Punishment for a crime should not be committed by ordinary people. If he did indeed commit the rape then he should be investigated by the police and then have a lawyer to defend him in court. and if he is found guilty then he should face the music. but when people take matters into their own hands such as what happened here then what is the difference between them and the rapist?
x
Turn on thread page Beta
-
~Seraphina~
- Follow
- 16 followers
- 2 badges
- Send a private message to ~Seraphina~
Offline2ReputationRep:- Follow
- 181
- 20-10-2015 14:14
-
- Follow
- 182
- 20-10-2015 14:16
(Original post by Emily.97)
Women don't have penises.
they can only be charged with sexual assault or assault by penetration instead.
(sexual offences act 2003 S3 (3)) -
rat poison
- Follow
- 4 followers
- 2 badges
- Send a private message to rat poison
Offline2ReputationRep:- Follow
- 183
- 20-10-2015 14:17
(Original post by JeremyOU)
and because of this, women cannot rape?
they can only be charged with sexual assault or assault by penetration instead.
(sexual offences act 2003 S3 (3))
but whatever, you know best. -
- Follow
- 184
- 20-10-2015 14:18
(Original post by JeremyOU)
and because of this, women cannot rape?
they can only be charged with sexual assault or assault by penetration instead.
(sexual offences act 2003 S3 (3))
That isn't what i said, was it? The girl said that those who rape should have their penises cut off, including women. Women do not have penises, so the comment doesn't make sense. Read back and quit making assumptions. -
In One Ear
- Follow
- 6 followers
- 17 badges
- Send a private message to In One Ear
Online17ReputationRep:- Follow
- 185
- 20-10-2015 14:20
(Original post by Danz123)
All of you saying physical castration should happen to rapists are despicable tbh. Are you all barbarians? Rape is a terrible crime and the man in question deserves a lengthy prison sentence, but not to have his penis chopped off. That would break the human rights act, as article 3 of the ECHR states, "No one shall be subjected to torture or inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment."
Yes rape is a terrible thing to endure but its mainly emotional damage, the physical damage is often minor (or non-existent) and will almost certainly heal given a bit of time. A woman can (given enough time) largely get over it (some will, some won't and will forever have mental baggage but certainly most have the potential to carry on their lives as normal after a bit of healing time, for the most part).
Chopping of a man's penis on the other hand is largely destroying him as a man- he will no longer have any sexual function for the rest of his life and certainly will never be able to have kids without medical intervention (assuming his testes are left intact). Its somewhat equivalent (but not directly) to chopping a woman's breasts off, then mashing up nether regions so she has no physical sensation down there so can't possibly feel sexual pleasure, but of course such a woman could still get pregnant and have kids without medical intervention if her ovaries were fine so its still not as bad. And what about that couple of % that get falsely accused of rape...you're destroying them physically for life when they are innocent!
Rape absolutely should carry very severe punishment, but chopping a man's penis off is not what that punishment should be. -
- Follow
- 186
- 20-10-2015 14:22
(Original post by Emily.97)
Ffs.
That isn't what i said, was it? The girl said that those who rape should have their penises cut off, including women. Women do not have penises, so the comment doesn't make sense. Read back and quit making assumptions.
they can only sexually assault. -
- Follow
- 187
- 20-10-2015 14:25
(Original post by In One Ear)
Thank god someone here has a brain. Chopping someones penis off is absolutely not an appropriate punishment and its not even vaguely comparable to being raped (for all those "eye for an eye" people here).
Yes rape is a terrible thing to endure but its mainly emotional damage, the physical damage is often minor (or non-existent) and will almost certainly heal given a bit of time. A woman can (given enough time) largely get over it (some will, some won't and will forever have mental baggage but certainly most have the potential to carry on their lives as normal after a bit of healing time, for the most part).
Chopping of a man's penis on the other hand is largely destroying him as a man- he will no longer have any sexual function for the rest of his life and certainly will never be able to have kids without medical intervention (assuming his testes are left intact). Its somewhat equivalent (but not directly) to chopping a woman's breasts off, then mashing up nether regions so she has no physical sensation down there so can't possibly feel sexual pleasure, but of course such a woman could still get pregnant and have kids without medical intervention if her ovaries were fine so its still not as bad. And what about that couple of % that get falsely accused of rape...you're destroying them physically for life when they are innocent!
