The Student Room Group

The age old question PPE vs E&M

Poll

PPE vs E&M

My GCSE results and AS subjects are listed below, and i am predicted high As in all of them. i am from a state grammar school.

i want to go into investment banking in the future.

i know that either course will get me into IB, but i still cant decide on which course to apply to.

any people with experiences in these courses with any advice?

Scroll to see replies

Reply 1
Age old question????
PPE is a highly regarded subject with years of tradition, status and famous alumni behind it; EM is an upstart subject with the kudos of Sociology at Thames Valley!!
Reply 2
PPE without a doubt.
looking at your other options, its clear you enjoy economics enough not to consider combining it with other subjects:
LSE - Economics Warwick - PPE/Economics, UCL - Economics
would you be satisified with studying politics and philosophy on the same level as economics (even if only in the first year)? would you prefer studying economics at a more profound level?
you just dont seem like a 'combined' degree type of person, so E&M seems more suitable, but read through the syllabuses.. and ask around to get a greater feel for both subjects.
Reply 4
E&M would be better for you, IMO.

But the two degree programmes are pretty different.

Does politics turn you on?
Reply 5
E+M ---> IB
PPE---> Future Tony Blair

:biggrin:
Reply 6
Ok, first thing, this *really* isn't a decision you want other people to make. Do you prefer philosophy and/or politics to management? If so, that makes it an easy choice. If not, then do you want to have more compulsory maths and stats in the first year (E&M has)? Then ask yourself about workload - are you the type of person who loves the academic side, or do you want to have more time to pursue other things - PPE has a higher workload than E&M for the first year. If you still can't decide, apply to Univ and do a dual application - I applied for E&M and PPE.

If you want to go into IB, I'd imagine E&M is more applicable. However contrary to what you said, *neither* will get you a job in IB, since that requires extra-curriculars, good interviews and to be very bright (moreso than getting into either course). But E&M is certainly a good way to go for IB. I would also suggest not to be so firmly set, as many people while here change their minds about what they want to go into. I wanted to go into IB before I came, and I certainly don't now.

OldMan
Age old question????
PPE is a highly regarded subject with years of tradition, status and famous alumni behind it; EM is an upstart subject with the kudos of Sociology at Thames Valley!!

Which explains why E&M at Oxford was named the most employable degree in the country. We have the same econ teaching as the PPEists (except extra maths in the first year) and the management teaching is generally at a much higher standard - the business school and it's staff are utterly amazing.

At careers fairs, saying you do E&M gets you some very nice reactions. Possibly because it's far rarer than PPE - there's 270 of them and under 90 of us per year - and possibly because of the applicants per place being a lot higher.
Reply 7
Drogue
Ok, first thing, this *really* isn't a decision you want other people to make. Do you prefer philosophy and/or politics to management? If so, that makes it an easy choice. If not, then do you want to have more compulsory maths and stats in the first year (E&M has)? Then ask yourself about workload - are you the type of person who loves the academic side, or do you want to have more time to pursue other things - PPE has a higher workload than E&M for the first year. If you still can't decide, apply to Univ and do a dual application - I applied for E&M and PPE.

If you want to go into IB, I'd imagine E&M is more applicable. However contrary to what you said, *neither* will get you a job in IB, since that requires extra-curriculars, good interviews and to be very bright (moreso than getting into either course). But E&M is certainly a good way to go for IB. I would also suggest not to be so firmly set, as many people while here change their minds about what they want to go into. I wanted to go into IB before I came, and I certainly don't now.


Which explains why E&M at Oxford was named the most employable degree in the country. We have the same econ teaching as the PPEists (except extra maths in the first year) and the management teaching is generally at a much higher standard - the business school and it's staff are utterly amazing.

At careers fairs, saying you do E&M gets you some very nice reactions. Possibly because it's far rarer than PPE - there's 270 of them and under 90 of us per year - and possibly because of the applicants per place being a lot higher.

A lot higher? I remember the % acceptance ratio to be marginally higher. Definitely not "a lot".
Maths. Do Maths instead.
Reply 9
Knogle
A lot higher? I remember the % acceptance ratio to be marginally higher. Definitely not "a lot".

PPE has ~4 apps per place, E&M ~7, according to oxford's website. That's a large difference. So yes, the acceptance ration is a lot higher for PPE.
Reply 10
More like 4.x and 6.x respectively.

Anyhow that shouldn't be the basis on which you determine what course to apply for.
Traum
E+M ---> IB
PPE---> Future Tony Blair

:biggrin:


That's funny, given that Blair didn't even do PPE.
As Drogue says, E&M is very well regarded by the financial sector.

However, I think PPE is a far broader and more interesting degree... although I am biased, of course.
Well the problem is, I find the combination of politics, philosophy and economics very interesting, and I am immersed in current economic and political affairs, as i enjoy them both. in terms of philosophy, I feel it would complement by study in economics and politics to a great extent, also, my economics teacher (a keen philosopher) manages to link a lot of what we learn in economics and current affairs to philosophical theory, which i find gripping. Therefore, i would love to study PPE.

However, in terms of career paths, i definitely want a business/finance based career and am serious about considering investment banking. assuming that i was dead set on going into IB, and i did joint honours in economics and politics or majored in economics. would i be in the same position as E&M-ists when trying to find employment within IB, or would my course put me at a disadvantage?
Reply 14
Knogle
More like 4.x and 6.x respectively.

Except it's not, since 14.4% acceptance is 6.9444 apps per place, which is a lot closer to 7. Please don't try and correct people's correct information with incorrect information.

Knogle
Anyhow that shouldn't be the basis on which you determine what course to apply for.

Nobody mentioned that at all! I was justifying why employers liked it - it being rarer and harder to get into tend to be good reasons.
Reply 15
for IB, E&M is simply the better degree, but as had been said, you will need lots of extra-cirriculars, good interview technique etc. and maths is also a viable option for IB, don't rule it out yet.
Reply 16
dimsumdim
Well the problem is, I find the combination of politics, philosophy and economics very interesting, and I am immersed in current economic and political affairs, as i enjoy them both. in terms of philosophy, I feel it would complement by study in economics and politics to a great extent, also, my economics teacher (a keen philosopher) manages to link a lot of what we learn in economics and current affairs to philosophical theory, which i find gripping. Therefore, i would love to study PPE.

However, in terms of career paths, i definitely want a business/finance based career and am serious about considering investment banking. assuming that i was dead set on going into IB, and i did joint honours in economics and politics or majored in economics. would i be in the same position as E&M-ists when trying to find employment within IB, or would my course put me at a disadvantage?

Sounds like PPE is the way to go for you. You have to really care about your subject- "passion and enthusiasm" is the way they describe what they're looking for.
You would not get be rejected on the basis of your degree "only being PPE". If you are rejected, it is for other reasons. Your employability in IB does not improve between the two of them because one has a better 'name'. The only point raised so far that sounds like it'll have any dramatic impact is workload in year 1. Which if lower for E&M, would be helpful, since you can then do extra-curriculars to a greater extent.
Reply 18
dimsumdim
Well the problem is, I find the combination of politics, philosophy and economics very interesting, and I am immersed in current economic and political affairs, as i enjoy them both. in terms of philosophy, I feel it would complement by study in economics and politics to a great extent, also, my economics teacher (a keen philosopher) manages to link a lot of what we learn in economics and current affairs to philosophical theory, which i find gripping. Therefore, i would love to study PPE.

However, in terms of career paths, i definitely want a business/finance based career and am serious about considering investment banking. assuming that i was dead set on going into IB, and i did joint honours in economics and politics or majored in economics. would i be in the same position as E&M-ists when trying to find employment within IB, or would my course put me at a disadvantage?


Do PPE. Choosing what degree to do at the age of 17 because you want to maximise your chance of becoming an investment banker is frankly a bit foolish; you can easily change your mind. Do the subject you will enjoy more; you will also probably get a better degree if you are truly passionate about it. And as Pres Ben said, sure E&M would be the slightly more obvious choice for IB, you certainly won't be turned away for not having a good enough degree.
Reply 19
samlangfield
That's funny, given that Blair didn't even do PPE.



right he did law... but that's hardly the point? What i was trying to say is that PPE is perhaps more suitable for a political carrer where as EM more for IB... what then i'm sure someone will prove me wrong:p: