The Student Room Group

This discussion is now closed.

Check out other Related discussions

Do English Catholics Celebrate Guy Fawkes Night?

Scroll to see replies

Reply 40
So just to clarify, trick or treating occurs on Halloween, and then all bonfires/fireworks are on 5th November (or the weekend nearest to it anyway).

I seriously doubt many people nowadays know the religious significance of Guy Fawkes night..to most people it's just Bonfire Night and a good excuse for a nice firework display and a big bonfire when it's cold outside :smile:.

Cxx
SamTheMan
For some reason, Newfoundland (a Canadian province, independent till 1949) takes bonfire night very seriously and it's part of their traditions. I think after Britain, that's probably the place where it's most celebrated.


I remember canuck mentioning this last year. :smile:
--------------
2 5 +
I thought glorification of terrorism was illegal now?


Guy Fawkes wasn't involved in terrorism, it was high treason. :smile:
Reply 42
Woodsy
Just wondering, I know that here in Northern Ireland the very suggestion for Catholics would be unheard of, I'm actually not sure if Protestants here in NI celebrate 5th November either, anybody tell me?

We have bonfires on Halloween night instead of 5th Nov. Just to open this up, what do the English, Scottish, Welsh actually do on Halloween Night? Fireworks etc is it?Do you do trick or treating and then penny for the guy thing on 5th Nov?

Surely, Catholics celebrating Guy Fawkes Night would lack logic? Let's be controversial, is the celebrating of Guy Fawkes Night politically incorrect? lol


1) You are incorrect, some Catholics in N.I do celebrate the 5th of November as do some Protestants, it's a celebration and most don't care anymore about it's origins.

2) A lot of things the Catholics/Protestants do in N.I lack logic. Don't even bother mentioning what is and what isn't politically correct in N.I because the overwelming majority in N.I do not care, it's the very small minority hardliners that take these things seriously.

3) Why have you got the Republic of Irelands flag when you have stated above you're from Northern Ireland? :wink:
Woodsy
In a society were the death penalty is long abolished


What? All of 7 years you mean? :rolleyes:

Woodsy
It strikes of the Orange Order and the Battle of the Boyne.


And the celebration of Christmas and Easter etc itself strikes to me of foreign blood interfering with the once druid lands that was once here.

Woodsy
I mean, for Christ sake you still can't be a Catholic and be Monarch - all it would take would be a piece of legislation transferring the head of the Church of England title to the Archbishop of Canterbury, sorted. Equality - my arse.


I'm sorry but Catholicism isn't perfect for equality now is it? Female bishops? Homosexuality?
guy fawkeswas trying to free ireland from british rule. what about the mass murder for the last 800 year the british government did on the irish people
Reply 45
2narrucluap
guy fawkeswas trying to free ireland from british rule. what about the mass murder for the last 800 year the british government did on the irish people


...what? Was any of that based in historical fact?
john171
1) You are incorrect, some Catholics in N.I do celebrate the 5th of November as do some Protestants, it's a celebration and most don't care anymore about it's origins.

2) A lot of things the Catholics/Protestants do in N.I lack logic. Don't even bother mentioning what is and what isn't politically correct in N.I because the overwelming majority in N.I do not care, it's the very small minority hardliners that take these things seriously.

3) Why have you got the Republic of Irelands flag when you have stated above you're from Northern Ireland? :wink:


because hes irish. im from belfast and have an irish passport. therefore im irish
What about the mass murder by the Romans? :rolleyes:
Poica
...what? Was any of that based in historical fact?


yes. ever hear of Collusion, hunger strikers, bloody sunday, the famine, colinisation,
Reply 49
2narrucluap
because hes irish. im from belfast and have an irish passport. therefore im irish


where were you born?
technik
where were you born?

belfast
Reply 51
2narrucluap
guy fawkeswas trying to free ireland from british rule. what about the mass murder for the last 800 year the british government did on the irish people


Any evidence that Guy Fawkes was trying to free Ireland? Any at all?

And Ireland is a very troubled place, and some mistakes have been made by the British Government regarding dealing with situations, but this does not in any way amount to mass murder.
2narrucluap
guy fawkeswas trying to free ireland from british rule.

What on earth? Freeing Ireland from British rule was probably the last thing on Guy Fawkes's mind! He had no connection with Ireland (both sides of his family came from York) - his intentions, as were those of the other conspiritors - were to kill those who suppressed and discriminated against Catholics.
Reply 53
2narrucluap
colinisation,


Yes, we evil Brits forced you all to name your first-born children 'Colin'... regardless of gender. That was until that meddling European Court of Human Rights got wind of it...

Can we now ignore the Irish sectarian trolls for a bit...
Reply 54
Do English Catholics Celebrate Guy Fawkes Night?


Yes.
Reply 55
2narrucluap
belfast


just one of these pseudo-irish folk due to the dodgy passport regulations operating between the UK and ROI then?
Reply 56
technik
just one of these pseudo-irish folk due to the dodgy passport regulations operating between the UK and ROI then?


As long as you are born on the Island of Ireland you are without doubt Irish.

To be honest, you are one of those Pseudo-British people clinging onto an Island that really hasn't wanted you for the past 50 odd years but is **** scared to give you up. How must that feel? Idiot.
--------------
HistoryStudent
What on earth? Freeing Ireland from British rule was probably the last thing on Guy Fawkes's mind! He had no connection with Ireland (both sides of his family came from York) - his intentions, as were those of the other conspiritors - were to kill those who suppressed and discriminated against Catholics.


Don't care whether he did or not, do you realise that for at least 300 years 95% of the people of Ireland (Catholics) had neither the vote nor representation at Westminster.
Reply 57
Woodsy
As long as you are born on the Island of Ireland you are without doubt Irish.


perhaps. this is a reference to passports however which doesnt give a flying fluck what island is what. though, seeings its the british isles...we can play that silly game if you want.

Woodsy
To be honest, you are one of those Pseudo-British people clinging onto an Island that really hasn't wanted you for the past 50 odd years but is **** scared to give you up. How must that feel? Idiot.


fortunately im just british and will be until the day i die. and try the little englander routine if you wish, it means little and is truly idiotic.
Reply 58
Woodsy
Don't care whether he did or not, do you realise that for at least 300 years 95% of the people of Ireland (Catholics) had neither the vote nor representation at Westminster.

You seem to be completely ignorant to the fact that atleast 99% of the entire of the British population would not have had a vote at this time - so comparatively the Irish catholics would have lived in a significantly more democratic environment.
Reply 59
bikerx23
You seem to be completely ignorant to the fact that atleast 99% of the entire of the British population would not have had a vote at this time - so comparatively the Irish catholics would have lived in a significantly more democratic environment.


ignore him. he has little clue.