The Student Room Group

Pet dog

Is it realistically possible to own a dog during the latter half of a medicine degree, ie years 4 to 5/6?
I say the latter half because I am well aware that little to no university provided accommodation allows pets so for this assume that you were living in your own accomodation that allowed pets.
Also, unless anybody thinks otherwise, I am assuming that a puppy would be too much time and commitment during university so I am more thinking of the possibility of adopting a fully grown dog.
Would the time commitment of years 4 to 5/6 of medicine (both work and social) allow for this? Experienced advice and/or examples would be very helpful, thanks.

Scroll to see replies

Reply 1
Would not recommend !
I mean if your adopting one from a shelter then I suppose your giving it a better life but it really depends how much time you spend at home. In my opinion I don’t really think it’s fair on them.
Reply 3
Original post by Amy hull 123
I mean if your adopting one from a shelter then I suppose your giving it a better life but it really depends how much time you spend at home. In my opinion I don’t really think it’s fair on them.

Like you said, it depends on how much time you spend at home, which is what I'm asking. I mean unless you're retired then generally most people who own dogs are out of the house for a large portion of the day but I don't know about a students time commitment or how routine it is during these years of med school.
You can generally expect your hours in clinical years to mostly be within 8am-5pm, with possibly a very occasional evening or night (latter generally aren’t compulsory but can be useful for learning).

I think the bigger issue is going to be travelling / distant placements. Depending on your uni and how far and wide they send people for placements, you may be expected to live out in hospital accommodation for some of your placements. Even if you choose not to live away for some of the more middle-distance ones, there may still be lengthy travelling involved at times.

Also, what would you plan to do once you graduate? FY years are definitely a lot more antisocial / irregular hours. Probably doable if you lived with a partner / others who were willing to share responsibility, but I dont think it would be doable for an FY dr living alone. You need to think long term with a pet.
Reply 5
Original post by junior.doctor
You can generally expect your hours in clinical years to mostly be within 8am-5pm, with possibly a very occasional evening or night (latter generally aren’t compulsory but can be useful for learning).

I think the bigger issue is going to be travelling / distant placements. Depending on your uni and how far and wide they send people for placements, you may be expected to live out in hospital accommodation for some of your placements. Even if you choose not to live away for some of the more middle-distance ones, there may still be lengthy travelling involved at times.

Also, what would you plan to do once you graduate? FY years are definitely a lot more antisocial / irregular hours. Probably doable if you lived with a partner / others who were willing to share responsibility, but I dont think it would be doable for an FY dr living alone. You need to think long term with a pet.

I intend to adopt a reletively older dog with a generally calm temperament as my parents have agreed that they'd be happy to take on certain breeds of dog if I could no longer keep it on graduating, however, I have heard of doctors managing to keep dogs with dog walkers for long shifts and training a dog to become accustomed to long hours alone. For example, my current dog has no major behavioural issues and can be happily left for up to 10 hours on some days, and at least 8 every other day. It is some years away for me yet, however, I very much dislike the idea of being unable to have a dog untill forming a family which could be nearly a decade or longer away!
If a doctor did own a dog would this not be taken into acount in creating rotas, or would the hospital simply say it was your responsibility to lose the dog?
Reply 6
Original post by Stickface1

If a doctor did own a dog would this not be taken into acount in creating rotas, or would the hospital simply say it was your responsibility to lose the dog?

This is a lovely idea, but does suggest you have maybe not done much research into what the job of a doctor is really like......
Original post by Stickface1
Is it realistically possible to own a dog during the latter half of a medicine degree, ie years 4 to 5/6?
I say the latter half because I am well aware that little to no university provided accommodation allows pets so for this assume that you were living in your own accomodation that allowed pets.
Also, unless anybody thinks otherwise, I am assuming that a puppy would be too much time and commitment during university so I am more thinking of the possibility of adopting a fully grown dog.
Would the time commitment of years 4 to 5/6 of medicine (both work and social) allow for this? Experienced advice and/or examples would be very helpful, thanks.

A lot of rented accommodation doesn't allow pets either, so that will be a barrier.

As mentioned, distant placements would probably be the main problem.
Original post by Stickface1
If a doctor did own a dog would this not be taken into acount in creating rotas, or would the hospital simply say it was your responsibility to lose the dog?

:laugh: :laugh:

Currently I'm having to make some complicated plan involving multiple taxis around town each week due to there being no flexibility to let me look after my child. A pet... lol no!

The NHS is a monopoly employer, and every much acts like it.
Reply 8
Original post by nexttime

Currently I'm having to make some complicated plan involving multiple taxis around town each week due to there being no flexibility to let me look after my child. A pet... lol no!

Can you not train it to be OK with being left alone for a few hours? I have with mine! Mind you, it took 16+ years........
Original post by GANFYD
Can you not train it to be OK with being left alone for a few hours? I have with mine! Mind you, it took 16+ years........

I mean, he's sufficiently light that I could probably just carry him with me at work... That New Zealand MP did it right?
Reply 10
Original post by nexttime
I mean, he's sufficiently light that I could probably just carry him with me at work... That New Zealand MP did it right?

Nobody would notice, I'm sure, but not going to be feasible for the next 15+ years, really? Although would work better with a dog.....
Original post by GANFYD
Nobody would notice, I'm sure, but not going to be feasible for the next 15+ years, really? Although would work better with a dog.....

Work would be better with a dog yes.
Reply 12
Original post by nexttime
Work would be better with a dog yes.


Everything is better with a dog!990CE08F-0EE3-4240-80BF-22B0F59CA8AD.jpg.jpeg
Original post by GANFYD
Everything is better with a dog!990CE08F-0EE3-4240-80BF-22B0F59CA8AD.jpg.jpeg


Or a sheep, apparently.
Original post by nexttime
I mean, he's sufficiently light that I could probably just carry him with me at work... That New Zealand MP did it right?

Mmm, viral baby and oncology patients - winning combination!
Original post by Stickface1
Is it realistically possible to own a dog during the latter half of a medicine degree, ie years 4 to 5/6?
I say the latter half because I am well aware that little to no university provided accommodation allows pets so for this assume that you were living in your own accomodation that allowed pets.
Also, unless anybody thinks otherwise, I am assuming that a puppy would be too much time and commitment during university so I am more thinking of the possibility of adopting a fully grown dog.
Would the time commitment of years 4 to 5/6 of medicine (both work and social) allow for this? Experienced advice and/or examples would be very helpful, thanks.

Dont. Either sponsor a dog or do BorrowMyDoggy
Reply 16
Original post by GANFYD
This is a lovely idea, but does suggest you have maybe not done much research into what the job of a doctor is really like......



To both, I think my question was along the wrong lines, I understand that shift patterns and hours are unsociable, however, I meant to refer more to extra time having to be spent at work outside of shifts. I have heard that it is not uncommon for doctors to be requested to work well beyond the 13 hour shift maximum or beyond rotared shifts which would be the sort of thing that would be unsuitable for dog owners as it cannot be planned around. Would it be possible at all for a doctor to simply say that they cannot work these sort of hours due to owning a dog or would this be unacceptable?
Ps there is not always one answer to these questions, having spoken to doctors who say that if you can't work certain hours then simply say you won't and protect your time and then others who may as well camp outside the hospital for the hours they do. I get the impression it is somewhat down to your commitment and willingness to bend over backward for the job and how confident you are to protect your time but correct me if I'm wrong as I can only go off what others have advised me for now.
Reply 17
Original post by nexttime
Or a sheep, apparently.

Black sheep and all that......
She is deeply upset, now!
Reply 18
Original post by Stickface1
To both, I think my question was along the wrong lines, I understand that shift patterns and hours are unsociable, however, I meant to refer more to extra time having to be spent at work outside of shifts. I have heard that it is not uncommon for doctors to be requested to work well beyond the 13 hour shift maximum or beyond rotared shifts which would be the sort of thing that would be unsuitable for dog owners as it cannot be planned around. Would it be possible at all for a doctor to simply say that they cannot work these sort of hours due to owning a dog or would this be unacceptable?
Ps there is not always one answer to these questions, having spoken to doctors who say that if you can't work certain hours then simply say you won't and protect your time and then others who may as well camp outside the hospital for the hours they do. I get the impression it is somewhat down to your commitment and willingness to bend over backward for the job and how confident you are to protect your time but correct me if I'm wrong as I can only go off what others have advised me for now.

You have answered your own question there. Depends whether you will walk out on sick patients or leave your colleagues unsupported? Most of us would not do that in the short term, but are not prepared to have this as an unwritten way of managing the rota
Original post by Helenia
Mmm, viral baby and oncology patients - winning combination!

I've actually called in sick today. Reason: Baby's first week of nursery.

Original post by GANFYD
Black sheep and all that......
She is deeply upset, now!

Feed her some grass that'll make her happy.

Original post by Stickface1
To both, I think my question was along the wrong lines, I understand that shift patterns and hours are unsociable, however, I meant to refer more to extra time having to be spent at work outside of shifts. I have heard that it is not uncommon for doctors to be requested to work well beyond the 13 hour shift maximum or beyond rotared shifts which would be the sort of thing that would be unsuitable for dog owners as it cannot be planned around. Would it be possible at all for a doctor to simply say that they cannot work these sort of hours due to owning a dog or would this be unacceptable?
Ps there is not always one answer to these questions, having spoken to doctors who say that if you can't work certain hours then simply say you won't and protect your time and then others who may as well camp outside the hospital for the hours they do. I get the impression it is somewhat down to your commitment and willingness to bend over backward for the job and how confident you are to protect your time but correct me if I'm wrong as I can only go off what others have advised me for now.

Normally you don't stay late after long shifts - its the kind of work where you just had it over. A few exceptions in smaller specialities, but not normally.

So, I've never owned a dog: Is it really the case that a 13 hour shift, that might be an hour or even 90 minute journey away from where you live, is not a problem for a dog?

And if it isn't, why are you worried about staying an hour or two late after an 8 hour shift every now and then?

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending