The Student Room Group

Eric Pickles signals end to multiculturalism

Scroll to see replies

Reply 200
Original post by DdotT
True but i'd still disagree, whether or not Christianity is a direct part and/or influence on our society is somewhat irrelevant considering Christian ethics have shaped our society into what it is today, perhaps thats just British culture but even so Christianity is tied into this country even in the present day.


I disagree. I think they are fundamentally, generally agreed upon rules for society, which Christianity has claimed as their own. As such, we owe nothing to 'Christian' values as for the most part they intrinsically come out in society anyway.
Original post by DdotT
You seem to be trying to 'twist' things.
Even if you don't have much or anything in common with someone theres a point where you realise this AFTER talking to them. How do most internationals know if this is the case without trying.
Observation is enough.

Not particuarly, i would just like to get to know people who i am going to be living with :rolleyes:. in over 6 months i havent had a chance to speak to her about her interests because she never comes out to talk.
There is a mutuality of these things. She doesn't come out to talk and you don't go to her to talk. I find it hard to believe that an opportunity has never arisen in six months where you could start a conversation (which is your duty, seeing as you are interested in her).

i didnt really understand your last point.... Im just saying internationals tend be anti social to those who they live with, study with,work with and whose country they are in (considering British people surround them you'd imagine they'd realise they need to integrate to some extent.) And you dont even have to deviate from your cultural group to integrate, talking a bit to a non international about general things such as 'hows the course going' is not had.
I see this as just disliking small talk, which is something that resonates with me. Perhaps they don't care how your course is going—why should they? It's general and completely pointless; the conversation will be forgotten shortly afterwards, and there is no solidification of friendship. The only reason you are talking in this case is because you're living together, not because you have an active concern about each other's lives. You don't contact her in the holidays to ask general questions because you don't actually care about her or what she's doing. In what way is this brazen pretence of concern friendly or good-willed, in this case, and why should she be obliged to participate in it?

Original post by DdotT
So living with someone for a year isn't enough reason to talk to them, rather absurd imo.
If talking is comprised of small talk, then no.

And i talk to alot of people in my lectures as i see know reason not to be friendly with others whether you have common interests or not, you do not need common interests to be friendly, also it doesn't even take much so time wise your not exactly wasting your time.
Do you talk to all of them?

It is a waste of time. Why should she be expected to dedicate any time or effort to a pointless, banal conversation? Why are you offended by someone not wanting to know how your day was?

Original post by DdotT
Friendly=/= polite as i said earlier, its common manners to say excuse me.
I Disagree aswell, its not that black and white.
A lack of manners is no more present in international students than domestic ones.

Elaborate on why you disagree.
(edited 12 years ago)
Reply 202
Wear a cross seriously? Who the hell wants to wear a cross all the Christians are in retirement homes now.
It'll be interesting to see the religion results for the latest census.
Reply 204
Original post by whyumadtho
Observation is enough.

There is a mutuality of these things. She doesn't come out to talk and you don't go to her to talk. I find it hard to believe that an opportunity has never arisen in six months where you could start a conversation (which is your duty, seeing as you are interested in her).

I see this as just disliking small talk, which is something that resonates with me. Perhaps they don't care how your course is going—why should they? It's general and completely pointless; the conversation will be forgotten shortly afterwards, and there is no solidification of friendship. The only reason you are talking in this case is because you're living together, not because you have an active concern about each other's lives. You don't contact her in the holidays to ask general questions because you don't actually care about her or what she's doing. In what way is this brazen pretence of concern friendly or good-willed, in this case, and why should she be obliged to participate in it?

If talking is comprised of small talk, then no.

Do you talk to all of them?

It is a waste of time. Why should she be expected to dedicate any time or effort to a pointless, banal conversation? Why are you offended by someone not wanting to know how your day was?

A lack of manners is no more present in international students than domestic ones.

Elaborate on why you disagree.


You don't live in my accomodation so you wouldn't know, in the 3 weeks ive been back this semester i've seen her twice. Once coming into the kitchen, another time in the hallway coming back from tesco (not even acknowledging im there).

Bold: I can't contact her in the holidays because we aren't friends because i never see and her rarely get a chance to talk.
You clearly just don't really grasp the situation. To you it's in black and white, that no one SHOULD go around and get to know someone who they are living with for a year if you don't have mutual interests. I can't really grasp how your brain functions because most of your points are alot inapplicable and just don't have a firm grasp of life.
Reply 205
Original post by Steevee
I disagree. I think they are fundamentally, generally agreed upon rules for society, which Christianity has claimed as their own. As such, we owe nothing to 'Christian' values as for the most part they intrinsically come out in society anyway.


I think people are inadvertently given 'Christian values' when they are raised. Modern Society also influences them. To say for the most part they would come out of society anyway, i definately think thats wrong, Religion seems to have played a large part in influencing laws and hence ethics and morals, you may say thats not applicable today buti think Christianity in this country has played a huge role in shaping the specific society we have in Britain today.
Lets be honest if an ArchBishop spoke out for the church of England condemning Leniant laws for murderers for example, even though Britain is a secular country figures like the Arch Bishop of Canterbury still have a big influence on our society, and theres nothing wrong with this.
Considering European History, religion has deeply influenced and shaped modern society as such its highly likely britain would be a different place.
Original post by DdotT
You don't live in my accomodation so you wouldn't know, in the 3 weeks ive been back this semester i've seen her twice. Once coming into the kitchen, another time in the hallway coming back from tesco (not even acknowledging im there).
She leaves her room at least once a day (toilet, food, etc.), so there is ample opportunity to encounter her.

Bold: I can't contact her in the holidays because we aren't friends because i never see and her rarely get a chance to talk.
Do you contact everyone you see in your lectures on a daily basis to ensure you exchange information about each other's day? Do you think people really care or miss anything if on any given day you neglect to ask generic questions about their lives?

You clearly just don't really grasp the situation. To you it's in black and white, that no one SHOULD go around and get to know someone who they are living with for a year if you don't have mutual interests. I can't really grasp how your brain functions because most of your points are alot inapplicable and just don't have a firm grasp of life.
No, I don't think they should, as I don't really see the point. If you have no intention of preserving the 'friendship', and without the agency of spatial proximity the 'friendship' is untenable due to the lack of mutual interests, one may as well cut out the feeble pretence of interest (small talk) and not talk to each other. It's a waste of time given that neither party has a legitimate interest in each other, and once the term ends they will be forgotten or never seen again.

Without mutual interests the friendship will remain on a tedious small talk level, which is completely pointless. What if she just wants to walk around the flat, use the kitchen, etc. without having to contribute to a banal, uninteresting, generic conversation about how everyone's day was when she really doesn't give a ****?
Original post by DdotT
I would say different, i don't know about you but i lived in a multicultural area(s) of london since i was born, i now live at a university.
At both places both a good majority of international students and migrants do not bother to integrate. Example my flat i have 4/7 international students, basically all of them don't bother to socialise with any of us non internationals, except for saying hello and a couple of general words around, same thing around the university, especially asians (orientals) they are rude and do not even try to integrate one bit (mostly).
But hi 5 to the ones who do which are a good number, but most are :/


I think its only obvious that immigrants that are settling here have to show pass some semblance of english language skills ( or should do) depending on the type of visa they apply for. If they do not but still qualify to come here , ie as a spouse or child of a current resident, they should be encouraged to take language classes.

As regards overseas students, i reckon most speak decent english already seeing as their courses are all in english here. Whether they choose to mix with you or not is not really relevant - they spend 5 times as much money as you to study here, they can do what they want quite frankly, they arnt sponging off anyone else. Isnt college full of people you will probably never speak to and either will or wont be friends with? If you want to mix with them, try being more interesting perhaps.

When british people go over to spain, do you think they become best buddies with all the spanish speaking locals or do they camp up alongside a bunch of other ex-pats in an english pub playing darts and watching sky tv?
Reply 208
Original post by Indo-Chinese Food
I think its only obvious that immigrants that are settling here have to show pass some semblance of english language skills ( or should do) depending on the type of visa they apply for. If they do not but still qualify to come here , ie as a spouse or child of a current resident, they should be encouraged to take language classes.

As regards overseas students, i reckon most speak decent english already seeing as their courses are all in english here. Whether they choose to mix with you or not is not really relevant - they spend 5 times as much money as you to study here, they can do what they want quite frankly, they arnt sponging off anyone else. Isnt college full of people you will probably never speak to and either will or wont be friends with? If you want to mix with them, try being more interesting perhaps.

When british people go over to spain, do you think they become best buddies with all the spanish speaking locals or do they camp up alongside a bunch of other ex-pats in an english pub playing darts and watching sky tv?


Was that an attempt at sarcasm?

British people go on holiday there, most don't settle down there. I don't know how you can compare the 2..
Original post by DdotT
Was that an attempt at sarcasm?

British people go on holiday there, most don't settle down there. I don't know how you can compare the 2..


Eh, what are you on about? More than a million british people live in spain alone. many more in france, portugal, cyprus various parts of europe etc - how integrated do you think they are?
It takes many generations to integrate properly.
Original post by DdotT
Was that an attempt at sarcasm?

British people go on holiday there, most don't settle down there. I don't know how you can compare the 2..
Ex-pats aren't holidaying.

How are the international students who will only be living with you for roughly 8 months settled down? They didn't choose to be put with you, so why should they be obliged to converse with you? They applied for accommodation, not conversation.
Reply 211
Original post by whyumadtho
Ex-pats aren't holidaying.

How are the international students who will only be living with you for roughly 8 months settled down? They didn't choose to be put with you, so why should they be obliged to converse with you? They applied for accommodation, not conversation.


And did i choose to be put with them no.
Im bored of this now. I think your intolerant and ignorant.
Original post by DdotT
And did i choose to be put with them no.
Im bored of this now. I think your intolerant and ignorant.
You're the one expecting something above the terms of contract. They applied for accommodation and they received it—there is no further obligation.
Reply 213
Original post by Indo-Chinese Food
Eh, what are you on about? More than a million british people live in spain alone. many more in france, portugal, cyprus various parts of europe etc - how integrated do you think they are?
It takes many generations to integrate properly.


There are far more British people in Australia than anywhere else, including Spain. Most of those British people are very well integrated into Australian life.
Original post by navarre
There are far more British people in Australia than anywhere else, including Spain. Most of those British people are very well integrated into Australian life.


Thats fine, im sure there are lots of other people that have integrated into USA society too.
Im talking about european countries here, where there is a significantly different culture, language etc.
Original post by Indo-Chinese Food
Eh, what are you on about? More than a million british people live in spain alone. many more in france, portugal, cyprus various parts of europe etc - how integrated do you think they are?
It takes many generations to integrate properly.


We only hear about the British ex-pats living in places like Benidorm; you'll find the vast majority who go to live in the French countryside etc, learning the language, sending their children to the local schools, starting businesses catering for the community (I mean the host community, not the British expats), even standing for election.

A few hundred lager louts moving to Benidorm =/= the whole British expat demographic.
Original post by A Mysterious Lord
We only hear about the British ex-pats living in places like Benidorm; you'll find the vast majority who go to live in the French countryside etc, learning the language, sending their children to the local schools, starting businesses catering for the community (I mean the host community, not the British expats), even standing for election.

A few hundred lager louts moving to Benidorm =/= the whole British expat demographic.



There is always different perspective for these things - they may think they fit in well, the local frenchman may not.

The spanish example doesnt jsut apply to few lager louts in benidorm, there is a problem with a lack of integration in most of spain-
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/mar/29/europe-news

The locals might agree. "British people do not seem to integrate terribly well," said a woman reporter on a Spanish daily. "They are very good at societies, book clubs, social organisations of different kinds but, in general, they seem to associate with themselves more often with other expats.

I would argue that is probaly the case in most of greece, the balerics, cyprus,
You can apply similar issues to thailand bali etc etc where there are a lot of ex pats too. Some do try to integrate, but in the eyes of the locals, arnt that successful.

Like i said, proper integration to a different culture takes generations
Reply 217
Original post by Indo-Chinese Food
Thats fine, im sure there are lots of other people that have integrated into USA society too.
Im talking about european countries here, where there is a significantly different culture, language etc.


Other than language, there aren't really many cultural differences between Brits and West Europeans.
Original post by navarre
Other than language, there aren't really many cultural differences between Brits and West Europeans.


then why arnt brits integrating well into spanish society?
Reply 219
Original post by Indo-Chinese Food
then why arnt brits integrating well into spanish society?


Mostly because they're not learning the language. The see Spain as a permanent beach holiday where they can relax and mingle with other Brits, without bothering to integrate into Spanish society.

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending