Go to first unread
Back
to top
Suicide
WatchThis discussion is closed.
Report
#81
(Original post by Joey_Johns)
I could beat you hands down at anything Geordie.
I could beat you hands down at anything Geordie.
0
(Original post by bono)
lol.
it will be "lets discuss the reasons why people are poor."
corey says - "many r poor due to bad political leaders who mess up the country."
joey says - "rubbish, i know some1 who knows some1, who is poor because he wants to, tehrefore you dont ahve a clue what ur talking about."
lol.
it will be "lets discuss the reasons why people are poor."
corey says - "many r poor due to bad political leaders who mess up the country."
joey says - "rubbish, i know some1 who knows some1, who is poor because he wants to, tehrefore you dont ahve a clue what ur talking about."
0
Report
#83
(Original post by timeofyourlife)
You do raise a very interesting point. Remember the case of Mrs. Pretty and her 'right to die'? Her case was dismissed by the high court judge, and her 'right' was defeated. Whether we have an autonomous right to end our lives, however, questions the whole meaning of automomy and is an ethical dilemma which unfortunately will only ever be founded by our own opinions.
You do raise a very interesting point. Remember the case of Mrs. Pretty and her 'right to die'? Her case was dismissed by the high court judge, and her 'right' was defeated. Whether we have an autonomous right to end our lives, however, questions the whole meaning of automomy and is an ethical dilemma which unfortunately will only ever be founded by our own opinions.
and Joey, I'm proud to be a Geordie, *cough* classics boy *cough*
0
Report
#84
(Original post by alaric)
You really don't understand 'proper' depression, the point with 'proper' depression is that there doesn't need to be a reason for it. At all. Everything can be going well and you can still want to kill yourself. There can be reasons, and lots of people have them too, but the overriding problem is that it doesn't need a reason. People who haven't been 'properly' depressed never understand this, they always assume there must be a reason.
Consequently it can be very hard to reach people who are in that situation.
Alaric.
You really don't understand 'proper' depression, the point with 'proper' depression is that there doesn't need to be a reason for it. At all. Everything can be going well and you can still want to kill yourself. There can be reasons, and lots of people have them too, but the overriding problem is that it doesn't need a reason. People who haven't been 'properly' depressed never understand this, they always assume there must be a reason.
Consequently it can be very hard to reach people who are in that situation.
Alaric.
0
Report
#85
(Original post by Joey_Johns)
I could beat you hands down at anything Geordie.
I could beat you hands down at anything Geordie.
reason - you look at your particular experience and not the wider, general picture, which is what matters in basing an opinion - not disregarding anything else if it hasnt happended to you.
thats what u did in this debate - kept constantly referring to your experience and based all ur views on that - despite it being obvious that a lot of suicides are based on reasons such as i explained - its obvious.
0
Report
#86
(Original post by Joey_Johns)
Thankyou, perhaps Corey needs someone close to him to die.
Thankyou, perhaps Corey needs someone close to him to die.
YOU WANT SOME1 CLOSE TO COREY TO DIE?
GO TO HELL LOSER.
0
Report
#87
(Original post by corey)
and Joey, I'm proud to be a Geordie
and Joey, I'm proud to be a Geordie
0
(Original post by Joey_Johns)
Thankyou, perhaps Corey needs someone close to him to die. Then maybe he would understand.
I know what your saying e.g. wider picture. In general people do commit suicide because of depression but there are many types of depression. But the fact remains I've been effected. You lot havent.
Thankyou, perhaps Corey needs someone close to him to die. Then maybe he would understand.
I know what your saying e.g. wider picture. In general people do commit suicide because of depression but there are many types of depression. But the fact remains I've been effected. You lot havent.
The thing is i have, it too hard for me to even think about, i hate telling people about it.
0
Report
#89
(Original post by Joey_Johns)
Thankyou, perhaps Corey needs someone close to him to die. Then maybe he would understand.
.
Thankyou, perhaps Corey needs someone close to him to die. Then maybe he would understand.
.
theres no need to get nasty
0
Report
#90
(Original post by onlylittleme)
Yes, but depression can be combated by people talking to you and helping you through what you are feeling.
Yes, but depression can be combated by people talking to you and helping you through what you are feeling.
(Original post by onlylittleme)
Depression can be onset by anything but is always amplified by any problems the person is going through, and the feeling of lonliness that they might feel greatly increased by the isolation of nobody trying to find out what is wrong.
Depression can be onset by anything but is always amplified by any problems the person is going through, and the feeling of lonliness that they might feel greatly increased by the isolation of nobody trying to find out what is wrong.
Alaric.
0
Report
#91
(Original post by Joey_Johns)
I know it happens a lot I never disputed that. I'm simply saying in my situation it was different. All suicides are different. Some are similar some arent. Nobody is the same, we all come from different background with different experiences, therefore all suicides are slighty different. You can generalis the factors contributing to a suicide but you cannot specifically pin point down the exact reason.
I know it happens a lot I never disputed that. I'm simply saying in my situation it was different. All suicides are different. Some are similar some arent. Nobody is the same, we all come from different background with different experiences, therefore all suicides are slighty different. You can generalis the factors contributing to a suicide but you cannot specifically pin point down the exact reason.
"I'm simply saying in my situation it was different." - i know!
"Some are similar some arent." - EXACTLY! i never said "each suicide is exactly identical". i meant the same sort of thing, loneliness, etc. the similar reasons.
"Nobody is the same, we all come from different background with different experiences," - well obviously, my arguments were general, and stating general reasons - not daying it was 100% identical in each case.
e.g.) kid feels lonely due to mum not giving a toss
e.g.) kid feels lonely due to mum dying.
BUT, similarity - kid feels suicidal due to loneliness of mum not being there 4 him.
"You can generalis the factors contributing to a suicide" - yes, and thats what i did.
"cannot specifically pin point down the exact reason" - well obviously, there are many. thats blatantly obvious.
0
Report
#92
(Original post by bono)
yes, it is very, very selfish.
there are always alternatives to suicide, thats what i think.
yes, it is very, very selfish.
there are always alternatives to suicide, thats what i think.
0
Report
#93
How do you use examples such as the case of your girlfriends which discussing/debating a matter?
You argue a point on principle, then you use an example to strengthen that point of principle. An example on its own as you have repeatably used is not really a valid argument.
I paid no attention to your girlfriends feelings because I am arguing on a point of principle - autonomous individual rights. That does not include your girlfriends feelings in it - nor do I consider them very relevant.
You argue a point on principle, then you use an example to strengthen that point of principle. An example on its own as you have repeatably used is not really a valid argument.
I paid no attention to your girlfriends feelings because I am arguing on a point of principle - autonomous individual rights. That does not include your girlfriends feelings in it - nor do I consider them very relevant.
0
Report
#94
(Original post by bono)
YOU ARE A SICK ****.
YOU WANT SOME1 CLOSE TO COREY TO DIE?
GO TO HELL LOSER.
YOU ARE A SICK ****.
YOU WANT SOME1 CLOSE TO COREY TO DIE?
GO TO HELL LOSER.
0
Report
#95
(Original post by corey)
yes, but that assisted suicide which was slightly different
and Joey, I'm proud to be a Geordie, *cough* classics boy *cough*
yes, but that assisted suicide which was slightly different
and Joey, I'm proud to be a Geordie, *cough* classics boy *cough*
0
Report
#96
(Original post by ThornsnRoses)
how is it selfish...people around you dont realise how much **** youre in!
how is it selfish...people around you dont realise how much **** youre in!
but if you read my 50 other posts instead of just this 1, you would see i elaborated.
can be selfish in some instances if things r going ok, but as the last 3 pages of debating suggests, often there is some justification.
0
(Original post by ThornsnRoses)
how is it selfish...people around you dont realise how much **** youre in!
how is it selfish...people around you dont realise how much **** youre in!
"poo...life sucks" there for you are not going to be top of the world and are going to be in favour of suicide.
0
Report
#98
(Original post by timeofyourlife)
Not a whole lot different in principle (apart form third parties obviously), she was unable to end her own life due do physical impairment - she was disputing the same core 'right to death', which isn't written in stone, more of an adjustment of the 'right to live' human right - phrased rather badly to many judges' dismay.
Not a whole lot different in principle (apart form third parties obviously), she was unable to end her own life due do physical impairment - she was disputing the same core 'right to death', which isn't written in stone, more of an adjustment of the 'right to live' human right - phrased rather badly to many judges' dismay.
0
Report
#99
(Original post by Joey_Johns)
You study books too much.
You study books too much.
0
Report
#100
(Original post by Joey_Johns)
You study books too much.
You study books too much.
0
X
new posts
