The Student Room Group

Scroll to see replies

Reply 20

I read it in year 7 (age 11) at school. The teacher explained the ideas and I understood it fine. Not sure I would have picked it all up on my own though!

Reply 21

I first read it when I was 10 years old by myself, and understood it, but I had an unusual and perhaps unhealthy interest in 20th Century History and Politics at that time, which probably helped. I re-read when I was 13 at school, but I didn't really learn much else, bar maybe the names of some of the symbols i.e. the sheep represent the Pravda newspaper, rather than the media as I thought when I first read it. Nothing major, though.

Age isn't everything though. More a good reading ability and understanding of history and politics, particularly the Russian Revolution and its aftermath.

Reply 22

We studied it in Year 8. We had to make presentations on the themes and use of allegory.

Reply 23

well...i got it from my nana (who's slightly dotty and was known to give me ABCcolouring books until I was 13), read the first page, thought "oh good she's now giving me children's animal stories" and then shoved it to the back of my bookcase for two months.

Then my English teacher bought it up in class, and briefly mentioned what it was actually representing. I then retrieved it, read all of it, and understood all the symbolism and shizz.

I was 14 for all that time.

Reply 24

Around 15?

I think one is able to understand it only when he or she has learnt certain history and social studies.

Reply 25

I'd see OP's question as open to interpretation. What level of understanding, and understand which aspects of the book? I'm unsure when I first read it - age 11 maybe? - but I don't think at the time I knew much about say Stalin. I do think I would have been able to work out some of the general themes about human nature though and still gain quite a bit from them. In fact, I'd say that an intelligent person from say a non-European country with no knowledge of the Soviet Union could still read Animal Farm outside of historical context, and understand a whole load about the themes, interactions between the sets of characters and more.

To my eyes it would actually be a pretty crappy book (as literature at least) if to read it you needed as a prerequisite a whole load of knowledge about history and political theory and what have you. If a book is an allegory, then there are a minimum of two levels on which it can be enjoyed or learned from (and the hidden meaning is often one that can be worked out for yourself). And personally I don't reckon that one particular understanding or another should be said to be the best or most important one. Throughout my childhood and teenage years I read a whole ton of books blithely missing out on a whole range of some of their meanings. But I also gained a hell of a lot from them too, and I don't think that my not understanding or noticing some of these meanings signifies that I oughtn't to have read them at all. A great deal of the books I went on to re-read and discover more meanings, and having read them in a sense through different eyes possibly that meant that overall I learned even more.

So as well as being unsure that there is one meaning behind Animal Farm to be discovered, even if there was I don't think that's a reason for a person to read or not read it at a particular age or not. Sure you can read a book and miss out on some fairly central stuff, and maybe feel a bit dumb later on because of it, but I'm all for encouraging kids to read whatever books they like at whatever age they like, just say nudging them in potentially interesting directions every once in a while instead of dictating.
(edited 13 years ago)

Reply 26

we studied it in year nine, so about 13-14.
Original post
by Uni Kid
At what age will most people be able to understand the basic idea behind Animal Farm? Did you have to read it at school? If so, what age were you?


Not read it at school, but the passages and texts I read are simple to understand, the meaning behind it - the critism of a totalitarian and arbitrary state and the innuendo to Russian revolution - by teenagers, also by brainy children partly.

Reply 28

Original post
by Uni Kid
At what age will most people be able to understand the basic idea behind Animal Farm? Did you have to read it at school? If so, what age were you?


We read Animal Farm in Year 8, and before we started, we had a whole term learning about democracy, communism, capatilism etc, And how to apply this knowledge to the book - to understand it. Of course some people were really confused, but I think it depends more on your maturity than your age.

How The Student Room is moderated

To keep The Student Room safe for everyone, we moderate posts that are added to the site.