The Student Room Group

Not paying parking fine

My car was in the garage last week and they parked the car when they had it on a car park. I recieved a parking charge notice as a result. I had no ticket or anything like that on my windscreen.

I received a parking charge notice. This is not a council or government penalty charge notice. This is from a private company. So I'm not going to pay this fine as it's difficult and costly for them to enforce. However us there cases of them being able to take people to court over parking?

I will try to get the garage to pay for the ticket as they were the ones who made me get the ticket. If not then I'll appeal it.

I'll see if I can post pictures of it

Scroll to see replies

It also says I'm invited to pay the unpaid parking charge. Should I write back saying I decline the invitation? :biggrin: £60 is a full tank of fuel for me.
The other side of the letter says how to pay, appeal, driver identification, complaints, and gdpr stuff
Use option B, and give the details of the garage.
Original post by olafgarten
Use option B, and give the details of the garage.

I'll do that, but I'm not sure. This is my first private parking charge
Original post by Nadim Chowdhury
My car was in the garage last week and they parked the car when they had it on a car park. I recieved a parking charge notice as a result. I had no ticket or anything like that on my windscreen.

I received a parking charge notice. This is not a council or government penalty charge notice. This is from a private company. So I'm not going to pay this fine as it's difficult and costly for them to enforce. However us there cases of them being able to take people to court over parking?

I will try to get the garage to pay for the ticket as they were the ones who made me get the ticket. If not then I'll appeal it.

I'll see if I can post pictures of it

Not quite clear what you meant in your first paragraph, are you saying it was left with a parking service (such as an airport parking company) and they parked it someplace where it got a private enforcement ticket?
Original post by Nadim Chowdhury
I'll do that, but I'm not sure. This is my first private parking charge


Generally the advice if you get a private parking ticket and don't intend to pay it is to be completely silent on the matter. Don't respond in any way at all. They will send increasingly aggressive letters about paying, but eventually they will give up. If you don't intend to pay, then there is no benefit at all for you to communicate with them, it will just extend the argument. They will continue to communicate with you as long as you reply.

However, you should speak to the garage about their liability. This has probably happened before if they do this regularly.
Original post by Nadim Chowdhury
My car was in the garage last week and they parked the car when they had it on a car park. I recieved a parking charge notice as a result. I had no ticket or anything like that on my windscreen.

I received a parking charge notice. This is not a council or government penalty charge notice. This is from a private company. So I'm not going to pay this fine as it's difficult and costly for them to enforce. However us there cases of them being able to take people to court over parking?

I will try to get the garage to pay for the ticket as they were the ones who made me get the ticket. If not then I'll appeal it.

I'll see if I can post pictures of it

https://www.moneysavingexpert.com/reclaim/private-parking-tickets/
Original post by Nadim Chowdhury
My car was in the garage last week and they parked the car when they had it on a car park. I recieved a parking charge notice as a result. I had no ticket or anything like that on my windscreen.

I received a parking charge notice. This is not a council or government penalty charge notice. This is from a private company. So I'm not going to pay this fine as it's difficult and costly for them to enforce. However us there cases of them being able to take people to court over parking?

I will try to get the garage to pay for the ticket as they were the ones who made me get the ticket. If not then I'll appeal it.

I'll see if I can post pictures of it

If you read the notice, the parking company accept that liability rests with the driver of the vehicle and they do not know whether that is you.

Why pick a war with the parking company, when if you write a polite letter to the parking company giving them the name of the garage, and I would suggest photocopies of the booking in slip, record of work done and invoice, you will probably not hear from the parking company again?
Like people have said any correspondence with them when you intend to not pay only weakens your standing.

(Ignored smart parking fine and they stopped the threats of court action after 18months)

I would speak to garage first, only talk to parking company if garage intends to pay.
Original post by Fullofsurprises
Not quite clear what you meant in your first paragraph, are you saying it was left with a parking service (such as an airport parking company) and they parked it someplace where it got a private enforcement ticket?


My car was getting some work done by a garage. They then drove the car and parked it in a car park. That's where the ticket is from
Original post by Nadim Chowdhury
My car was getting some work done by a garage. They then drove the car and parked it in a car park. That's where the ticket is from

They are legally responsible for paying it then. Pay the ticket to the enforcement company and then write to the garage with a copy of the ticket and your proof of payment, requesting that they pay the amount to you within 28 days. If they don't or they refuse, you may be able to take them to small claims court. If you still owe them money, simply deduct it from what you owe them and explain why.
Original post by threeportdrift
Generally the advice if you get a private parking ticket and don't intend to pay it is to be completely silent on the matter. Don't respond in any way at all. They will send increasingly aggressive letters about paying, but eventually they will give up. If you don't intend to pay, then there is no benefit at all for you to communicate with them, it will just extend the argument. They will continue to communicate with you as long as you reply.

However, you should speak to the garage about their liability. This has probably happened before if they do this regularly.

Really? This is garbage advice.

Do not ignore the parking tickets, it's a civil matter yes - but once it gets through the courts, you're toast.

OP, don't ignore it and appeal saying you weren't responsible for it. Then await their reply.
Original post by RoyalSheepy
Really? This is garbage advice.

Do not ignore the parking tickets, it's a civil matter yes - but once it gets through the courts, you're toast.

OP, don't ignore it and appeal saying you weren't responsible for it. Then await their reply.


I'm not a legal professional, but any search online, and personal experience, indicates that the current situation is summarised as below -

"Many people assume all parking tickets are the same however there are a number of important differences between parking tickets from the local council, and those enforced by private companies.
Understanding these differences is vital in working out whether it is worth challenging the fine, and how to go about winning your case.
Public parking tickets are issued for breaching parking rules on public land - such as on the road or in a public car park. While private parking tickets are issued for breaching the rules on private land, such as in a supermarket car park.
Local authorities, police, or Transport for London enforce public parking tickets which usually will come with fines in the form of a Penalty Charge Notice, or PCN.

But private parking firms have no power to issue fines or enforce private parking tickets. Instead they fine the drivers and are technically issuing invoices for an alleged breach of contract."

The OP indicated that is was a private parking ticket, not a PCN. That being the case, it isn't worth the company's time in proceeding to court on an alleged breach of contract. If you choose to ignore them, they will give up chasing when in stops being cost effective.
Original post by threeportdrift
I'm not a legal professional, but any search online, and personal experience, indicates that the current situation is summarised as below -

"Many people assume all parking tickets are the same however there are a number of important differences between parking tickets from the local council, and those enforced by private companies.
Understanding these differences is vital in working out whether it is worth challenging the fine, and how to go about winning your case.
Public parking tickets are issued for breaching parking rules on public land - such as on the road or in a public car park. While private parking tickets are issued for breaching the rules on private land, such as in a supermarket car park.
Local authorities, police, or Transport for London enforce public parking tickets which usually will come with fines in the form of a Penalty Charge Notice, or PCN.

But private parking firms have no power to issue fines or enforce private parking tickets. Instead they fine the drivers and are technically issuing invoices for an alleged breach of contract."

The OP indicated that is was a private parking ticket, not a PCN. That being the case, it isn't worth the company's time in proceeding to court on an alleged breach of contract. If you choose to ignore them, they will give up chasing when in stops being cost effective.


Correct, it's not a PCN. Incorrect about the company not following it up. I suggest if you have insufficient knowledge on this topic, I recommend you stay in your assigned area as a FH.

Private tickets can be enforced in courts using sufficient evidence, it's a huge gamble to just ignore a notice like that - you don't know if they're bluffing or not. If they're not bluffing you'd have wished you paid the fine in the first place with all the court costs incurred.
Original post by RoyalSheepy
Correct, it's not a PCN. Incorrect about the company not following it up. I suggest if you have insufficient knowledge on this topic, I recommend you stay in your assigned area as a FH.

Private tickets can be enforced in courts using sufficient evidence, it's a huge gamble to just ignore a notice like that - you don't know if they're bluffing or not. If they're not bluffing you'd have wished you paid the fine in the first place with all the court costs incurred.


And how would they have sufficient evidence against the OP if the car was with the garage at the time?

This seems to be your area of speciality, do you have any stats about how many private tickets are issued v how many are taken to court? Maybe also the equivalent PCN data? That would be very helpful to see.
Just write back with the details of the garage. If the garage are the ones who parked there, then the contract is with them and they are liable. However, if you bury you're head in the sand and do nothing, how is the parking company supposed to know?

The law around this is covered in the Proctection of Freedoms Act 2012, which allows parking companies to assume that the registered owner is the driver (therefore liable) unless the RO supplies the actual driver details.

If I were you, I would write back within the garage details, then if it goes further and they still claim you're liable, appeal. However, if you do nothing, then it drastically weakens your case.

Many times a parking company will just forget the whole matter, but never assume that this will happen in your case. The last thing you need is a CCJ against you.
(edited 4 years ago)
Original post by threeportdrift
I'm not a legal professional, but any search online, and personal experience, indicates that the current situation is summarised as below -

"Many people assume all parking tickets are the same however there are a number of important differences between parking tickets from the local council, and those enforced by private companies.
Understanding these differences is vital in working out whether it is worth challenging the fine, and how to go about winning your case.
Public parking tickets are issued for breaching parking rules on public land - such as on the road or in a public car park. While private parking tickets are issued for breaching the rules on private land, such as in a supermarket car park.
Local authorities, police, or Transport for London enforce public parking tickets which usually will come with fines in the form of a Penalty Charge Notice, or PCN.

But private parking firms have no power to issue fines or enforce private parking tickets. Instead they fine the drivers and are technically issuing invoices for an alleged breach of contract."

The OP indicated that is was a private parking ticket, not a PCN. That being the case, it isn't worth the company's time in proceeding to court on an alleged breach of contract. If you choose to ignore them, they will give up chasing when in stops being cost effective.

You have ignored how the article you have quoted finishes

"However, you should use caution when ignoring a ticket if the firm decides to call your bluff and take you to court, you could end up paying a lot more.”

Ultimately if, as appears to be the case, the OP is not liable, that is what the judge will decide.

However the judge has a discretion about the parking company's costs, even in a small claim and the judge could well decide that the OP behaved unreasonably in ignoring a perfectly sensible letter asking him for who was driving. The OP could end up not have to pay the penalty but having to pay the court fee and the parking company's lawyer's time for establishing that the OP was not responsible.
Reply 19
Original post by Nadim Chowdhury
My car was in the garage last week and they parked the car when they had it on a car park. I recieved a parking charge notice as a result. I had no ticket or anything like that on my windscreen.

I received a parking charge notice. This is not a council or government penalty charge notice. This is from a private company. So I'm not going to pay this fine as it's difficult and costly for them to enforce. However us there cases of them being able to take people to court over parking?

I will try to get the garage to pay for the ticket as they were the ones who made me get the ticket. If not then I'll appeal it.

I'll see if I can post pictures of it

Don't ignore it. Speak to the garage who parked your car. It's their responsibility.

Original post by threeportdrift
Generally the advice if you get a private parking ticket and don't intend to pay it is to be completely silent on the matter. Don't respond in any way at all. They will send increasingly aggressive letters about paying, but eventually they will give up. If you don't intend to pay, then there is no benefit at all for you to communicate with them, it will just extend the argument. They will continue to communicate with you as long as you reply.

However, you should speak to the garage about their liability. This has probably happened before if they do this regularly.


Whilst it used to be the case that you could safely ignore tickets from private parking companies, this is no longer the case. They can and have taken people to court in the past (and yes, they've won).

I'm with Sheepy - perhaps stay in your assigned area if you're not knowledgeable on the subject.

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending