Go to first unread
Back
to top
Reincarnation
WatchThis discussion is closed.
(Original post by pal_sch)
Souls are either non-existant or non-explicable, so don't even try.
There is no provable evidence for reincarnation and all the religions that believe in it say it is imposible to remember past lifes or prove someone is a reincarnation of someone else. Sounds like a cop out to me.
Souls are either non-existant or non-explicable, so don't even try.
There is no provable evidence for reincarnation and all the religions that believe in it say it is imposible to remember past lifes or prove someone is a reincarnation of someone else. Sounds like a cop out to me.
0
Report
#42
(Original post by Eeyore)
Hmmm... not sure i agree there. I read this fascinating book, "Past LIves, Future Lives" by Jenny Cockell. I'd highly recommend it!
Hmmm... not sure i agree there. I read this fascinating book, "Past LIves, Future Lives" by Jenny Cockell. I'd highly recommend it!
0
(Original post by Joey_Johns)
If reincarnation is true wouldnt we all have been reincarnated from the same person once upon a time? So we are infact the same person!?? lol.
If reincarnation is true wouldnt we all have been reincarnated from the same person once upon a time? So we are infact the same person!?? lol.
0
Report
#45
(Original post by Eeyore)
Hmmm... not sure i agree there. I read this fascinating book, "Past LIves, Future Lives" by Jenny Cockell. I'd highly recommend it!
Hmmm... not sure i agree there. I read this fascinating book, "Past LIves, Future Lives" by Jenny Cockell. I'd highly recommend it!
0
(Original post by pal_sch)
I've heard lots of theorys, but none strike me as realistic. The people who claim to remember past lifes are going against most theorys and religions, as well as basic physics and biology.
I've heard lots of theorys, but none strike me as realistic. The people who claim to remember past lifes are going against most theorys and religions, as well as basic physics and biology.
0
Report
#47
(Original post by Eeyore)
Not quite sure I understand the logic there... or am I just being thick?!
Not quite sure I understand the logic there... or am I just being thick?!
0
Report
#48
(Original post by Eeyore)
Well, it's good to go against these theories and religions from time to time, I say.
Well, it's good to go against these theories and religions from time to time, I say.
0
(Original post by pal_sch)
I agree, thats the only way to live. Its also a definition of a science.
I agree, thats the only way to live. Its also a definition of a science.
0
Report
#50
(Original post by Eeyore)
What, to question theories and religions?
What, to question theories and religions?
0
Report
#51
(Original post by pal_sch)
Well, to question eveything realy. If it can't be proven, don't trust it. If it can be proven, chalenge it. Religions are the same, but have a extra clause; "but what we tell you is true and if you chalenge it you go tp hell"
Well, to question eveything realy. If it can't be proven, don't trust it. If it can be proven, chalenge it. Religions are the same, but have a extra clause; "but what we tell you is true and if you chalenge it you go tp hell"
0
(Original post by pal_sch)
Well, to question eveything realy. If it can't be proven, don't trust it. If it can be proven, chalenge it. Religions are the same, but have a extra clause; "but what we tell you is true and if you chalenge it you go tp hell"
Well, to question eveything realy. If it can't be proven, don't trust it. If it can be proven, chalenge it. Religions are the same, but have a extra clause; "but what we tell you is true and if you chalenge it you go tp hell"
0
Report
#53
(Original post by G4ry)
How did you work that out? Some religions believe in reincarnation.
How did you work that out? Some religions believe in reincarnation.
0
Report
#54
(Original post by ThornsnRoses)
lol...wasnt thinking of the wacky religions...just the monotheistic ones
lol...wasnt thinking of the wacky religions...just the monotheistic ones
should be;
wasnt thinking of all the wacky religions...just the monotheistic ones
0
Report
#55
(Original post by ThornsnRoses)
lol...wasnt thinking of the wacky religions...just the monotheistic ones
lol...wasnt thinking of the wacky religions...just the monotheistic ones
0
Report
#56
(Original post by G4ry)
Judaism believes in reincarnation to a certain extent. Although i don't know if you classify Judaism as a "wacky religion"...
Judaism believes in reincarnation to a certain extent. Although i don't know if you classify Judaism as a "wacky religion"...
0
Report
#57
(Original post by G4ry)
Judaism believes in reincarnation to a certain extent. Although i don't know if you classify Judaism as a "wacky religion"...
Judaism believes in reincarnation to a certain extent. Although i don't know if you classify Judaism as a "wacky religion"...
0
Report
#58
(Original post by ThornsnRoses)
Judaism is monotheistic...but yeah theyre all ''wacky''...to a certain extent...
Judaism is monotheistic...but yeah theyre all ''wacky''...to a certain extent...
0
Report
#59
(Original post by pal_sch)
Well, to question eveything realy. If it can't be proven, don't trust it. If it can be proven, chalenge it. Religions are the same, but have a extra clause; "but what we tell you is true and if you chalenge it you go tp hell"
Well, to question eveything realy. If it can't be proven, don't trust it. If it can be proven, chalenge it. Religions are the same, but have a extra clause; "but what we tell you is true and if you chalenge it you go tp hell"
That is not true, for most major religions. In a few fundamentalist churches it probably is nearing the truth, but your perception of religion is certainly over-simplified.
P.S. I think you are completely right that we should question everything, but if people feel that they gain something from religion, why not let them having it? It is not harming them in anyway, provided they are sensible about it, and they may find it helpful. And after all, you have no proof they are wrong. Don't forget that science still does not have all the answers. It might someday, but at the moment it still has to create something from nothing.
0
Report
#60
(Original post by Mr White)
Reincarnation can't exist - there are more people being born than there are dying, so where are the extra souls coming from?
Reincarnation can't exist - there are more people being born than there are dying, so where are the extra souls coming from?
- God is creating more souls
- God is sending down more souls who have wanted "independence" only to know they will want to come back.
- Animals/plants being reborn as humans
Its quite simple to explain why more people are being born than r dying. Did you forget about all the souls in animals and plants?
0
X
new posts
