The Student Room Group

Most despicable?

A situation arose a bit ago for some friends of mine, and we'd been debating who had behaved the worst. Here's the situation:

2 good male friends of each other, let's call them A & B, live together. A was going out with a young lady, we'll call her C, and had been going out with her for about 8 months. B obviously knew C and they got on pretty well. A and C decided things weren't going perfectly and decided to head in their separate directions, with no hard feelings. The following day A goes out clubbing and decided to spend the night hoovering the face off another young lady, D. C & D know each other reasonably well, but you wouldn't describe them as friends. Anyway, C sees A & D together. The following day A and C have a chat and agree that while nothing wrong had been done it was a bit out of order thrusting things in her face as it were. Everything is hunky dorey. A week later everyone is out at the same club independently, with everyone in 'an advanced state of intoxication'. A & D end up surgically joined at the lips once more. C is not happy with this, and finds B to have a moan about A's behaviour. One thing leads to another and soon B & C are locked in a similar fashion to A & D.

Anyway, so the question is, rank A, B & C in order of who has acted worst.

Reply 1

Argh too many letters!!!!!!

Reply 2

i think B is the worst in all this as he had a loyalty towards his friend, C didnt have a loyalty towards D as they werent friends. however A shouldnt have pulled someone straight away and in front of C, even if they were broken up. Everyone other than D is a bit guilty in this story...

Reply 3

Is there a correct answer to his? I dont think there is

which letter are you btw?

Reply 4

i think c was a complete whinge bag and should get over it like they say life is indeed a bitch!!

i hate people who get annoyed about who their exes are seeing and who they are sleeping with or kissing ex means no more get over it C

Reply 5

Laursy
i think c was a complete whinge bag and should get over it like they say life is indeed a bitch!!

i hate people who get annoyed about who their exes are seeing and who they are sleeping with or kissing ex means no more get over it C


I think it's fair to say that actually there wasn't that much moaning - C has completely got over the situation, B & A haven't fallen out, no one got hurt - it just caused a bit of a sharp intake of breath amongst all the people that know every one of A, B, C & D.....

Reply 6

mangomaz
Argh too many letters!!!!!!


I feel like I am trying to sit an 11 plus exam again..

I am not actually sure who has acted worse because it is all circumstanstial so I don't feel like I can judge. B shouldn't be taking advantage of the miserable state of C and the same could be said for D but then again it could be completely different.

Reply 7

A can't help who he falls in love with!!

Reply 8

Tim Kabel
A can't help who he falls in love with!!


But we don't know it is actually love do we?

Reply 9

It doesn't seem like love. Just a load of rebounding going on.

Reply 10

I think 'despicable' is far too strong a word. They're all...very minorly...guilty - but it's not like it's life threatening

Reply 11

Poica
I think 'despicable' is far too strong a word. They're all...very minorly...guilty - but it's not like it's life threatening


True. It isn't like anyone committed murder or anything. I suppose what happens will make them stronger in the end.