Hello , I need a bit of help sorry if this is a stupid question, but its confusing the heck out of me.
Here is the question and how the book solves the question.
a) I got correct. so no issue.
bi) i got it right. the graph is moving 2 in the xdirection each x coordinate of the orignal graph will be shifted by 2, which gives new x coordinates of 2 and 2. As for the y coordinate this is what I did
I replaced x in the original equation f(x)=x(x4) with (x+2) to get y= (x+2)(x2).
i put x=0 and got 2x2 = 4 . so the y coordinate 4 which is correct.
MY QUESITON 1
my quesiton is i dont see any working to find the y coordinate in part bi. which makes me think im doing it wrong. can you see where i have gone wrong
MY QUESITON 2
why dont they have any working for the y intercept.
Thanks and sorry if this is a silly question

jayseanfan
 Follow
 6 followers
 1 badge
 Send a private message to jayseanfan
 Thread Starter
Offline1ReputationRep: Follow
 1
 07122010 20:39
Last edited by jayseanfan; 07122010 at 20:41. 
jayseanfan
 Follow
 6 followers
 1 badge
 Send a private message to jayseanfan
 Thread Starter
Offline1ReputationRep: Follow
 2
 07122010 21:46
ive been waiting a whole hour and still no reply

 Follow
 3
 07122010 21:48
What do you need help with? Do you need help with finding where the lines cross the axes in part c) of the question?

 Follow
 4
 07122010 21:51
1) You don't need to do any more working for the minimum because you know that since f(x) is always greater than or equal to 4, then f(stuff) is always greater than or equal to 4, whatever 'stuff' is.
2) I'm not sure what you're asking. They increase all y coordinates by 4 if y is now f(x)+4 as opposed to just f(x) 
 Follow
 5
 07122010 21:52
QUESTION 2:
To find the yintercept, put in x=0 in the function.
Not sure what your first question is, do you want to find the coordinates of the minimum point? 
jayseanfan
 Follow
 6 followers
 1 badge
 Send a private message to jayseanfan
 Thread Starter
Offline1ReputationRep: Follow
 6
 07122010 22:33
Most of the replies seem confused by my quesiton. Sorry. Let me try and explain again.
I done part a and had no problems.
part bi is where im getting confused.
Basically the questions asking you to apply the transformation y=f(x+2) to the curve f(x)=x(x4)
The curve is being moved by 2 along the x axis, this means the new x coordinates will be 2 and 2.
I get that bit.
So lets say i drew on my curve crossing the xaxis at 2 and 2.
I can see that the curve intercepts the yaxis. so i obviously have to label that on otherwise il loose marks and i dont know what it is. so i try and find it. I replaced x in the original equation f(x)=x(x4) with (x+2) to get y= (x+2)(x2).
i put x=0 and got 2x2 = 4 . so the y coordinate 4
which i now label on the graph.
what i dont get is for their working on bi (take a look at the pic for Bi) you will see their is no working to find the ycoordinate. I understand why there isn't any working for the x coordinate , but i dont understand why there is no working for the y coordinate. this is were im thinking I am supposed to have calculated the yintercept a different way. Because my way took some time and on their "how to do it" marking scheme. there is no calcultion for the yintercept.
I hope that clears thingsLast edited by jayseanfan; 07122010 at 22:35. 
 Follow
 7
 07122010 23:04
(Original post by jayseanfan)
Most of the replies seem confused by my quesiton. Sorry. Let me try and explain again.
I done part a and had no problems.
part bi is where im getting confused.
Basically the questions asking you to apply the transformation y=f(x+2) to the curve f(x)=x(x4)
The curve is being moved by 2 along the x axis, this means the new x coordinates will be 2 and 2.
I get that bit.
So lets say i drew on my curve crossing the xaxis at 2 and 2.
I can see that the curve intercepts the yaxis. so i obviously have to label that on otherwise il loose marks and i dont know what it is. so i try and find it. I replaced x in the original equation f(x)=x(x4) with (x+2) to get y= (x+2)(x2).
i put x=0 and got 2x2 = 4 . so the y coordinate 4
which i now label on the graph.
what i dont get is for their working on bi (take a look at the pic for Bi) you will see their is no working to find the ycoordinate. I understand why there isn't any working for the x coordinate , but i dont understand why there is no working for the y coordinate. this is were im thinking I am supposed to have calculated the yintercept a different way. Because my way took some time and on their "how to do it" marking scheme. there is no calcultion for the yintercept.
I hope that clears things
Probably the reason why they split this bit into a separate part is to make sure that you do actually go to the trouble of calculating the intersections, rather than just leaving them unlabelled on your sketch. 
 Follow
 8
 07122010 23:15
(Original post by jayseanfan)
Most of the replies seem confused by my quesiton. Sorry. Let me try and explain again.
I done part a and had no problems.
part bi is where im getting confused.
Basically the questions asking you to apply the transformation y=f(x+2) to the curve f(x)=x(x4)
The curve is being moved by 2 along the x axis, this means the new x coordinates will be 2 and 2.
I get that bit.
So lets say i drew on my curve crossing the xaxis at 2 and 2.
I can see that the curve intercepts the yaxis. so i obviously have to label that on otherwise il loose marks and i dont know what it is. so i try and find it. I replaced x in the original equation f(x)=x(x4) with (x+2) to get y= (x+2)(x2).
i put x=0 and got 2x2 = 4 . so the y coordinate 4
which i now label on the graph.
what i dont get is for their working on bi (take a look at the pic for Bi) you will see their is no working to find the ycoordinate. I understand why there isn't any working for the x coordinate , but i dont understand why there is no working for the y coordinate. this is were im thinking I am supposed to have calculated the yintercept a different way. Because my way took some time and on their "how to do it" marking scheme. there is no calcultion for the yintercept.
I hope that clears thingsLast edited by roar558; 07122010 at 23:17. 
 Follow
 9
 07122010 23:27
(Original post by jayseanfan)
Most of the replies seem confused by my quesiton. Sorry. Let me try and explain again.
I done part a and had no problems.
part bi is where im getting confused.
Basically the questions asking you to apply the transformation y=f(x+2) to the curve f(x)=x(x4)
The curve is being moved by 2 along the x axis, this means the new x coordinates will be 2 and 2.
I get that bit.
So lets say i drew on my curve crossing the xaxis at 2 and 2.
I can see that the curve intercepts the yaxis. so i obviously have to label that on otherwise il loose marks and i dont know what it is. so i try and find it. I replaced x in the original equation f(x)=x(x4) with (x+2) to get y= (x+2)(x2).
i put x=0 and got 2x2 = 4 . so the y coordinate 4
which i now label on the graph.
what i dont get is for their working on bi (take a look at the pic for Bi) you will see their is no working to find the ycoordinate. I understand why there isn't any working for the x coordinate , but i dont understand why there is no working for the y coordinate. this is were im thinking I am supposed to have calculated the yintercept a different way. Because my way took some time and on their "how to do it" marking scheme. there is no calcultion for the yintercept.
I hope that clears things 
 Follow
 10
 07122010 23:33
(Original post by chrypton)
I think the reason there is no working for the ycoordinate is because it is very clear from the graphs. 
jayseanfan
 Follow
 6 followers
 1 badge
 Send a private message to jayseanfan
 Thread Starter
Offline1ReputationRep: Follow
 11
 07122010 23:33
(Original post by ttoby)
In the answers for part c, they do calculate the axis intersections (including the one you are referring to). So what they probably expect you to do is sketch the graphs in part b, then do part c and once you know the required axis intersections to go back and label them on your graphs.
Probably the reason why they split this bit into a separate part is to make sure that you do actually go to the trouble of calculating the intersections, rather than just leaving them unlabelled on your sketch.
Because yes you know the graph is translated by +4 in the y axis. and since the original y interception is at 0 this means the curve will cut 4. but how are you supposed to know that the graph just touches the xaxis at 2? I could have draw it like this
i wouldn't have know the curve touches the xaxis at 2 till i get to part c and calculated the x intercept (which is not a intercept in this case but you know what i mean). say there wasn't a part c ?
Im so confused. I understand the general concept but im getting confused by when your supposed to do what.Last edited by jayseanfan; 07122010 at 23:35. 
 Follow
 12
 07122010 23:36
(Original post by jayseanfan)
This is what I though too. But then i dont get how you are supposed to sketch BII.
Because yes you know the graph is translated by +4 in the y axis. and since the original y interception is at 0 this means the curve will cut 4. but how are you supposed to know that the graph just touches the xaxis at 2? I could have draw it like this
i wouldn't have know the curve touches the xaxis at 2 its till i get to part c and calculated the x intercept (which is not a intercept in this case but you know what i mean). say there wasn't a part c ?
Im so confused. I understand the general concept but im getting confused by when your supposed to do what. 
 Follow
 13
 07122010 23:40
(Original post by jayseanfan)
This is what I though too. But then i dont get how you are supposed to sketch BII.
Because yes you know the graph is translated by +4 in the y axis. and since the original y interception is at 0 this means the curve will cut 4. but how are you supposed to know that the graph just touches the xaxis at 2? I could have draw it like this
i wouldn't have know the curve touches the xaxis at 2 till i get to part c and calculated the x intercept (which is not a intercept in this case but you know what i mean). say there wasn't a part c ?
Im so confused. I understand the general concept but im getting confused by when your supposed to do what.Last edited by roar558; 07122010 at 23:42. 
jayseanfan
 Follow
 6 followers
 1 badge
 Send a private message to jayseanfan
 Thread Starter
Offline1ReputationRep: Follow
 14
 07122010 23:42
(Original post by roar558)
ah yes that's true, in this sort of equation, distance between the two points of intersection=distance above or below x axis, ie 2(2)=4, as the graph has a U shape, the point of intersection =4
Can i even use it or C1? and when can i use it ? Or am i better of translating the graph accoding to the rule and then put x=0 or y=0 to see where the curve intercepts the x or y axis? 
jayseanfan
 Follow
 6 followers
 1 badge
 Send a private message to jayseanfan
 Thread Starter
Offline1ReputationRep: Follow
 15
 07122010 23:51
so what would u guys say to conclude
is it okay if i just apply the transformaiton first
and then just calculate the x intercept by y=0 OR the y intercept by x=0 
 Follow
 16
 07122010 23:51
(Original post by jayseanfan)
I didn't know that rule.
Can i even use it or C1? and when can i use it ? Or am i better of translating the graph accoding to the rule and then put x=0 or y=0 to see where the curve intercepts the x or y axis? 
 Follow
 17
 07122010 23:53
(Original post by jayseanfan)
so what would u guys say to conclude
is it okay if i just apply the transformaiton first
and then just calculate the x intercept by y=0 OR the y intercept by x=0 
 Follow
 18
 08122010 00:01
In this case, that calculation would be finding the minimum point of the curve to see if it's above or below or touching the x axis.
Reply
Submit reply
Related discussions:
 C1 Differentiation question
 c1 Tomorrow mock paper
 c1 question
 C1 (AS LEVEL/SOLOMON PAPER) Graph question
 The MEGA AS Level Maths Question Countdown  63 DAYS ...
 C1 Maths help graphical question
 Most embarrassing/stupid exam mistake you've made?
 C1 question, quick help.
 AQA GCSE Chemistry C1 Unofficial Markscheme 2017
 Arsey's Edexcel C1 Summer 2013 Model Solutions BOTH ...
TSR Support Team
We have a brilliant team of more than 60 Support Team members looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.
This forum is supported by:
 SherlockHolmes
 Notnek
 charco
 Mr M
 TSR Moderator
 Nirgilis
 usycool1
 Changing Skies
 James A
 rayquaza17
 RDKGames
 randdom
 davros
 Gingerbread101
 Kvothe the Arcane
 The Financier
 The Empire Odyssey
 Protostar
 TheConfusedMedic
 nisha.sri
 Reality Check
 claireestelle
 Doonesbury
 furryface12
 Amefish
 harryleavey
 Lemur14
 brainzistheword
 Rexar
 Sonechka
 LeCroissant
 EstelOfTheEyrie
 CoffeeAndPolitics
 an_atheist
 Moltenmo
Updated: December 8, 2010
Share this discussion:
Tweet