The Student Room Group

Gender affirming surgeries treated as "non essential"; as hospitals prepare for COVID

Scroll to see replies

Original post by AngeryPenguin
For transgender and gender non-conforming people, gender-affirming surgeries are life-altering procedures, which, for many, can greatly reduce gender dysphoria and improve their quality of life. But in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic, trans communities on Reddit and Twitter are being flooded with reports of postponed and canceled surgeries in the U.S., U.K., Spain, Thailand, and elsewhere, leading to enormous stress and disappointment on top of a global health crisis.

This underscores a common experience amongst trans people seeking medical care or surgery: Research has suggested that gender-affirming surgery, in particular, has a notable and long-term impact on mental health, but far too often, trans people already wait far longer than is safe or healthy for this care. Further delays can be dangerous and even life-threatening.

https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/wxekyz/transgender-surgeries-delayed-coronavirus-hospitals

One of the many ways in which the SARS2 pandemic is affecting normal people - not just the elderly and immunocompromized.

I work in the NHS in cancer care. Operations to remove cancers have been put on hold for the next few weeks. We have stopped all cancer screening. Do you have any idea about the impact of this. No probably not.
Original post by remussjhj01
Yeah, that's because it is non-essential.
This is coming from a trans man. At the present time, gender reassignment surgeries are not a priority. I get that it's disappointing-I'm wondering if I'm even going to get my first gender clinic appointment this year (which I am due to have), but if I didn't, whilst disappointing, I would understand.
Trans people aren't going to die if they don't get GRS.
This is a pandemic, not discrimination or people not caring.


At long last someone with sense.
The disgrace is that TSR hasnt removed him.
Reply 22
Original post by squeakysquirrel
I work in the NHS in cancer care. Operations to remove cancers have been put on hold for the next few weeks. We have stopped all cancer screening. Do you have any idea about the impact of this. No probably not.

Please say this is a dark joke? Why on earth would they do this? As i said in a previous comment, whilst someone 'may' die from this bug many people will die simply by delaying treatment with many cancers - especially the more aggressive ones.
Let me explain this to you, @AngryPenguin.

People who want cosmetic surgery are not going to die if they wait a short while for cosmetic surgery. People with the Wuhan coronavirus are going to die if they don't get treated for that.
Reply 24
Original post by squeakysquirrel
I work in the NHS in cancer care. Operations to remove cancers have been put on hold for the next few weeks. We have stopped all cancer screening. Do you have any idea about the impact of this. No probably not.


At long last someone with sense.

its quite stupid since cancer has a much higher death rate, we don't really need many doctors in this pandemic it's mostly nurses we need, so we should be building temporary facilities like they did in China and having nurses operate in them with few doctors reserved for the extreme cases, it shouldn't be drastically eating into our existing resources like it is
Reply 25
I've been in constant pain for the last 10 years and the surgery to stop it has been cancelled. Am I mad? No. If I was going to die of the pain then I'd have died by now. I can wait. Its more important that lives are saved.
Reply 26
Original post by Napp
Please say this is a dark joke? Why on earth would they do this? As i said in a previous comment, whilst someone 'may' die from this bug many people will die simply by delaying treatment with many cancers - especially the more aggressive ones.

Not to mention the risk of infection for cancer patients is an almost guaranteed death sentence :frown:
Original post by remussjhj01
Yeah, that's because it is non-essential.
This is coming from a trans man. At the present time, gender reassignment surgeries are not a priority. I get that it's disappointing-I'm wondering if I'm even going to get my first gender clinic appointment this year (which I am due to have), but if I didn't, whilst disappointing, I would understand.
Trans people aren't going to die if they don't get GRS.
This is a pandemic, not discrimination or people not caring.


I am sorry about this, but these are unprecedented times.

One day you will get your clinic time, and I hope you get the outcome you would like.

Big hugs from me xx
Original post by Napp
In fairness i can think of a fair few surgeries that should take priority over this. Whilst someone might die from covid someone will definitely die without an organ transplant or certain cancer related treatments (for example)

They are still carrying on cancer surgery (at least according to the BBC, and where I live)
Reply 29
Original post by Oxford Mum
They are still carrying on cancer surgery (at least according to the BBC, and where I live)

One would hope so.
Although i'm curious what would happen to the dedicated cancer hospitals like the Churchill if the covid situation really went tits up. Would it be converted into a normal hospital or continue in its specialist role?
Original post by squeakysquirrel
I work in the NHS in cancer care. Operations to remove cancers have been put on hold for the next few weeks. We have stopped all cancer screening. Do you have any idea about the impact of this. No probably not.


At long last someone with sense.

Oh no, squirrel. That's terrible.
As has been said, literally anything that isn't necessary to prevent a death in the immediate few days after is being treated as non-essential. Not just trans surgeries (which lets be clear aren't just cosmetic but are about quality of life improvement) but hip replacements, knee replacements, cancer biopsies - triage is a thing and while it does cause people inconvenience in the short to medium term, it's necessary
Original post by plainjayne1
I've been in constant pain for the last 10 years and the surgery to stop it has been cancelled. Am I mad? No. If I was going to die of the pain then I'd have died by now. I can wait. Its more important that lives are saved.

Spoken like a true heroine
Original post by Napp
One would hope so.
Although i'm curious what would happen to the dedicated cancer hospitals like the Churchill if the covid situation really went tits up. Would it be converted into a normal hospital or continue in its specialist role?

I heard that cruise ships and hotels are being converted to coronavirus wards. Much better than them standing empty.
Original post by Oxford Mum
Oh no, squirrel. That's terrible.


Original post by 3121
its quite stupid since cancer has a much higher death rate, we don't really need many doctors in this pandemic it's mostly nurses we need, so we should be building temporary facilities like they did in China and having nurses operate in them with few doctors reserved for the extreme cases, it shouldn't be drastically eating into our existing resources like it is


Original post by Napp
Please say this is a dark joke? Why on earth would they do this? As i said in a previous comment, whilst someone 'may' die from this bug many people will die simply by delaying treatment with many cancers - especially the more aggressive ones.

So as I understand it..... we have a list of patients that we discuss each week and their outcomes. They appear to be grading according to severity. So I have one patient who has an incompletely excised cancer - normally she would get an operation within a couple of weeks to remove it. She has been told that she will have to wait until after the Covid19 has died down. She is unlikely to die of cancer but if that was me I would want it done like now. I think they will probably do the most severe, but it is the bed crisis. The older patients are more likely to need an intensive care bed post operatively. They are also at more risk of contracting the virus because - old, cancer, multiple comorbidities etc. So it is a fine balancing act - what is more likely to kill them - virus or cancer. Need the wisdom of Solomon for this.

A couple of years ago I had a patient whose cancer was curable. He decided to go on a cruise that he had already booked - couple of months. By the time he came back he was palliative - still horrifies me that one.
Original post by Napp
One would hope so.
Although i'm curious what would happen to the dedicated cancer hospitals like the Churchill if the covid situation really went tits up. Would it be converted into a normal hospital or continue in its specialist role?


Good question - I reckon it would be pressed into service, at least partially. The problem there would be segregating immunocompromised cancer patients from Covid-19 ones. Alternatively, all cancer patients could be diverted to one hospital like the Churchill to keep patients well segregated.
Original post by squeakysquirrel
So as I understand it..... we have a list of patients that we discuss each week and their outcomes. They appear to be grading according to severity. So I have one patient who has an incompletely excised cancer - normally she would get an operation within a couple of weeks to remove it. She has been told that she will have to wait until after the Covid19 has died down. She is unlikely to die of cancer but if that was me I would want it done like now. I think they will probably do the most severe, but it is the bed crisis. The older patients are more likely to need an intensive care bed post operatively. They are also at more risk of contracting the virus because - old, cancer, multiple comorbidities etc. So it is a fine balancing act - what is more likely to kill them - virus or cancer. Need the wisdom of Solomon for this.

A couple of years ago I had a patient whose cancer was curable. He decided to go on a cruise that he had already booked - couple of months. By the time he came back he was palliative - still horrifies me that one.

That's a really sad story. Nobody could have predicted that. We live in awful times right now.
Original post by Oxford Mum
That's a really sad story. Nobody could have predicted that. We live in awful times right now.

Speaking from the front line we do need to get it into perspective. Most people who get the virus will have only mild symptoms. Those with comorbidities and the older patients are the ones who need to be careful.

Very thoughtful article from the BBC this morning

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-51979654
Original post by A Rolling Stone
good.

the idea of being transgender is MADE UP. you are the gender you were assigned at birth, unless intersex.

Not really relevant to this thread, though, is it
Original post by bones-mccoy
Not really relevant to this thread, though, is it

there are millions of people like the OP who genuinely think trans-appeasement should be a priority of our healthcare professionals right now

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending