Criticism needed. Thanks
People injured whilst participating in extreme sports should not be treated by a publicly
funded health service.
Explain the reasoning behind this statement. Suggest an argument against this statement. To
what extent, if any, does the statement justify a change in public attitudes to personal risk
taking?
Individuals who have decided to participate in extreme sports are in most cases aware of the dangers involved. An injury obtained during the sport should not be treated at the public’s expense. It is a personal risk and should therefore be a personal financial burden. This is the reasoning behind the statement.
However, in order to receive medical treatment under a publicly funded health service an individual must be a tax payer or in some way a part of the funding group. With this understanding, it is possible to establish that the individual is in fact paying for the health service.
This statement also looks at health care as a privilege and not a right. Health care should be a right because without it then the right to live is meaningless when one is sick or injured. It can be argued that those who have rights also have responsibilities of which included is understanding risks and dealing with problems. We share these responsibilities the same way we share the rights. Therefore if one is injured in extreme sports, the public shares the responsibility to ensure that one receives medical attention.
In addition, the personal risk taken affects the public both positively and negatively. The public should not base an attitude change solely upon the negative aspects of it as this statement suggests. The benefits should also be considered both to the person and the public. For example extreme sports benefit the industry that manufactures the sports gear, provides leisure entertainment through sporting events, attracts tourists and creates market for local products through this tourism.
In conclusion, it is to a small extent that this statement would justify a change in public attitudes towards personal risk taking.