The Student Room Group

My best friend stole the guy

Ok, so I had liked this guy (who happens to be a very good friend of mine) for a long while and my best friend knew. Then, the other day she comes out and tells me that she likes him too. Being the good friend that I am and not wanting to start any conflict, I backed off and told her I didn't care for him as much anymore (all of which was a load of rubbish) Two days later, I was kicking myself for not ever telling him how I felt and letting her take him. Then she announces to me that they are dating. Apparently, they had talked on the phone and he liked her too. I feel betrayed by her and feel sick to my stomach everytime I see them together. I feel like no one is on my side and when I gave him a hug today, I nearly burst into tears on his shoulder. She knows that it bothers me, yet I can't find it in myself to be mad at her. I keep telling her everything's alright when I know it's not. What should I do? I also can't help but think that maybe he never liked me because his best friend has a major crush on me. Everyone tells me that I'm thinner than my friend, prettier than her, more agreeable and yet she always wins the guy :frown: This isn't the first time she's done this to someone either...

Scroll to see replies

Reply 1

Anonymous
Ok, so I had liked this guy (who happens to be a very good friend of mine) for a long while and my best friend knew. Then, the other day she comes out and tells me that she likes him too. Being the good friend that I am and not wanting to start any conflict, I backed off and told her I didn't care for him as much anymore (all of which was a load of rubbish) Two days later, I was kicking myself for not ever telling him how I felt and letting her take him. Then she announces to me that they are dating. Apparently, they had talked on the phone and he liked her too. I feel betrayed by her and feel sick to my stomach everytime I see them together. I feel like no one is on my side and when I gave him a hug today, I nearly burst into tears on his shoulder. She knows that it bothers me, yet I can't find it in myself to be mad at her. I keep telling her everything's alright when I know it's not. What should I do? I also can't help but think that maybe he never liked me because his best friend has a major crush on me. Everyone tells me that I'm thinner than my friend, prettier than her, more agreeable and yet she always wins the guy :frown: This isn't the first time she's done this to someone either...


Done what, exactly?

Reply 2

what do you mean?

Reply 3

Pretty Boy
Don't speak to her again.

'Friends are your enemies with secret identities'


But I've know her since we were 10 years old! :frown:

Reply 4

Don't try to break them up - it will have the opposite effect. Next time pounce whilst the iron is hot (I love mixed metaphors - sorry). Keep an eye on the relationship, if you still like the guy when the break up then get in their more quickly. And if you find someone else you like don't hang around.

Reply 5

Not much of a friend realistically.

If she really had feelings for him, and knew you liked the guy, the good thing would have been to at least ask if you dont mind if she goes for him.

From a psyc point of view:

It could come from a sub concious insecurity, and her "stealing" friends love interests could be her way of validating herself agains you.

but you have to remember: You snooze, you loose. < sorry thats harsh


Sorry i havent been much help tonight.... hella late and im hyped on caffene.

Reply 6

I know it seems awful now, but you will get over it in time. Trust me.

You should have told your friend how you honestly felt, because at the end of the day she isn't a mind reader.

My friend did something similar last year. Six months down the line the guy I liked decided it was me he liked after all. But by this point I didn't feel the same.

If you and this guy were best friends, maybe it is best if nothing ever happened. It's not nice losing a friend.

Reply 7

Anonymous
Ok, so I had liked this guy (who happens to be a very good friend of mine) for a long while and my best friend knew. Then, the other day she comes out and tells me that she likes him too. Being the good friend that I am and not wanting to start any conflict, I backed off and told her I didn't care for him as much anymore (all of which was a load of rubbish) Two days later, I was kicking myself for not ever telling him how I felt and letting her take him. Then she announces to me that they are dating. Apparently, they had talked on the phone and he liked her too. I feel betrayed by her and feel sick to my stomach everytime I see them together. I feel like no one is on my side and when I gave him a hug today, I nearly burst into tears on his shoulder. She knows that it bothers me, yet I can't find it in myself to be mad at her. I keep telling her everything's alright when I know it's not. What should I do? I also can't help but think that maybe he never liked me because his best friend has a major crush on me. Everyone tells me that I'm thinner than my friend, prettier than her, more agreeable and yet she always wins the guy :frown: This isn't the first time she's done this to someone either...


Listen to that song by son of dork called Holly im the one its exactly your situation!!

Reply 8

well let's be fair, she didn't actually steal him, did she?! you said so yourself you weren't even sure if he liked you, indicating he wasn't actually yours in the first place, plus you even lied to her about your feelings for him and basically gave her permission to persue him.

am i missing something?!

Reply 9

I'm afraid there is only one solution to your tragic circumstances: assassinate her in the night with a rusty knife.

Reply 10

Very good, ferrus.

Reply 11

She didn't steal him. He was never 'yours' to claim in the first place. Plus you told her that you didn't care much about him anymore.

Reply 12

Anonymous
Everyone tells me that I'm thinner than my friend, prettier than her, more agreeable


Oh excellent, if Mr Darcy happens by I'm sure you'll be in for a good seeing-to.

Reply 13

LibertineNorth
Oh excellent, if Mr Darcy happens by I'm sure you'll be in for a good seeing-to.


Wonderful! I do love Mr. Darcy :p: Whoever suggested murdering her with a rusty knife...I think I'm gonna go with that one :biggrin: lol.

Ok, so here's what happened. I did give her the ok, but the next day when she asked me if it was ok, I told her that I'd lied the day before and that I wasn't. Yet she still proceeded to date him. :frown:

And about the whole 'hugging my friends boyfriend' issue that someone brought up, we're all very close. Before any of this happened we'd hug eachother when we saw one another and hug eachother when we said goodbye. The fact that she's dating him is not going to change my relationship with him and she knows that. He's a very flirtatious guy anyways...

Reply 14

Oh that has happened to me!! We both had known the guy for a long long time, she knew him for a little longer. It was common knowledge that i was head over heels in love with him. I knew that he liked my friend *the other girl* and well all of a sudden last summer....out of the blue they started going out when he asked her. She knew it would break my heart.

Needless to say i have gotten over it and well, she's a nobody to me now. Anon, seriously, try and move on and forget about it because well, im sure you have other fabulous friends out there like i have and well, neither of them are worth it!!!

Hope everything goes well and remember to keep smiling!!!

C xxxxx

Reply 15

Riddy
Listen to that song by son of dork called Holly im the one its exactly your situation!!


omg i freakin love that song!!!!
never let boys come between a friendship.... even though what your friend did was rotten

Reply 16

Anonymous


Ok, so here's what happened. I did give her the ok, but the next day when she asked me if it was ok, I told her that I'd lied the day before and that I wasn't. Yet she still proceeded to date him. :frown:



Its not really fair to announce that actually youre not ok with them dating when lets face it - they clearly like eachother if shes willing to go through with it. why should all 3 of you be unhappy just because you couldnt tell her earlier that you still liked him?

i know its hard on you and i sympathise but in situations like this i sometimes feel sorry for the couple who are being told essentially that they shouldnt be seeing eachother even if they really like eachother.

in the end though try and remain friends with her, because a friend is not worth loosing over something like this. give it time and you will get over him.

Reply 17

You shouldn't have told him you wasn't that keen on him anymore, because that obviously could have been interpreted as your permission to let her go for him. I think you need to talk to her and explain you still like him, because otherwise she will think everything she's doing is fine because you aren't into him anymore.

Reply 18

pianist
You shouldn't have told him you wasn't that keen on him anymore, because that obviously could have been interpreted as your permission to let her go for him. I think you need to talk to her and explain you still like him, because otherwise she will think everything she's doing is fine because you aren't into him anymore.


I didn't tell him anything. He still has no idea that I ever liked him and she knows that I'm not fine with what's going on. Even though they're dating now, I had told her my feelings before he even confessed that he liked her back! I really felt betrayed by her. If she had liked a guy and I began liking him too, I would have never told her and would have forced myself to stop for her. She told me and I acted totally composed and fine, but I know that if I had done the same thing to her, she would have hit the fan :frown:

Reply 19

Anonymous
I didn't tell him anything. He still has no idea that I ever liked him and she knows that I'm not fine with what's going on. Even though they're dating now, I had told her my feelings before he even confessed that he liked her back! I really felt betrayed by her. If she had liked a guy and I began liking him too, I would have never told her and would have forced myself to stop for her. She told me and I acted totally composed and fine, but I know that if I had done the same thing to her, she would have hit the fan :frown:


typo, I meant you shouldn't have told her that you weren't really keen on him anymore. :eek: