This discussion is now closed.

Check out other Related discussions

Aragog or Shelob?

eeve02

Out of both these giant spiders from Harry potter and Lord of the rings which would win in a fight?

Reply 1

Tnacilppa

eeve02

Out of both these giant spiders from Harry potter and Lord of the rings which would win in a fight?

Quite clearly Aragog! :wink:

He'd get all his other spiders to join in the attack. Shelob is a lonely spider who should get out more!

Reply 2

Eru Iluvatar

18

Shelob is infinitely better, simply because she doesn't come from harry potter!

Reply 3

littleredfrog

aragog simply because he's huge and has a scary voice and an army full of lots of little and big spiders. then again spiders are scary anyway so either would win f they fought against me!!! im a little red frog im gonna lose!!! :frown:

and plus harry potter is a great film and it does deserve to have the winning spider!!

Reply 4

tessie

depends, if it was a one on one fight shelob would definetly win cos she was a way scarier spider (also with real spiders the females kill the males after mating with them), but if aragog got the rest of the nest to help him he would win.

Reply 5

Ketio

tessie

depends, if it was a one on one fight shelob would definetly win cos she was a way scarier spider (also with real spiders the females kill the males after mating with them), but if aragog got the rest of the nest to help him he would win.

Yeah if it was one on one Shelob would win because she's much stronger....aragog is an old fogey

Reply 6

Kyrotec

Shelob also had an army of spiders - Rowling seriously copied off Tolkien.
Compare the Night riders to Dementors!
Shelob :tongue:

Reply 7

hitchhiker_13

11

Shelob obviously.
It's the law of diminishing returns. As Aragog is a blatant rip-off, he/she/it cannot possibly be as good.

Reply 8

cellochickee

Nay, I will go with Aragog, simply because it has a large possy of spiders. I think that Shelob is worse, though.

Reply 9

Sam2k

11

I would have to go with aragog because Shelob can't see because she got stabbed in the eye.

Reply 10

cellochickee

moncal

I would have to go with aragog because Shelob can't see because she got stabbed in the eye.

Hah, excellent point.

Reply 11

Koolguy

Excluding the fact that her eye was stabbed, I say, Shelob... Definately.

Reply 12

George-W-Duck

2

Kyrotec

Shelob also had an army of spiders - Rowling seriously copied off Tolkien.
Compare the Night riders to Dementors!
Shelob :tongue:

The number of glaringly obvious tolkien rip offs in harry potter is the main thing that spoilt the books for me.

Reply 13

riffraff

1

shelob, because although she did get stabbed in the eye, she has multiple eyes and thus can still see pretty good. also because i hate Rowling's blatant copying of LOTR. Dammit- why couldn't Aragog kill the little squirt?

Reply 14

George-W-Duck

2

riffraff

shelob, because although she did get stabbed in the eye, she has multiple eyes and thus can still see pretty good. also because i hate Rowling's blatant copying of LOTR. Dammit- why couldn't Aragog kill the little squirt?

If your publishers were paying you millions per book would you kill him off??? :smile:

Reply 15

mojosephene

George-W-Duck

If your publishers were paying you millions per book would you kill him off??? :smile:

Reply 16

George-W-Duck

2

Oh it is a nice day when you are so loved that people quote me just for the sake of quoting me :smile:

Reply 17

mojosephene

George-W-Duck

Oh it is a nice day when you are so loved that people quote me just for the sake of quoting me :smile:

Reply 18

mojosephene

George-W-Duck

Oh it is a nice day when you are so loved that people quote me just for the sake of quoting me :smile:

Reply 19

poowpoow

aragog ................#shudder#