Okay I recently just passed my grade 8 clarinet and I am ready to move away from the instrument and start playing saxophone since I absolutely love jazz (stuff like youngblood brass band)
tenor or alto sax?
I believe that tenor sax fingering is somewhat similar to clarinet and also since they're both in Bb its probably easier for me to recognise pitches etc.
However I also love the sound of the alto sax...
Anyone got any tips or have actually moved from clarinet to saxophone themselves?
Clarinet player - wants to transition to saxophone? Watch
- Thread Starter
- 08-04-2011 23:13
- 08-04-2011 23:15
You'll find it mega easy - with the possible exception of the soprano, which will still be easier for a clarinet player -it being basically a big metal clarinet.
Sax has much cooler image, I know - but with the right mouthpiece, the clarinet is a great jazz instrument.Last edited by Clip; 08-04-2011 at 23:17.
- 08-04-2011 23:18
I play Alto, so I'm slightly biased..
- 10-04-2011 20:28
If you're planning on buying a saxophone, don't forget that Tenors tend to be more expensive that Altos.
And yeah, since you're a clarinet player the saxophone should be quite easy. Good luck!
- 11-04-2011 10:06
The fingering is the same on all saxes - the music is transposed: Eb for alto and baritone, Bb for soprano and tenor. Surprisingly little difference in price between alto and tenor as they are the most common - soprano and especially baritone are dearer. Go to your music shop and try before you buy, it'll be the weight and feel of the instrument that makes most difference (there's only 5 notes difference in the pitch ).
- 20-04-2011 08:21
Why move away from the clarinet now you're grade 8? :O
That is where the true fun begins!
Anyway, I'm a sax player myself, you should be fine being a clarinettist, but the fingering is different. The only similarity is once you get to the D above the break to B above that.
I'd say tenor is more of a jazz instrument and alto for classical however they both have scope for either.
However, if you're mega rich get a baritone omg that beast is gorgeous!
- 06-07-2011 23:37
As not only both a clarinet and a saxophone player but also an alto and a tenor player, I really wanted to give my opinion on your problem. I started playing saxophone when I was about grade 3 on the clarinet because my hands were finally big enough. it was an amazingly easy transition and I think I did my grade 3 sax the same term. The fingering is almost exactly the same as the second octave for the clarinet on the saxophones. Obviously you need a different embrachure but I'm sure you will adapt.
As for tenor or alto, I would say start with alto. I have been playing tenor for about three years now and although I'm grade 8 alto, the sound is much harder to make nice on a tenor; essentially you need a much more expensive instrument to get the same quality. although the tenor is a lovely instrument and is great for jazz, the alto is much more versatile. It can play classical romantic modern jazz or pop music easily, whereas the tenor is only really for jazz. I know you said you mainly wanted to do jazz but one genre will become boring, even if it is jazz. If you start on the alto it will be easier to progress onto the tenor than going straight from clarinet to tenor.
One last thing, don't give up the clarinet. Not only is it more useful for band purposes
but it's lovely and if you've got to grade 8 it'd be a waste, even if you don't want to do anything in music as a career.
Hope it was useful
- 07-07-2011 22:59
Congratulations on your first post (and sound advice it was too - rep). Check out the saxophone Society - it's gone a bit quiet in there recently and we could do with some new discussion.