Cailleuxs roundness index formula

Question for Geographers really..

I know its 2r/a * 1000 where r = radius of sharpest angle of the sone and a = longest axis however do you have to use mm or cm for r and a values?

Thanks for replying

Reply 1

CHL

OP

any1 ? :-/

Reply 2

chrisbphd

2

CHL

Question for Geographers really..

I know its 2r/a * 1000 where r = radius of sharpest angle of the sone and a = longest axis however do you have to use mm or cm for r and a values?

Thanks for replying

I'm a Physicist but I can answer your question using a purely mathematical approach. Because you are dividing r by a, as long as they have the same units it won't matter which ones you use (cm, mm, m, km, inches, miles, AU, light-years etc - although some of these would be pretty silly units to use!). All you are interested in here is the ratio of 2r to a.

For example
Suppose r = 30 cm = 300 mm and a = 15 cm = 150 mm

Then, with r and a in cm:

2r/a * 1000 = (2*30)/15 * 1000 = 4000

With r and a in mm:

2r/a * 1000 = (2*300)/150 * 1000 = 4000

These results are the same.

Reply 3

CHL

OP

but the equation is only spose to give a value between 0 and 1000 - where 1000 is perfectly round .. :-/ ?

Reply 4

CHL

OP

ahh ive see what youve done and i understand now :smile:

you wouldnt of known it but r will never if ever be a larger figure than a, thanks tho mate - I will use mm for both :smile:

Reply 5

chrisbphd

2

Sorry, it will give a value between 0 and 1000 as long as 2r<=a. I didn't know that it had to be between 0 and 1000 because I'd never seen the equation before (My knowledge of Geography is a GCSE A* that I got in 2001 - therefore limited). The statement about the units is still true though, just make sure that 2r is less than or equal to a.

Cailleuxs roundness index formula

Related discussions

Articles for you

How The Student Room is moderated