This discussion is closed.
Mentally Ill
Badges: 0
Rep:
?
#421
Report 16 years ago
#421
(Original post by Tek)
I would have thought that interviews were an ideal place to assess candidates' potential and enthusiasm. Because so many people are attaining straight As nowadays they need a way of distinguishing candidates.
Well how do you display TRUE enthusiasm? and even more important, Potential?

People watch much television nowadays, and acting tips are readily available.
0
manu
Badges: 0
#422
Report 16 years ago
#422
(Original post by Tek)
I would have thought that interviews were an ideal place to assess candidates' potential and enthusiasm. Because so many people are attaining straight As nowadays they need a way of distinguishing candidates.
i agree.

esp with comparing international and british applicants, who come from completely different school systems...
0
lizzzy`
Badges: 0
Rep:
?
#423
Report 16 years ago
#423
(Original post by Mentally Ill)
Yeah, dunno what they thought of my tooth...they kept staring into my mouth.....or perhaps they were thinking "such lovely lips, I would love to snog him"??? god knows.

I think I would have been ok in Jeans. besides, they want to simulate a supervision...i would never dream of wearning anything other than jeans to a tutorial......
Maybe it would have been ok. But what if your interview was some pompous old don who thinks everyone should be dressed in suits?
(for example)
0
Tek
Badges: 7
Rep:
?
#424
Report 16 years ago
#424
(Original post by Mentally Ill)
Well how do you display TRUE enthusiasm? and even more important, Potential?

People watch much television nowadays, and acting tips are readily available.
The simple fact remains that interviewsers need a way to set candidates apart and a face to face meeting is the best way to do it. I am not suggesting for a minute that the interviews are foolproof, but they seem to be as good as it gets.
0
manu
Badges: 0
#425
Report 16 years ago
#425
(Original post by lizzzy`)
Someone who applied to Oxford a few years ago went dressed pretty scruffily...and the interview report came back and half of it was about his scruffiness...so not such a good idea:|
do we all get an interview report? how can we find out what they thought of us?
0
Mentally Ill
Badges: 0
Rep:
?
#426
Report 16 years ago
#426
(Original post by manu)
i agree.

esp with comparing international and british applicants, who come from completely different school systems...
Is it not true that international applicants are not called for interview?

Clearly, Oxbridge do not feel that interviews are all that useful for comparing these kinds of applications.
0
lizzzy`
Badges: 0
Rep:
?
#427
Report 16 years ago
#427
(Original post by manu)
i agree.

esp with comparing international and british applicants, who come from completely different school systems...
International applicants get asked stuff which is more on the Personal Statement than anything else, and less of the random, logic questions that Cambridge throws at the British applicants.
So if you like, the International application seems to be an easier one. But on the other hand, places are very limited, and set with a quota.
0
lizzzy`
Badges: 0
Rep:
?
#428
Report 16 years ago
#428
(Original post by manu)
do we all get an interview report? how can we find out what they thought of us?
Your school/college should probably receive one automatically, but I think in most cases it is only if you get rejected You can get your tutor/head to write to them to ask, if you like. Don't know if they will oblige you though, depends on the college and how busy they are?
0
manu
Badges: 0
#429
Report 16 years ago
#429
(Original post by Mentally Ill)
Is it not true that international applicants are not called for interview?

Clearly, Oxbridge do not feel that interviews are all that useful for comparing these kinds of applications.
well im not an international applicant (coz germany does happen to be part of the EU), but i'm not from england (well, yes originally i am, but for now:i'm not) and did get an interview.

lizzy is right, i hardly got any logical questions in either interview, but then again i am applying for architecture and it was all more about my portfolio.
0
lizzzy`
Badges: 0
Rep:
?
#430
Report 16 years ago
#430
(Original post by Mentally Ill)
Is it not true that international applicants are not called for interview?

Clearly, Oxbridge do not feel that interviews are all that useful for comparing these kinds of applications.
Some are, and some aren't. Dr Bowkett, the admissions tutor for Christ's, travels to Singapore and Malaysia each year to interview applicants there (for most colleges, not only Christ's, for science subs)
0
lizzzy`
Badges: 0
Rep:
?
#431
Report 16 years ago
#431
(Original post by manu)
well im not an international applicant (coz germany does happen to be part of the EU), but i'm not from england (well, yes originally i am, but for now:i'm not) and did get an interview.

lizzy is right, i hardly got any logical questions in either interview, but then again i am applying for architecture and it was all more about my portfolio.
They would be more interested in your portfolio rather than trying to see how you think on your feet because it is Architecture
0
Seer
Badges: 0
Rep:
?
#432
Report 16 years ago
#432
Philosophy owns all other subjects!
0
Mentally Ill
Badges: 0
Rep:
?
#433
Report 16 years ago
#433
(Original post by Tek)
The simple fact remains that interviewsers need a way to set candidates apart and a face to face meeting is the best way to do it. I am not suggesting for a minute that the interviews are foolproof, but they seem to be as good as it gets.
Yes, I agree - the simple fact is that interviewers need a way to set candidates apart. a face to face meeting may seem the best option at first.....but hundreds of years of experience have shown that it doesnt work well. Interviewers have feelings, and a naive interviewee may make a stupid mistake that offends the interviewee and thats the end of it for them! For example, I once knew someone whose int was going well until at the end he said "you do know that imp coll have made me an offer". The interviewer clearly thought he was trying some kind of 'blackmail' - for want of a better/more appropriate word. Now should this idiotic comment mean he should not be made an offer, despite almost having it in the bag prior to his silly statement?

It would be just as 'fair' to pick names out of a hat.
0
manu
Badges: 0
#434
Report 16 years ago
#434
(Original post by lizzzy`)
They would be more interested in your portfolio rather than trying to see how you think on your feet because it is Architecture
exactly.

although they did ask me some architectural questions, would have been surprised if not ;-)
0
lizzzy`
Badges: 0
Rep:
?
#435
Report 16 years ago
#435
(Original post by Seer)
Philosophy owns all other subjects!
Medicine rocks
0
Seer
Badges: 0
Rep:
?
#436
Report 16 years ago
#436
Not really. The hat is a complete lottery; whether you make idiotic comments or not isn't.
0
lizzzy`
Badges: 0
Rep:
?
#437
Report 16 years ago
#437
(Original post by manu)
exactly.

although they did ask me some architectural questions, would have been surprised if not ;-)
Haha. I would have been worried if I was applying for Architecture and they didn't.
0
lizzzy`
Badges: 0
Rep:
?
#438
Report 16 years ago
#438
(Original post by Seer)
Not really. The hat is a complete lottery; whether you make idiotic comments or not isn't.
I think the general rule would be try not to behave in an offensive manner
0
manu
Badges: 0
#439
Report 16 years ago
#439
(Original post by Mentally Ill)
Yes, I agree - the simple fact is that interviewers need a way to set candidates apart. a face to face meeting may seem the best option at first.....but hundreds of years of experience have shown that it doesnt work well. Interviewers have feelings, and a naive interviewee may make a stupid mistake that offends the interviewee and thats the end of it for them! For example, I once knew someone whose int was going well until at the end he said "you do know that imp coll have made me an offer". The interviewer clearly thought he was trying some kind of 'blackmail' - for want of a better/more appropriate word. Now should this idiotic comment mean he should not be made an offer, despite almost having it in the bag prior to his silly statement?

It would be just as 'fair' to pick names out of a hat.
it would be fair. and thats (partly) what they do in germany, resulting in there being no such standout unis as (oxbridge) in britain.
0
Seer
Badges: 0
Rep:
?
#440
Report 16 years ago
#440
My outfit was basically, black loafers, black chinos, pink shirt with jumper of the top, I think that was adequate At least I hope so
0
X
new posts
Back
to top
Latest
My Feed

See more of what you like on
The Student Room

You can personalise what you see on TSR. Tell us a little about yourself to get started.

Personalise

Had lockdown impacted your relationships?

Yes, my partner and I are struggling (36)
7.47%
Yes, my partner and I broke up (38)
7.88%
Yes, it's hard being around my family so much (115)
23.86%
Yes, I'm feeling lonely isolating alone (68)
14.11%
No, nothing has changed (147)
30.5%
No, it's helped improve my relationships (78)
16.18%

Watched Threads

View All