I read somewhere that if you're having a lucid dream, the way to tell is to try and turn a light on. Apparently you can't switch lights on in dreams.
Is there a definitive way to establish if you're dreaming or awake? Watch
- 02-12-2010 21:54
- 02-12-2010 22:04
I doubt you could tell for a non-lucid dream. Dreams are believed to be fragments of jumbled of memories streaming through, which your brain tries to interpret in the same way it interprets while conscious (hence why you report dreams as having a plot). No matter how ridiculous the situation you would still believe that was real.
As for the simulation idea, quite frankly I don't see why it would matter even if we were living in a simulation.
(Original post by whythehellnot)
- 02-12-2010 23:50
Yet you've made no attempt to enrich our understanding of the subject. It may well be stupid, perhaps even pointless, but I can't see why we wouldn't take it seriously. If, like many people, you think our senses are the main source of knowledge, then this thought experiment brings into question all knowledge ascertained through sense experience. How is this not to be taken seriously?
There are all manner of crazy possibilities in life but only a finite amount of time; this one is so crazy that it's not really worth thinking about.Last edited by electriic_ink; 02-12-2010 at 23:52.
- 02-12-2010 23:59
I often have dreams in which I remember I've had the dream before (regardless of whether I had or not) and proceeded to tell those around me not to worry because it is, in fact, a dream. This is usually then followed by me attempting to wake myself up as a crocodile tries to get in through my bedroom window. :-/
We discussed this a lot in Philosophy lessons to avoid any actual work and the argument was put forward that maybe there isn't even an 'awake' state. We could all be living in a constant dream state, individually creating our lives around us. Total mind f*ck. Man I loved those philosophy lessons!
(Original post by KayK)
- 03-12-2010 01:15
Not sure if i understand exactly what you mean or whether this may be of any relevance: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucid_d...eality_testing
Anyhow, I would really reccomend learning lucid dreaming. It is an amazing experience, and really, practice is the only way to know if you are dreaming. Not feeling pain is a myth, and most anomalies is only recognizable if you are trained in looking for them.
(Original post by Lewis :D)
- 03-12-2010 18:33
I know this is weird but I can tell when I'm in a dream, everything is confusing and nothing is easy to do.
OP: I think the general rule is that you are aware of your consciousness when awake, although you are unaware of your unconsciousness when you're asleep.
- 03-12-2010 21:00
anyone heard of disassociative disorder?
its the feeling that everything feels unreal and that you are in a dream, i used to have it, its not as cool as you think, its pretty unpleasant actually. It can occur for different reasons, sometimes in can occur with people who have pro-longed depression, they have depression for so long that their body defends itself from feeling the pain of the depression by completely dulling all the senses and making the world feel far away, hence why it feels like life is like a dream. Its like becoming vegetated emotionally.
- 10-12-2010 02:33
No, there is no way to establish you are not dreaming.
All I can say is that those who believe they are dreaming betray themselves with their behaviour.
Feel free to disagree!
(Original post by whythehellnot)
- 24-12-2010 21:17
Classic Descartes. Can you beyond a doubt tell if you're a awake as opposed to dreaming?
Perhaps there is no fool proof method for this, maybe there is. Either way, what methods could be employed (regardless of if they're fool proof) to attempt to establish if we're sleeping or not?
My friend suggested that we cannot feel pain whilst we sleep, which is where the expression "pinch me I must be dreaming" surely comes from.
Also trying to read a digital clock in dreams is meant to be a test too.