Without using L' Hospital's rule,how to get 0 as the answer for limit of (1cos x)/x as x approaches 0?
I did some research previously.I don't want to use L' Hospital's rule because I'm in the process of proving the derivative of sin x is cos x.
Appreciate your response.

 Follow
 1
 14032013 09:55

 Follow
 2
 14032013 10:38
(Original post by MR INFINITY)
Without using L' Hospital's rule,how to get 0 as the answer for limit of (1cos x)/x as x approaches 0?
I did some research previously.I don't want to use L' Hospital's rule because I'm in the process of proving the derivative of sin x is cos x.
Appreciate your response.
Then you can use .Last edited by Notnek; 14032013 at 10:42. 
 Follow
 3
 14032013 10:52
(Original post by MR INFINITY)
Without using L' Hospital's rule,how to get 0 as the answer for limit of (1cos x)/x as x approaches 0?
I did some research previously.I don't want to use L' Hospital's rule because I'm in the process of proving the derivative of sin x is cos x.
Appreciate your response.
Last edited by Farhan.Hanif93; 14032013 at 10:54. 
 Follow
 4
 14032013 10:59
(Original post by Farhan.Hanif93)
Given that both the limit you're trying to prove and the limit you're assuming are proven in essentially the same way, assuming one is just as big an assumption as assuming the other. You may as well prove the one we want, if you're going to assume that limit (which requires proof nonetheless).
I'm a bit rusty and couldn't think of a way to prove it. I got too used to quoting sinx/x for trig limits. 
 Follow
 5
 14032013 11:06
(Original post by notnek)
Agreed.
I'm a bit rusty and couldn't think of a way to prove it. I got too used to quoting sinx/x for trig limits. 
 Follow
 6
 14032013 11:10
[QUOTE=Farhan.Hanif93;41804455]Observe that (think carefully about how you'd show the RH inequality).
Could you explain how you get and what RH inequality is? I'm only one more step to squeeze theorem and get 0 as the answer.
Thanks. 
 Follow
 7
 14032013 11:31
(Original post by MR INFINITY)
Could you explain how you get and what RH inequality is? I'm only one more step to squeeze theorem and get 0 as the answer.
Thanks.
The LH inequality arises from the boundedness of cosx, and the RH inequality arises from the power series definition of cosx. I'll leave you to fill in the details; please post back with some working if you want further help. 
 Follow
 8
 14032013 12:29
(Original post by Farhan.Hanif93)
The LH inequality arises from the boundedness of cosx
(Original post by Farhan.Hanif93)
RH = RH inequality arises from the power series definition of cosx.
cos x = 1  0  (x^2)/4 + 0 + ...
cos x =1 (x^2)/4 + ...
cos x ≥ 1  (x^2)/4
1cos x≤ (x^2)/4
1cos x≤ x^2
Now I get it.Thanks for your brilliant tips. It seems like this method requires formula d(sin x)/dx=cos x or d(cos x)/dx= sin x (same reason I don't prefer L' Hospital' rule). Do you know of a method that does not involve the two formulas?(something like http://2000clicks.com/mathhelp/Calcu...xOverxIs1.aspx )Thanks again.Last edited by MR INFINITY; 14032013 at 12:30. 
 Follow
 9
 14032013 13:04
(Original post by MR INFINITY)
From cos x ≤ 1,I get 0 ≤ 1cos x.
cos x =cos 0  (sin0)(x)  (cos 0)*(x^2)/2! + (sin 0)*(x^3)/3!+...
cos x = 1  0  (x^2)/4 + 0 + ...
cos x =1 (x^2)/4 + ...
cos x ≥ 1  (x^2)/4
1cos x≤ (x^2)/4
1cos x≤ x^2
Plus 2!≠4.
It seems like this method requires formula d(sin x)/dx=cos x or d(cos x)/dx= sin x (same reason I don't prefer L' Hospital' rule). Do you know of a method that does not involve the two formulas?(something like http://2000clicks.com/mathhelp/Calcu...xOverxIs1.aspx )Thanks again.
EDIT: Also, is this actually something to do with ALevels or did you mislabel the thread? 
 Follow
 10
 14032013 13:20
(Original post by MR INFINITY)
Now I get it.Thanks for your brilliant tips. It seems like this method requires formula d(sin x)/dx=cos x or d(cos x)/dx= sin x (same reason I don't prefer L' Hospital' rule). Do you know of a method that does not involve the two formulas?(something like http://2000clicks.com/mathhelp/Calcu...xOverxIs1.aspx )Thanks again.
Unit circle:
What are the lengths of the arc AB and the line AB? 
 Follow
 11
 14032013 13:58
(Original post by Farhan.Hanif93)
Instead, you define cos x by the power series and build your argument from there.
(Original post by Farhan.Hanif93)
Plus 2!≠4. 
 Follow
 12
 14032013 14:11
(Original post by notnek)
What are the lengths of the arc AB and the line AB?
By Pythagoras theorem,
(Line AB)^2 = (sin x)^2 + (1+cos x)^2
= (sin x)^2 + 1  2cos x +(cos x)^2
Applying Pythagorean identity,
= 1 + 1  2cos x
(Line AB)^2 = 2 (1 cos x)
Arc AB is longer than line AB.
x ≥ 2 sqrt(1 cos x)
x/2 ≥ sqrt(1 cos x)
That sqrt is bothering me! Where did I get wrong? 
 Follow
 13
 14032013 14:27
(Original post by MR INFINITY)
Arc AB = 1*x = x
By Pythagoras theorem,
(Line AB)^2 = (sin x)^2 + (1+cos x)^2
= (sin x)^2 + 1  2cos x +(cos x)^2
Applying Pythagorean identity,
= 1 + 1  2cos x
(Line AB)^2 = 2 (1 cos x)
Arc AB is longer than line AB.
x ≥ 2 sqrt(1 cos x)
x/2 ≥ sqrt(1 cos x)
That sqrt is bothering me! Where did I get wrong?
Alternatively, if D is the point where the vertical from A meets OB then consider the angle DAB which is x/2 and you can show

 Follow
 14
 14032013 15:11
(Original post by notnek)
Alternatively, if D is the point where the vertical from A meets OB then consider the angle DAB which is x/2 and you can show
http://math.stackexchange.com/questi...queezetheorem
Is this what they mean?
<x approaches zero)lim(1cos x)/x
<x approaches zero)lim (1cos^2 x)/(x+cos x)
(1square of cos 0) / (0+1)
(11)/(0+1)
so the limit =0 
 Follow
 15
 15032013 04:39
(Original post by MR INFINITY)
How is the power series then? I haven't actually started my A level (the proper way at school) so I still don't know many things
Otherwise, the geometrical approach works fine.
PS: since you're trying to prove that you've probably shown that as
You could then take the following shortcut by whipping out a trig identity:
... and avoid the limit altogether! 
 Follow
 16
 15032013 21:44
(Original post by MR INFINITY)
Still can't figure things out.My geometry is bad enough.
http://math.stackexchange.com/questi...queezetheorem
Is this what they mean?
<x approaches zero)lim(1cos x)/x
<x approaches zero)lim (1cos^2 x)/(x+cos x)
(1square of cos 0) / (0+1)
(11)/(0+1)
so the limit =0
The limit of is a
wellknown question to use the
Because
And why ?
Look at the picture bellow:
For the area (A) of triangles and Section
that is
using x>0 as sinx/x is even, and cosx>1 as x>0 from the sandwich rule
follows
Last edited by ztibor; 15032013 at 21:47.
Reply
Submit reply
Related discussions:
 Trigonometry
 Limits  help
 Differentiating trig functions
 What's your favourite topic in Maths?  A Level Maths & FM
 2016 Edexcel C2 Morning exam[discussion thread]
 Edexcel Unit 1: Physics on the Go ~20th May 2014
 How long does it take you to do a single chapter of C3/C4?
 The topics you enjoy(ed) the most in the core modules of A ...
 Edexcel IAL Core Mathematics  C12  WMA01  JUNE 2016
 OCR MEI FP2 Thread  AM 27th June 2016
TSR Support Team
We have a brilliant team of more than 60 Support Team members looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.
This forum is supported by:
 SherlockHolmes
 Notnek
 charco
 Mr M
 TSR Moderator
 Nirgilis
 usycool1
 Changing Skies
 James A
 rayquaza17
 RDKGames
 randdom
 davros
 Gingerbread101
 Kvothe the Arcane
 Airmed
 The Financier
 The Empire Odyssey
 Protostar
 surina16
 nisha.sri
 Reality Check
 claireestelle
 Doonesbury
 furryface12
 Amefish
 harryleavey
 Lemur14
 brainzistheword
 Rexar
 Sonechka
 LeCroissant
 EstelOfTheEyrie
 CoffeeAndPolitics
Updated: March 15, 2013
Share this discussion:
Tweet