The Student Room Group

please help me make my career decision!!

sorry if this is in the wrong place, dont know where to put it.

Im in my 2nd year doing psychology/philosophy.

I really want to be a therapist/shrink- its my ambition to go and live in New York as a therapist- possibly a relationship therapist. (yehh....highly unlikely i know!! but we all need to aim high right?!)

For me to do this I would need a P.H.D in clinical psychology. To get this I am going to need tons of work experience, its highly competitive- only 30% of people get onto this course, i *may* need to do a masters first depending what degree class i get. And realistically, with work experience etc i would be lookng at getting on to the PHD at about 26-27. The thing is it requires an awful lot of work to be a clinical psychologist. A ridiculous amount (there are other routes but this is guaranteed the most success). And tbh i just want to start a career now.

My other option is to be an estate agent (i know theyre so different). This isnt a dream job, but i would be happy enough. Ive always had an interest in housing and i like competition. Im guessing on average i would be earning about 30-40,000 a year, in comparison to a good therapist who can earn well in excess of £60,000.

Im asking now because this is my last summer before graduation and i have been offered work experience in an estate agent. I am currently doing some work which would help my clinical side, but there is some of it that im only doing so it goes on my CV. And right now, i dont have the time to be doing both. If i do the work experience in an estate agent then i think id have a better chance of getting a graduate job in one if thats what i decide to do next year. But if i want to apply to be an assistant psychologist i need to do this other voluntary work. And because i have a job over summer etc (i need the money, i support myself) i dont have the time to do all the voluntary/work experience.

Do i give up on my dream job? I just dont know if my hearts in it anymore.
that link didnt work.

i just want someone to tell me what to do!! feeling so split
Reply 3
If it's your dream job, go for it. You only have one life and if it's what you really want to do then you may end up regretting it when you are older and look back... :no:

The only person who can make this decision is you, I really don't know how helpful my or any other answers can be in helping you reach the right one. Imagine yourself in the future:-
a) as an estate agent.
b) as a therapist.
In all honesty which scenario makes you feel happier? Regardless of any anxiety (it's only natural because it's a massive decision), the one which makes you feel more excited is probably the right option.

Bear in mind that to train as a therapist/shrink you will learn skills and knowledge than can be applied to many other jobs in the field of psychology/therapy. So even if you don't end up as a relationship therapist, you still have a high chance of finding a similar job - and still have the opportunity to work towards your dream job.

For the therapist job, you NEED the degree and the training. The estate agent option can be a backup - you don't need a degree for that. You can take training within a firm and gain experience instead.

If you go don't the estate agent route now, then you won't be able to pursue your "dream job", however becoming an estate agent can be a back-up plan if the therapy/shrink option doesn't work out.

I hope this helps, good luck making your decision!
:smile:
that really helped thanks :smile:
Reply 5
If I was you, I would go for the therapist option, else you may spend the rest of your life kicking yourself thinking 'well maybe if I had carried on...'
as long as you work hard and show commitment and passion (which you obviously have) and can strive through knock backs, then you can get your dream job!
just think you've come so far (A levels, gotten into uni, completed first year) that it would be silly to not take a risk and go for it
and if it doesn't work out, I'm sure their will be other opportunities to get into estate agency
best of luck with your future! :smile:
Reply 6
Original post by pinkangelgirl
sorry if this is in the wrong place, dont know where to put it.

Im in my 2nd year doing psychology/philosophy.

I really want to be a therapist/shrink- its my ambition to go and live in New York as a therapist- possibly a relationship therapist. (yehh....highly unlikely i know!! but we all need to aim high right?!)

For me to do this I would need a P.H.D in clinical psychology. To get this I am going to need tons of work experience, its highly competitive- only 30% of people get onto this course, i *may* need to do a masters first depending what degree class i get. And realistically, with work experience etc i would be lookng at getting on to the PHD at about 26-27. The thing is it requires an awful lot of work to be a clinical psychologist. A ridiculous amount (there are other routes but this is guaranteed the most success). And tbh i just want to start a career now.

My other option is to be an estate agent (i know theyre so different). This isnt a dream job, but i would be happy enough. Ive always had an interest in housing and i like competition. Im guessing on average i would be earning about 30-40,000 a year, in comparison to a good therapist who can earn well in excess of £60,000.

Im asking now because this is my last summer before graduation and i have been offered work experience in an estate agent. I am currently doing some work which would help my clinical side, but there is some of it that im only doing so it goes on my CV. And right now, i dont have the time to be doing both. If i do the work experience in an estate agent then i think id have a better chance of getting a graduate job in one if thats what i decide to do next year. But if i want to apply to be an assistant psychologist i need to do this other voluntary work. And because i have a job over summer etc (i need the money, i support myself) i dont have the time to do all the voluntary/work experience.

Do i give up on my dream job? I just dont know if my hearts in it anymore.


Stop watching Hollywood chick flicks and there is no way an estate agent earns 30-40K. My mum's friend who has been an estate agent for 12 years in central London earns £26000.
Original post by yothi5
Stop watching Hollywood chick flicks and there is no way an estate agent earns 30-40K. My mum's friend who has been an estate agent for 12 years in central London earns £26000.


I dont really like chick flicks :s-smilie: Its just something i want to do, whats wrong with that? Someone has to be a relationship therapist and thats what i want.
Failing being a therapist i would still be happy working as a clinical psych in a hospital.

Ok maybe i was wrong on the salary- but i wouldnt want to just be an estate agent, id want to be the best and be at the top of it- managerial level or higher. And they can get a lot of commission.
There are few misapprehensions in your original post, and it may be useful for you to be aware of the following.

If you want to be a therapist there are several ways to do that. Clinical Psychologists are one kind of therapist, but there are therapists from other backgrounds. Some train in healthcare fields like nursing, counselling or occupational therapy, whilst others train independently without a clinical background. In fact you don't even have to go to university at all to be a psychotherapist or counsellor.

While clinical psychologists do therapy, its not all they do. For example, In my day to day work, I spend about 40% of my time doing therapy, 40% doing supervision and teaching, and about 20% doing research. Others may do things like cognitive assessments or various other non therapy tasks. I would say if you want to be a therapist, being a CP is probably not the best way to go about doing it. Also we don't all work in hospitals.

To be a clinical psychologist you do not do a PhD, you do something called a DClinPsy which is very different. You can read all about this on www.clinpsy.org.uk. You are right that the average age of clinical trainees is in the mid to late 20s and will have to go through extra study or lower level posts in order to be a viable candidate. Also not all CPs will be earning £60,000 salaries. Ones that are consultant in management and leadership roles in the NHS or specialist roles may, but the sort that spend their bulk of time delivering therapy certainly won't be.

Also be advised UK clinical training is not accepted in the US. To work in the US you would have to re-train to some extent and demonstrate you meet US licensure requirements.

As for your question about what to do, I think

1) You need to research the field more thoroughly and get an idea of what clinical psychology, psychotherapy, and couples counselling are and what is required. You can get this from your university and asking professionals in those fields.

2) If your heart is really not in it, thats probably not a good sign. Any field where you are going to be dealing with vulnerable people or those in distress requires a high level of commitment and dedication. Its not really something you can do lightly, and to be honest for the amount of work you do, you could be better paid, doing other work (and more quickly and easily too).
(edited 11 years ago)
let me put it this way.
Do you think people (other than those with inherited wealth), honestly believe they have the oppourtunity to make somthing of themselves, or do they just end up there.
i believe you should aim high and be ambitious, but you will be setting yourself up for a life that a minimal percentage live.
Original post by Lord Asriel
There are few misapprehensions in your original post, and it may be useful for you to be aware of the following.

If you want to be a therapist there are several ways to do that. Clinical Psychologists are one kind of therapist, but there are therapists from other backgrounds. Some train in healthcare fields like nursing, counselling or occupational therapy, whilst others train independently without a clinical background. In fact you don't even have to go to university at all to be a psychotherapist or counsellor.

While clinical psychologists do therapy, its not all they do. For example, In my day to day work, I spend about 40% of my time doing therapy, 40% doing supervision and teaching, and about 20% doing research. Others may do things like cognitive assessments or various other non therapy tasks. I would say if you want to be a therapist, being a CP is probably not the best way to go about doing it. Also we don't all work in hospitals.

To be a clinical psychologist you do not do a PhD, you do something called a DClinPsy which is very different. You can read all about this on www.clinpsy.org.uk. You are right that the average age of clinical trainees is in the mid to late 20s and will have to go through extra study or lower level posts in order to be a viable candidate. Also not all CPs will be earning £60,000 salaries. Ones that are consultant in management and leadership roles in the NHS or specialist roles may, but the sort that spend their bulk of time delivering therapy certainly won't be.

Also be advised UK clinical training is not accepted in the US. To work in the US you would have to re-train to some extent and demonstrate you meet US licensure requirements.

As for your question about what to do, I think

1) You need to research the field more thoroughly and get an idea of what clinical psychology, psychotherapy, and couples counselling are and what is required. You can get this from your university and asking professionals in those fields.

2) If your heart is really not in it, thats probably not a good sign. Any field where you are going to be dealing with vulnerable people or those in distress requires a high level of commitment and dedication. Its not really something you can do lightly, and to be honest for the amount of work you do, you could be better paid, doing other work (and more quickly and easily too).


Thanks for that :smile: it was really helpful.

I am aware there are other ways to be a therapist but I also have always wanted to do clinical psychology so failing to be a therapist then being a clinical psych will be my next option, then an estate agent if that makes sense.

Thanks for your help :smile:
Original post by Lord Asriel
There are few misapprehensions in your original post, and it may be useful for you to be aware of the following.

If you want to be a therapist there are several ways to do that. Clinical Psychologists are one kind of therapist, but there are therapists from other backgrounds. Some train in healthcare fields like nursing, counselling or occupational therapy, whilst others train independently without a clinical background. In fact you don't even have to go to university at all to be a psychotherapist or counsellor.

While clinical psychologists do therapy, its not all they do. For example, In my day to day work, I spend about 40% of my time doing therapy, 40% doing supervision and teaching, and about 20% doing research. Others may do things like cognitive assessments or various other non therapy tasks. I would say if you want to be a therapist, being a CP is probably not the best way to go about doing it. Also we don't all work in hospitals.

To be a clinical psychologist you do not do a PhD, you do something called a DClinPsy which is very different. You can read all about this on www.clinpsy.org.uk. You are right that the average age of clinical trainees is in the mid to late 20s and will have to go through extra study or lower level posts in order to be a viable candidate. Also not all CPs will be earning £60,000 salaries. Ones that are consultant in management and leadership roles in the NHS or specialist roles may, but the sort that spend their bulk of time delivering therapy certainly won't be.

Also be advised UK clinical training is not accepted in the US. To work in the US you would have to re-train to some extent and demonstrate you meet US licensure requirements.

As for your question about what to do, I think

1) You need to research the field more thoroughly and get an idea of what clinical psychology, psychotherapy, and couples counselling are and what is required. You can get this from your university and asking professionals in those fields.

2) If your heart is really not in it, thats probably not a good sign. Any field where you are going to be dealing with vulnerable people or those in distress requires a high level of commitment and dedication. Its not really something you can do lightly, and to be honest for the amount of work you do, you could be better paid, doing other work (and more quickly and easily too).


In reference to statement you made that you don't need a degree to register/practice as a psychotherapist or counsellor, I believe to be incorrect (please correct me if I'm wrong). According to both prospects.ac.uk and the UK Council for Psychotherapy (UKCP), you require a relevant undergraduate degree (counseling/psychology/social work) and a master in psychotherapy to even practice in the NHS. Although in private practice, this is not necessarily the case for psychotherapists.
Reply 12
Original post by pinkangelgirl
I dont really like chick flicks :s-smilie: .


It's just New York therapist is such a cliche in all TV and film. It may be a coincidence, but you must have developed the idea from somewhere..
Original post by ForKicks
It's just New York therapist is such a cliche in all TV and film. It may be a coincidence, but you must have developed the idea from somewhere..


where do we all get our job ideas from?
In reference to statement you made that you don't need a degree to register/practice as a psychotherapist or counsellor, I believe to be incorrect (please correct me if I'm wrong). According to both prospects.ac.uk and the UK Council for Psychotherapy (UKCP), you require a relevant undergraduate degree (counseling/psychology/social work) and a master in psychotherapy to even practice in the NHS. Although in private practice, this is not necessarily the case for psychotherapists.


Currently, most counsellors in the UK come under the remit of the BACP who state at present there are no legal minimum qualifications necessary to practise as a counsellor in the UK.

http://www.bacp.co.uk/crs/education/training.php

While the UKCP do have higher requirements, not all psychotherapists are registered with them, nor need to be.

Psychotherapist is not a protected title or structured career like Nurse, GP or clinical psychologist and there aren't minimum standards of qualification. However, this may change with government moves to introduce professional registration in the future.

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending