Five year old in court Watch

Badges: 14
Report Thread starter 8 years ago
Has anyone else seen this silliness?

A five-year-old Irish boy who was wrongly accused of stealing a bag of crisps has won 7,500 euros damages for defamation of character.

The case, reported in the Irish Times on Wednesday, concerned Tadhg Mooney from Balbriggan in County Dublin.

The court heard he was in a local branch of Lidl with his mother in June 2009 when a shop assistant grabbed his arm and made the accusation.

His barrister told the court her client had suffered injury to his reputation.

She added that, Tadhg, now aged six, had also been caused to suffer distress and inconvenience.

The Circuit Civil Court also heard that the action of the shop assistant in grabbing the boy's arm amounted to false imprisonment and assault.

The barrister told the judge, Mr Justice Matthew Deery, that she was recommending acceptance by the court of a settlement offer of 7,500 euros and costs by Lidl Ireland Ltd.

Mr Justice Deery approved the offer.

On Wednesday, the family's lawyer Dermot McNamara told the AFP wire service that Tadhg's mother had shown a receipt for the bag of crisps to the store.

However, he said the shop manager failed to take her concerns seriously, causing her to take legal proceedings against the firm for slander, for false imprisonment, assault and negligence.

"We managed to settle it over negotiations lasting for a month or two," Mr McNamara said.

Defamation against his character? Are you serious? He's five years old!

EDIT: Beaten to it by someone else. Sorry for the extra thread :P
Badges: 0
Report 8 years ago
Looks like Ireland's not to far from this so-called American-style suing culture.

But at least the child now has tonnes of pocket money after this scuffle, which tbqh is quite an overreaction on the shop assistant's part, would a shop assistant try to be a vigilante if someone actually stole from their store?

Quick Reply

Attached files
Write a reply...
new posts
My Feed

See more of what you like on
The Student Room

You can personalise what you see on TSR. Tell us a little about yourself to get started.


Were you ever put in isolation at school?

Yes (84)
No (239)

Watched Threads

View All