Rape absolutely should carry very severe punishment, but chopping a man's penis off is not what that punishment should be. -
- Follow
- 188
- 20-10-2015 14:26
(Original post by JeremyOU)
no but in Saudi Arabia rapists get 100 lashes and banishment. is that much better? -
- Follow
- 189
- 20-10-2015 14:35
(Original post by Jooooshy)
What's your point? -
- Follow
- 190
- 20-10-2015 14:36
(Original post by JeremyOU)
Britain has really nice punishments. people go to jail -
- Follow
- 191
- 20-10-2015 14:38
(Original post by Jooooshy)
Nice or appropriate? -
jeremy1988
- Follow
- 7 followers
- 11 badges
- Send a private message to jeremy1988
Offline11ReputationRep:- Follow
- 192
- 20-10-2015 14:49
I don't really feel sorry for him. Any man that rapes a woman really shouldn't have the right to reproduce.
Honestly seems sort of fair to me. You misuse it, you lose it. They used to have a rule in ancient times where they cut off the hand of a thief. This seems more reasonable than that, but along the same lines.
I mean, no, we can't really do that as an official punishment. But let's just say I wouldn't be inclined to give much of a sentence to someone who did that to a rapist in the heat of the moment if I were a judge or a jury member. LOL.
Is it barbaric? Yeah. But so is rape. I guess for crimes like rape and murder, it's just not upsetting to see a brutal punishment. Probably the two worst crimes anyone could ever commit.Last edited by jeremy1988; 20-10-2015 at 15:12. -
thunder_chunky
- Follow
- 57 followers
- 16 badges
- Send a private message to thunder_chunky
Offline16ReputationRep:- Follow
- 193
- 20-10-2015 14:59
Seems a bit barabric.
-
- Follow
- 194
- 20-10-2015 15:57
This is just wrong. But at least it wasn't the government so what can you do? :/
-
ByronicHero
- Follow
- 182 followers
- 20 badges
- Send a private message to ByronicHero
- PS Reviewer
Offline20ReputationRep:PS Reviewer- Follow
- 195
- 20-10-2015 16:09
(Original post by thunder_chunky)
Seems a bit barabric. -
- Follow
- 196
- 20-10-2015 16:19
(Original post by PrincessZara)
Why did you state he was Black, Why bring race in to things.
It's no secret that the national average on penis size in the East Asia is among the lowest. Could there also be some deep rooted envy and insecurity in this case? Because the gesture seem symbolic. -
PrincessZara
- Follow
- 67 followers
- 11 badges
- Send a private message to PrincessZara
Offline11ReputationRep:- Follow
- 197
- 20-10-2015 16:21
(Original post by Truths)
Actually the race aspect with greater context suggests a different angle/motive to the story. Black men are stereotypically associated with hyper masculinity, athleticism, strength and of course big penises. When I see this story I am immediately taken taken back to 17th century where blacks were castrated as punishment. But what is so special about a black mans penis that you cut if off after you've already lynched him? Could the driver of this practice stem from envy and insecurity.
It's no secret that the national average on penis size in the East Asia is among the lowest. Could there also be some deep rooted envy and insecurity in this case? Because the gesture seem symbolic. -
- Follow
- 198
- 20-10-2015 16:22
(Original post by PrincessZara)
So you're trying to say that he wrote the guys race to tell us that he had a big penis? wtf lmao da*** -
- Follow
- 199
- 20-10-2015 16:27
(Original post by HucktheForde)
by angry mob and was reminded that this is not india
I dont know which one is worse, the rape or the...Spoiler:Show
WARNING EXTREME GRAPHICS
http://www.dawgshed.com/threads/fore...ry-mob.163499/
look...........I have to post link from censored source to comply to forum rules. The uncensored one can be found through google search. There is one on liveleak.
Rapists don't deserve human rights -
- Follow
- 200
- 20-10-2015 16:34
(Original post by 010197)
Good.(Original post by TheonlyMrsHolmes)
Good it should happen to every rapist.(Original post by saxsan4)
Should not have raped her then(Original post by Most Competitive)
Serves him right imo(Original post by zyzzyspirit)
Ahaha, karma's a ***** isn't it?(Original post by driftawaay)
Cool. This shoould be law everywhere.(Original post by sparkletoo)
Good. He certainly won't be raping anyone else anytime soon. Clean, swift justice executed finely. Next.(Original post by z33)
good, this should be done to every rapist - man or woman
How would you feel if you got castrated because someone simply pointed the finger at you? You guys need to get into critical thinking instead of being so emotional.
Reply
Submit reply
Turn on thread page Beta
Related discussions:
TSR Support Team
We have a brilliant team of more than 60 Support Team members looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.
This forum is supported by:
Updated: October 24, 2015
Share this discussion:
Tweet