Not really. Certain universities don't accept them but most average universities will accept them and will probably realise that in some ways they're better than A-levels. Doing a BTEC extended diploma you do a lot of practicals and learn about a broad range of topics whereas at A-level it goes into so much detail and there's very little actual practical experience. Someone who did chemistry and biology A-levels might know more about DNA than me for instance but they probably won't have ever used a centrifuge or own their own little vial of their DNA that they extracted themselves. They also won't have done as many titrations as a BTEC student and they won't have as much experience researching and referencing as we do. One of our core units is called perceptions of science and it's all about researching and referencing different views on scientific topics and saying how different things change the opinions of the public.
We also have a unit called scientific investigation where we decide on something we personally want to investigate.
I did AS's in maths, biology, business studies and statistics. I didn't like my subject combination and I had a lot of distractions so I basically flunked the year.
I'm now at college in my last year of a BTEC extended diploma in forensic science (level 3, worth 3 a-levels) that I got into because of my gcse grades and despite a lot of set backs within the college I'm hoping to do quite well. I applied for 4 universities to study forensic psychology and I've had offers from all 4. My choices are portsmouth, southampton solent, UEL and bedfordshire and I've got my heart set on portsmouth.
Basically if you do a BTEC you're never going to be seen as oxbridge material and you won't get into any of the really good universities like UCL, york, leeds etc. But to be honest if you did A-levels which are harder in my opinion having tried them before this course, you'd probably end up with less ucas points than you would doing a BTEC. My lowest offer is MMP (2 Cs and an E) and for me that would be easy to obtain right now despite having no proper teachers at all in the first year! At A-level it's quite hard to get a C! Especially in something science related like what I'm doing.
Also if you're doing applied science (or possibly medical) rather than applied (forensic) then you'll be in a better position for applying to do something very sciencey at university because there's more science content. My friend on my course wanted to do biochemistry or something at university and a lot of universities said he'd have to do a foundation year. Bear that in mind when choosing which science BTEC you want to do. I personally really enjoy the forensics stuff on my course. The other day we actually got to search our lecturers car, retrieving evidence in proper forensic evidence bags that the police let us have. We found hammers, bullets, a gun, screwdrivers, a womans shoe and a bag of what was supposed to be cocaine (probably flour lol). It was actually part of a murder investigation all set up for us by our lecturer and he's got the whole college involved so we're going round interviewing the lab technicians and the security guards who have all been told what their role is lol it's really good fun...
I know exactly what you mean about the BTEC stigma! There really are a lot of advantages to being a BTEC student though. I love being in a college rather than a school. I only go in 3 days a week, we call our lecturers by their first name and we have to be responsible for our own work and be organized which I think are good things to learn. One of the advantages is that we have no exams which means that thoughout the year we know where we are and we'll know what we've got as soon as we finish because we keep track of everything ourselves and know how to use the points system. It means that if it's the last month of the course and we're finishing things off we'll know how many BTEC points we have and how to top it up. We don't have to wait around for exam results either so we can accept our university places as soon as we finish and spend all summer organizing everything for when we leave and get first dibs on halls
