The Student Room Group

Footballer or Footballer - This or That type

Scroll to see replies

Diaby but Essien at his peak.

Prime Drogba or prime Henry? :smile:
Henry best prem striker ever

Hoilett or Sturridge


This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App
I would say Sturridge spontaneously.

Klose or Quagliarella?

By the way is it possible to name former footballers?
Klose lol.

Alexis Sanchez or Demba Ba? :smile:
As I like Barcelona, I say Sanchez. He is currently playing there, ins't he?

So these are former footballers, but well-known:
Cruyff or Puskas?
Original post by Multitalented me
Why? because Cannavaro has won the WC :rolleyes:
Pedro (very underrated)

Mikel or Parker? :smile:


Cannavaro would get in my all-time dream team. Alongside either Koeman, de Boer, or Baresi in defence.

Puskas is the best striker of all time so obvoiusly him.

Titus Bramble or Ugo Ehiogu?
Original post by CJG21
Cannavaro would get in my all-time dream team. Alongside either Koeman, de Boer, or Baresi in defence.

What about the likes of Moore, Beckenbauer, Passarella & Nesta?
Bramble (underrated lol)

Terry or Puyol? :smile:
Reply 3367
Original post by Multitalented me
What about the likes of Moore, Beckenbauer, Passarella & Nesta?
Bramble (underrated lol)

Terry or Puyol? :smile:


Puyol, Terry is/was a good defender but I can't stand him

Del Piero or Totti?
Totti

Deschamps or Matthaus? :smile:
Original post by Multitalented me
What about the likes of Moore, Beckenbauer, Passarella & Nesta?
Bramble (underrated lol)

Terry or Puyol? :smile:


Moore won the WC. Big wup. I can't remember a Nesta who wasn't old, and I always prefered Costacurta. Beckenbauer was good, but people like him are always overrated because of achievements with an intenational team that they just happened to be on. If Cannavaro was in the german team instead of Beckenbauer he would have done just as well if not better.
Reply 3370
Original post by Multitalented me
Totti

Deschamps or Matthaus? :smile:


Deschamps

Alba or Baines.
alba

dzagoev or sneijder


Original post by CJG21
Seriously?! Maldini < Cannavaro

This is laughable


Original post by Zubby77
Gomez, definitely, although Inzaghi got the act of goal poaching down to an art

This is also laughable... Gomez>Inzaghi, are you mad!? Inzaghi achieved far more than Gomez ever will!
Reply 3372
Original post by simoncino
alba

dzagoev or sneijder



This is laughable



This is also laughable... Gomez>Inzaghi, are you mad!? Inzaghi achieved far more than Gomez ever will!


That might be so but looking solely at the players, Gomez is much more of a rounded player, and offers more to the team than Inzaghi did.

Sneijder at the moment, but I think Dzagoev has a lot of potential.

Patrick Vieira (prime) or Yaya Toure
Yaya Toure

Zola or Ballack? :smile:
Reply 3374
Zola for me. Though I suppose they brought different things to the table. :yep:

Lassana Diarra or Flamini?

Original post by simoncino

This is also laughable... Gomez>Inzaghi, are you mad!? Inzaghi achieved far more than Gomez ever will!


Just to note, this thread is not for calling people out on their opinions. You're welcome to take the discussion somewhere more appropriate (The Ultimate Football Thread, for example) and continue the conversation there, but not here, please. :smile:
Diarra.

Vieira or Busquets?
Original post by simoncino

This is laughable


How is it laughable?!? Maldini was a great defender, however Cannavaro is just much better. He was one of the best centre backs in the world despite being 5"9
Reply 3377
Vieira... by a very slim margin. :beard: I think over the course of his career, Busquets will come to be regarded as better than Vieira (certainly at this rate).

Menez or Dzagoev?


Original post by CJG21
How is it laughable?!? Maldini was a great defender, however Cannavaro is just much better. He was one of the best centre backs in the world despite being 5"9


Again, not here, please.
(edited 11 years ago)
Menez.

Llorente or Urzaiz?
Llorente.

Falcao or Ibrahimovic.

Quick Reply

Latest