec, if you haven’t already!
Brief summary of papers: Paper 1 AS involves looking at two texts then comparing, the analysis being the same as GCSE, the style of essay being different. Paper 2 AS involves an essay on the topics below and a creative essay/article. Paper 1 A2 you look at two texts than comparing (like in year 1) but the texts are from different time periods so you compare that and a Child Language Acquisition question is tagged on to the end of the paper. Paper 2 A2 is a question on language diversity or language change and then a language attitudes question, followed by a creative essay/article, like for AS but more serious perhaps and more suited to A2 level. Coursework is in addition to this for A2 year. We did AS, I’m not sure if you will as it varies from centre to centre, but it all needs to be covered at some point for A2, so there you go anyway.
Topics across the two years included how language is affected by your: age, gender, sexuality, occupation, social class and social group (AS) and Child Language Acquisition, World Englishes and Language Change throughout the centuries (A2). A2 topics I found were naturally more in depth but nothing too difficult. As you can tell, this is not like GCSE, which was much less content-based and more you get what you’re given and analyse it. A lot of groundwork goes into A Level analysis but it’s not a bore or anything.
3. I will quickly mention the coursework structure to make it clearer – firstly, you do a language investigation on your topic of choice, provided that the teacher is okay with it. Some people did the language of people on Love Island, football commentaries, song lyrics etc. So it’s pretty much up to you and your interests, which is nice. Then you do the creative piece with a style model to base yours from. Finally, you do a commentary on your piece.
As mentioned above in 2. , each year has one creative essay/article but no other creative aspects to the exam. As for the coursework, the original writing piece (750 words approx.) is most people’s favourite part because it’s quite free and broad- we could write it in the form of an article, blog post, poem, story etc. but it has to be based on a language issue. You then have to do the commentary on it, only like 750 words, sort of analysing your own work. It’s odd to get back to creative writing after GCSE, for which I remember doing more of it, definitely! Like with the form, the topic is completely up to you; you get a lot more freedom than GCSE for certain. I did my investigation on the language from a comedy show I liked and my creative section on why people weren’t learning other languages anymore since the English language is so massive in the world. It was immense but I enjoyed it immensely!
4. I already mentioned the paper structure and topics that you are tested on, however as for whether it’s more analysis or fact recall, it’s hard to say. Paper One, you just need to know your grammar and essay structure as the texts themselves are unseen, in addition to the CLA studies. Paper Two is definitely more memory-based as there are a lot of language studies under the umbrella of age, gender etc. (from my experience, you don’t need to remember more than the theorist e.g. Lakoff and what they did e.g. ten features of women’s language before giving examples and doing a little analysis). You don’t need to remember all the studies, in case that worries you, and you can do well without giving all the one’s you’ve learned; in fact, you can just choose the most relevant ones and the examiner will appreciate this more than just spewing out all you have remembered on to the page!
5. This is a tricky one because, of course, it depends on how well you do at the end of the day but, like I said previously, it’s not a facilitating subject like Literature. It’s hard work, like all A-Levels, and I don’t like thinking like my CV will have the ‘soft’ option on it. It is what you make it; if you enjoy it, work hard and do well, it will be beneficial to you. It’s an A Level at the end of the day and while it depends on the subject you want to do at university, or the job you want to get (e.g. lit is more beneficial if you want to get into teaching – none of my language lecturers/teachers for GCSE or A Level did language at degree), what matters most is the enjoyment and skills you get out of it because two years is a long time to study something you aren’t happy with.
Echoing your original post, I know it’s a lot (did so not intend to get into it that deeply), but I really hope I have helped you make up your mind a little. It’s a big decision, so I hope I’ve helped a bit. Congrats on getting through your GCSEs and good luck with your results/ good luck at A Level, whichever subjects you decide on in the end. If you have any more questions, please feel free to ask
P.s If I got any info wrong, I apologise; at first, most was wiped from my memory post exams!