Societies can’t work in an age of information chaos. Government, science, law: none of them work unless you have agreed facts.
But - at the very time that people might be expected to turn to journalism for a reliable guide to the world around us - surveys show the media to be the least trusted of all institutions.
What do you think went wrong? Why is the media experiencing a crisis in both economics and trust? And how will societies ensure a reliable source of news in the future?
Not an easy question by any means, but is it arguable that the crises of the last couple of decades has destroyed faith in the old liberal centrist democratic consensus, leading to extreme identity and ideological interest groups based on conflict emerging.
They give themselves power by arguing that they alone can interpret the wishes of the people, and that no one else can understand the will of the people. It is therefore in their interest to undermine directly and indirectly the credibility of any other institution claiming to represent the people, not just rival social and political groups, but also any news story or service that does not agree without question with their version of the truth.
The media is cast as an agent of political opponents seeking to undermine the people and their one true group of representatives, through selective emphasis on particular scandals and reports, thus discrediting it when it’s stories indirectly or directly weaken the group. News media then either adapts and focuses on a singular demographic and its world view (Fox News) or attempts to obsessively deliver balance and keep its entire consumer base (BBC).
The existence of partisan news outlets then further drives division, as people reach the mental conclusion that there are multiple versions of the truth, but only theirs is right, and anything outside of that is a lie, a half truth, or “fake news”. The truth rather than driving the narratives and stories we tell ourselves (eg libertarianism, communism, fascism) instead is subsumed into becoming PART OF the narrative.
Rudy Guiliani said it best: “Truth is not truth”, arguably the single most important phrase of the entire Trump presidency, and one which has dire ramifications for a democracy and society built upon the idea that we all agree on the facts, but just can’t agree on what we do with the facts. We may be moving back to a new yet familiar era (think Stalins USSR) in which critical reporting becomes a partisan attack and facts themselves become an opinion, as is once again exemplified by Trumps standard attack of “fake news “ on unflattering journalistic reports.
There is no way out of this that I can think of. The crisis in journalism is part of a wider crisis in society, in which the foundation of consensus through which we live together is being constantly eroded by an unprecedented series of global issues as humanity transitions from one era of global history to another. All we can do is hope to weather the storm, and hope that someday our descendants will be able to rebuild the social consensus. With any luck they will be smarter people than us, so long as our bickering does not destroy their future first.