India is about to hang someone.

Thanks for that clear reasoning

Very good point. A classical example of how inconsistent the Indian justice system really is.

Again with Bin Laden it was a targeted operation in which only Bin Laden and those trying to protect him were killed.

what the f are you talking about. First of all Baba Rajoana didnt even kill anyone. Second, he has served 17 years for conspiracy despite pleading guilty. Mate, you know very little dont you about indian system of justice don't you. Here look at this example, YES LOOK AT IT FIRST, then reply

Kishori Lal- a man involved in ethnic cleansing, 6 death sentances passed, let off because a) congress man and b) good behaviour?

Baba Rajoana - freedom fighter avenging for the generations wiped out by Butcher Beant, served 17 years in jail, openly admitted that only beanta and his traitors were the target, no ethnic cleanser. He should be hanged?

Finallly, FOR YOUR INFORMATION, as Baba Rajoana greatly argues, IF YOUR PEOPLE ARENT RECOGNISED IN YOUR COUNTRY'S CONSTITUTION, WHO DO YOU SEEK JUSTICE FROM? Please answer this question

would you call soldiers of the taliban innocent?

If you want to say the Indian Legal System is guilty then that is a separate issue which you can campaign for.

He was involved in the planning of the bombing, that makes him jointly culpable.

Just because there are examples of cases that have been incorrect, doesn't mean you should just ignore the rule of law for everyone, otherwise what's the point in having a legal system?

Admittedly I don't know the constitution of India, but I do know it is a secular state, perhaps you could point me to the part of the Indian constitution where it says that it doesn't apply to Sikhs, then I can pass comment.

Do your research.

You will find that the Indian Government censors any campaign for Sikh justice. Hence, by publicising this case Sikhs are able to gain world-wide media attention to show the world how corrupt the justice system is.

my friend first you say you dont know the constution of india so how can you comment accuratley on its judiciary? Please answer the last point of my previous post in capital if you can be so kind

.

The legal system revolves around the "constitution of India". How can one come to a judgement about the overall case without consulting this?

can a prisoner of war be hanged?

Under the Geneva Conventions of 1977, no.

"No sentence shall be passed and no penalty shall be executed on a person found guilty of an offence except pursuant to a conviction pronounced by a court offering the essential guarantees of independence and impartiality."

exactly so baba rajoana cant be hanged on international law

my friend first you say you dont know the constution of india so how can you comment accuratley on its judiciary?

Please answer the last point of my previous post in capital if you can be so kind

.

Exactly: India claims to be the "world's largest democracy".

Yeah right.

You don't need to know a country's entire constitution to have an opinion on their judiciary, I am basing my opinion on my belief in the rule of law, not the Indian constitution.




It is a view expressed by Babba Roajana, I have already asked you to point me to the part of the constitution that proves his claim, if his claim is correct that Sikhs aren't represented in the constitution then I can make further comment.

exactly so baba rajoana cant be hanged on international law

fair play on the first point. On the second one, of course yes Sikhs are not represented in the constitution they got bundled in with the hindus, jains, buddhists and the like as all hindus. If you know anything about Sikhism, classing us as Hindu is in my view insulting bordering on racist. BABA RAJOANA WAS A POLICE OFFICER OF PANJAB I THINK HE KNOWS THE CONSTITUTION INSIDE OUT DONT YOU

Which bit am I missing? There is nothing in the text quoted that says prisoners of war can't be hanged.

Is he even a prisoner of war?

fair play on the first point. On the second one, of course yes Sikhs are not represented in the constitution they got bundled in with the hindus, jains, buddhists and the like as all hindus. If you know anything about Sikhism, classing us as Hindu is in my view insulting bordering on racist. BABA RAJOANA WAS A POLICE OFFICER OF PANJAB I THINK HE KNOWS THE CONSTITUTION INSIDE OUT DONT YOU