The Student Room Group

A2 Philosophy (AQA) 2011

Scroll to see replies

Original post by jcosgrove4
Currently teaching myself Philosophy and will be sitting both unit 3 and unit 4 in 3 weeks. I was going to revise 3 topics for unit 3 but everyone on here looks to be doing only 2? Is this what your teachers have advised as I might do the same?


If you can learn two really well, I suggest doing that. They give you a choice of question within the topics anyway! If you're comfortable with 3, revise 3.
(edited 12 years ago)
Reply 41
Original post by Dansat
You're welcome :smile: also this video series is really good for the political and moral stuff- http://www.justiceharvard.org/watch/ ah well guess more than one school does the same topics :tongue:


Ive been watching them, the examples Sandel uses are superb! How are you feeling about the exam?
Reply 42
Original post by JaiP
Ive been watching them, the examples Sandel uses are superb! How are you feeling about the exam?


Yeah they're interesting, good for if you're too lazy to revise properly like me :smile: Not too good really :s there's alot of stuff I still don't know much about. You?

And does anyone have a copy of the specimen paper/ mark scheme? I can't find it anywhere!
Reply 43
Is anyone else doing philosophy of mind?

I'm fairly happy with Descartes and phil of religion but nothing in the phil of mind seems to make any sense whatsoever. It might just be me being stupid but the chapter in the main AQA book on the phil of mind just went straight over my head.

I only got a B last year so it looks like I'll be heading for a B or a C... THANK GOD I don't need the grade in this.
Reply 44
Original post by Dansat
Yeah they're interesting, good for if you're too lazy to revise properly like me :smile: Not too good really :s there's alot of stuff I still don't know much about. You?

And does anyone have a copy of the specimen paper/ mark scheme? I can't find it anywhere!


im making Mill revision notes as we speak! haha. Its going okay, except i know all the content but my essay structure is terrible..havent done enough 50 mark questions to get the gist, may just revise mark schemes instead. :smile:
Reply 45
Original post by JaiP
im making Mill revision notes as we speak! haha. Its going okay, except i know all the content but my essay structure is terrible..havent done enough 50 mark questions to get the gist, may just revise mark schemes instead. :smile:


Im revising justice right now ha. Yeah essays are a problem for me, struggle to keep it relevant to the question. I was like that with the last exam but this time round I don't really know the content either :frown: where you from?
I haven't even tried to write essays.... :s-smilie: :s-smilie: :s-smilie: :s-smilie: :s-smilie:

Yep, I'm ****ed.

I don't seem to have any understanding whatsoever as to how to structure them?

If you read the examplar responses on the AQA website for Unit3&4 it doesn't seem that hard to get an A/B. All you have to do is define the terms and set the argument out in the first paragraph. Then blitz with arguments for and arguments against, mention other theories if need be, compare them; and BAM short conclusion. Get your english right and assuming the examiner isn't blind and hopefully you'll have yourself a A/B! :colondollar:

Am I too optimistic?
I have been lucky enough to have done quite a few mock essays (50 mark Unit 3 ones mainly, but have done a few Mill).

Regarding structure I would do a concise in introduction highlighting the theories involved in the quote/question given.

I would then clearly outline this argument, before looking at criticisms, possible responses to criticisms and alternatives if appropriate, before moving onto a conclusion which should express your clear point of view - this is made much easier if you have a clear viewpoint (even if it is just one you have selected for the purposes of the exam).

Remember that there are a huge number of marks for evaluation so it is key that you go into sufficient depth. I would also try to get in as many philosophers/quotes as appropriate
Original post by mirandaandhector

Original post by mirandaandhector
I have been lucky enough to have done quite a few mock essays (50 mark Unit 3 ones mainly, but have done a few Mill).

Regarding structure I would do a concise in introduction highlighting the theories involved in the quote/question given.

I would then clearly outline this argument, before looking at criticisms, possible responses to criticisms and alternatives if appropriate, before moving onto a conclusion which should express your clear point of view - this is made much easier if you have a clear viewpoint (even if it is just one you have selected for the purposes of the exam).

Remember that there are a huge number of marks for evaluation so it is key that you go into sufficient depth. I would also try to get in as many philosophers/quotes as appropriate


How do you remember quotes?
Reply 49
I'm doing Philosophy of Mind, Philosophy of Religion, and Descartes Meditations.

I used the AQA Book for Mind, Lacewing for Religion, and Southwell for Meditations.

I've made concise notes on Mind and Religion but haven't started Descartes yet (not too worried about that thought since Des' is pretty simplistic :P)

I haven't started memorising the arguments yet... I've put keywords on flashcards which follow the argument structures including criticisms.


I got 186/200 UMS last year, so if my calculations are correct I only need 134UMS this year to get an A. And that's, what, 67UMS per Unit this year? So a high C? I think I might be able to wing that... haha. I really wanted an A* though. I wish I'd started revising sooner!!! ;_;

P.S. Anyone have the Specimen papers for Phil3 and Phil4? I can't find them anywhere!



P.P.S Oh and to anyone worried about not having done any practice questions, I really haven't done many at all except in the mock... I find Philosophy questions way too daunting to practice. I just like to wing them on the day when I have loads of exam-adrenaline. I find they come out better that way!
(edited 12 years ago)
Original post by Shuu
I'm doing Philosophy of Mind, Philosophy of Religion, and Descartes Meditations.

I used the AQA Book for Mind, Lacewing for Religion, and Southwell for Meditations.

I've made concise notes on Mind and Religion but haven't started Descartes yet (not too worried about that thought since Des' is pretty simplistic :P)

I haven't started memorising the arguments yet... I've put keywords on flashcards which follow the argument structures including criticisms.


I got 186/200 UMS last year, so if my calculations are correct I only need 134UMS this year to get an A. And that's, what, 67UMS per Unit this year? So a high C? I think I might be able to wing that... haha. I really wanted an A* though. I wish I'd started revising sooner!!! ;_;

P.S. Anyone have the Specimen papers for Phil3 and Phil4? I can't find them anywhere!



P.P.S Oh and to anyone worried about not having done any practice questions, I really haven't done many at all except in the mock... I find Philosophy questions way too daunting to practice. I just like to wing them on the day when I have loads of exam-adrenaline. I find they come out better that way!


http://web.aqa.org.uk/qual/gce/humanities/philosophy_materials.php?id=10&prev=

Past papers are there, not sure about specimen ones though. But you don't really need them, just take a philosophical view and put 'Assess' in front of it.
Original post by heartsandminds
How do you remember quotes?


I tend to go through notes and make a list of some key quotes for each topic area - if you keep them short and sweet then I then find it quite easy to memorise a few (don't worry about being word perfect, so long as you have the general expression of the idea in question then that will be fine. This technique is also useful for the Mill exam
Original post by Shuu
P.S. Anyone have the Specimen papers for Phil3 and Phil4? I can't find them anywhere!


Think PHIL 3 Specimen was withdrawn on grounds of questions being too hard (way some were phrased)! Don't know about PHIL 4.
I was going through an exemplar paper on the AQA site just now, and one thing I noticed is that they don't seem to do what I do and use philosopher's view and arguments and instead they talk more generally about arguments if that makes sense.

http://store.aqa.org.uk/qual/gce/pdf/AQA-2170-W-TRB-U03SAMPANS-JUN10.PDF

I usually give an intro and mention a philosopher with an argument then move straight onto that philosopher and his arguments and stick with philsophers or theories but, if you look at the moral philosophy one, they talk about general arguments and general criticisms of the view. Which one is better? Or are they both the same?
Original post by KwamiOdoom
I was going through an exemplar paper on the AQA site just now, and one thing I noticed is that they don't seem to do what I do and use philosopher's view and arguments and instead they talk more generally about arguments if that makes sense.

http://store.aqa.org.uk/qual/gce/pdf/AQA-2170-W-TRB-U03SAMPANS-JUN10.PDF

I usually give an intro and mention a philosopher with an argument then move straight onto that philosopher and his arguments and stick with philsophers or theories but, if you look at the moral philosophy one, they talk about general arguments and general criticisms of the view. Which one is better? Or are they both the same?


If you're answering the question it doesn't matter.
Original post by dancinginrainbows
If you're answering the question it doesn't matter.


And as per usual, you're on hand to make me feel better haha. Thank you.
Reply 56
I'm also doing Political/ Moral Philosophy and Mill. Just wondering does anyone happen to have any scripts of past exams which were given B/A/A*?
I've read the markscheme, but just would be interesting to see how past responses have actually been marked.

Also, I'm really set on what to revise for Moral and Mill, if anyone needs any help (even if its getting a little late!), but just want to double check Politics, would I be right in thinking this is what I need to cover?

Ideologies: Conservative, Liberalism (Classical, Social, Libertarian), Socialism, Marxism, Anarchism.
Justice: Desert/merit distinction, Redistributive justice, Dif. ideologies take on justice distinctions.
Liberty: Positive/Negative distinction, Liberty and Utility, Dif. ideologies take on liberty distinctions.
Nation States: Compatibility with Ideologies, The Just war theory.

I'm also fast-tracking which means all my AS notes on "Should I be governed?" are mixed with my A2 Political phil. notes... which is why I'm a bit confused.
For those doing Mill, what type of exam questions do you think we will get? Will they just be on liberty, human development and democracy?
My Philosophy teacher said that on all of the Mill papers he has seen (old and new spec), there has always been a question focused around chapter 3 (Individuality). To have enough for an essay question focus is likey to be mainl either chapter 2 or chapter 3. I will find the past paper questions I have for Mill and some additional ones which our teacher made up for mocks.
Reply 59
Original post by dancinginrainbows
I don't I'm afraid. I'm planning on writing them though, so I can send them to you when I have done so :smile: The same in return would be appreciated!


Sorry for the slow reply, that sounds good when i get round to typing them up i'll give you a message... i'm thinking we could go for the generic ones (ad hominem, un-testable etc) and then i read in the examiner's report (sorry your probs already know this but..) that they prefer you to look at the synpotic links throughout the whole history of philosophy , so like i guess you don't need direct criticisms as much as good poeple to weigh him up against... we do phil of religion so there's some overlap there which saves the 'hunt' for criticisms concerning that area :tongue:

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending