# ok then do this one... [maths]

Watch
Announcements

This discussion is closed.

This is one of the hardest questions I have come across in my life, im sure there is a trick to do it but dont know wot.

If

find all pairs of m and n which satisfy this relationship

If

**m**and**n**are connected by:**m^n = n^m**find all pairs of m and n which satisfy this relationship

0

Report

#4

(Original post by

This is one of the hardest questions I have come across in my life, im sure there is a trick to do it but dont know wot.

If

find all pairs of m and n which satisfy this relationship

**integral_neo**)This is one of the hardest questions I have come across in my life, im sure there is a trick to do it but dont know wot.

If

**m**and**n**are connected by:**m^n = n^m**find all pairs of m and n which satisfy this relationship

by changing the base:

logm (n) = logm (n) logn (m)

=> logn (m) = 1

=> m == n

0

the question asks for finding all the pairs.. ur answer cannot be right that

m = n

m = n

0

Report

#7

(Original post by

the question asks for finding all the pairs.. ur answer cannot be right that

m = n

**integral_neo**)the question asks for finding all the pairs.. ur answer cannot be right that

m = n

0

Report

#8

I did it without logs:

m^n = n^m

(m^n)/(m^n) = (n^m)/(m^n)

(n^m)/(m^n) = 1

n^(m-n) = 1 = n^0

m-n = 0

m=n

so m and n can be anything as long as they are equal.

wow I didn't think I'd get that one!

m^n = n^m

(m^n)/(m^n) = (n^m)/(m^n)

(n^m)/(m^n) = 1

n^(m-n) = 1 = n^0

m-n = 0

m=n

so m and n can be anything as long as they are equal.

wow I didn't think I'd get that one!

0

Report

#10

ok... maybe what i proved was that if they are equal it must work

but now that I think about it that goes without saying.

but now that I think about it that goes without saying.

0

so if u face this question in an exam, any kinda of exam, wot r u supposed to write if it cant be solved?

0

Report

#12

(Original post by

so if u face this question in an exam, any kinda of exam, wot r u supposed to write if it cant be solved?

**integral_neo**)so if u face this question in an exam, any kinda of exam, wot r u supposed to write if it cant be solved?

0

Report

#15

this is wot 'theone' posted be4

Most equations of this form, i.e. of x^y = y^x are unsolvable directly.

However you can deduce various facts about such equations.

Now consider the function f(t) = ln(t) / t. If you sketch the graph and find it's maximum you see that if x < e, then there are two values of t for which f(t) = x. If x = e, there is one value, if x > e there are no values.

But x^y = y^x is equivalent to y/lny = x/lnx. so lny/y = lnx /x . Now we know lnx/ x < 1/e, so for each value of x there are two values of y which give lny/y = lnx/x, except when x = e, when there is one solution.

This also tells us about the range of the solutions, when there are two, one will always be in the range [0,e] and one in [e,+inf]

i would like to say i follow but it is tricky...how can u do this?

and incidently, wot does 'transcedental' mean/

Most equations of this form, i.e. of x^y = y^x are unsolvable directly.

However you can deduce various facts about such equations.

Now consider the function f(t) = ln(t) / t. If you sketch the graph and find it's maximum you see that if x < e, then there are two values of t for which f(t) = x. If x = e, there is one value, if x > e there are no values.

But x^y = y^x is equivalent to y/lny = x/lnx. so lny/y = lnx /x . Now we know lnx/ x < 1/e, so for each value of x there are two values of y which give lny/y = lnx/x, except when x = e, when there is one solution.

This also tells us about the range of the solutions, when there are two, one will always be in the range [0,e] and one in [e,+inf]

i would like to say i follow but it is tricky...how can u do this?

and incidently, wot does 'transcedental' mean/

0

Report

#16

Which bits don't you follow?

Transcendental means that the number is not the solution to any polynomial with integer coefficients.

Transcendental means that the number is not the solution to any polynomial with integer coefficients.

0

Report

#17

I can't wait to learn about Log and In... I don't have a clue what they mean but they sound pretty important.

edit: and "e" as well. what's e? is it a constant?

edit: and "e" as well. what's e? is it a constant?

0

Report

#18

(Original post by

I can't wait to learn about Log and In... I don't have a clue what they mean but they sound pretty important.

edit: and "e" as well. what's e? is it a constant?

**mik1a**)I can't wait to learn about Log and In... I don't have a clue what they mean but they sound pretty important.

edit: and "e" as well. what's e? is it a constant?

e can be defined in various ways, all equivalent. The most common ones are the constant such that e^x has gradient e^x or the limit of ((n+1)/n)^n as n -> infinity.

0

Report

#19

**mik1a**)

I can't wait to learn about Log and In... I don't have a clue what they mean but they sound pretty important.

edit: and "e" as well. what's e? is it a constant?

0

Report

#20

**mik1a**)

I can't wait to learn about Log and In... I don't have a clue what they mean but they sound pretty important.

edit: and "e" as well. what's e? is it a constant?

0

X

new posts

Back

to top

to top