Are these the results of an actual experiment? I wonder whether some of the magnesium was left unreacted.
I realise that you want to get to a formula of MgO, but from the start it looks like the amount of mass of magnesium is too great compared to the mass of oxygen. It isn't that an error in your calculations has created that problem. (Strictly speaking the Oxygen should be 0.0025/0.0025 but obviously the answer is still '1'.)
So I think going for a formula like Mg5O2 is probably the best you can do now and hope for the mark on an error carried forward basis.
You could add "I was expecting a formula of MgO – possibly some of the magnesium remained unreacted."