The Student Room Group

Can I have some feedback on my poem?

I wrote this based on a short story I read earlier.

Colours

Red, indigo, violet, blue
I see them, as I see you
Fie, fie the dagger of lust,
Yet drag you against my skin, I must

They don't see what I see in you.

Scarlet, scarlet, trickling near
The exodus of doubt and fear
Heart aflutter,
Mind into butter,

As the room becomes white and blue,
I bid you my farewells to you.

Coveted dagger my only friend,
Yet assured I am; this is the end.

Scroll to see replies

6/10. Seems quite generic.

Posted from TSR Mobile
Original post by writerSalmon
I wrote this based on a short story I read earlier.

Colours

Red, indigo, violet, blue
I see them, as I see you
Fie, fie the dagger of lust,
Yet drag you against my skin, I must

They don't see what I see in you.

Scarlet, scarlet, trickling near
The exodus of doubt and fear
Heart aflutter,
Mind into butter,

As the room becomes white and blue,
I bid you my farewells to you.

Coveted dagger my only friend,
Yet assured I am; this is the end.


I like it :smile: I like the use of colour to convey a bit of mood :smile:

Just a couple of things I'd change - you used blue twice, I'd say change one of those because it feels like nothing has changed, when I guess a lot has in terms of the poem. "Heart aflutter, Mind into butter" idk that line just feels a bit forced so I would change it. I like the idea but butter is gooey, golden etc which I don't think really fits the mood of the poem. Also the extra you "I bid you my farewells to you", get rid of one of them :tongue:

I really like "coveted dagger" :smile:
Reply 3
Original post by Pessimisterious
6/10. Seems quite generic.

Posted from TSR Mobile


Could you explain why?
Reply 4
Original post by cant_think_of_name
I like it :smile: I like the use of colour to convey a bit of mood :smile:

Just a couple of things I'd change - you used blue twice, I'd say change one of those because it feels like nothing has changed, when I guess a lot has in terms of the poem. "Heart aflutter, Mind into butter" idk that line just feels a bit forced so I would change it. I like the idea but butter is gooey, golden etc which I don't think really fits the mood of the poem. Also the extra you "I bid you my farewells to you", get rid of one of them :tongue:

I really like "coveted dagger" :smile:


Thank you! The extra "you" was a typo. :colondollar:
Reply 5
It's hard to make sense of what's going on..
Original post by writerSalmon
Could you explain why?


Well it just didn't really feel like it had any heart to it. It seemed like you just parroted all the usual conventions for a poem, rather than making it your own.
Reply 7
Original post by writerSalmon
I wrote this based on a short story I read earlier.

Colours

Red, indigo, violet, blue
I see them, as I see you
Fie, fie the dagger of lust,
Yet drag you against my skin, I must

They don't see what I see in you.

Scarlet, scarlet, trickling near
The exodus of doubt and fear
Heart aflutter,
Mind into butter,

As the room becomes white and blue,
I bid you my farewells to you.

Coveted dagger my only friend,
Yet assured I am; this is the end.


I don't feel any passion coming from the words, and it comes across as if you are trying too hard.
Reply 8
Original post by mrmicrosoft
I don't feel any passion coming from the words, and it comes across as if you are trying too hard.


How could I make it have more passion and more effortless?
Reply 9
OP your poem was fine: there is a special section for creatives like you and i...

Creative Corner www.thestudentroom.co.uk/forumdisplay.php?f=139‎
Reply 10
I guess I'll just stop writing. Thanks for the feedback.
Reply 11
Original post by the bear
OP your poem was fine: there is a special section for creatives like you and i...

Creative Corner www.thestudentroom.co.uk/forumdisplay.php?f=139‎


But the vast majority of posters said it was terrible.
Original post by writerSalmon
How could I make it have more passion and more effortless?


can i ask are you actually passionate about poetry?

If so, write about something you are passionate about, something that will invoke real emotion.

It doesn't have to be serious. It can be funny. It can be both:



See how, even though it is serious and funny, it offers the artist's critique of the 'American Dream' and is full of emotion.

I really like the Ballad of Reading Gaol by Oscar Wilde:

''Yet each man kills the thing he loves
By each let this be heard,
Some do it with a bitter look,
Some with a flattering word,
The coward does it with a kiss,
The brave man with a sword!''
Reply 13
Original post by mrmicrosoft
can i ask are you actually passionate about poetry?

If so, write about something you are passionate about, something that will invoke real emotion.

It doesn't have to be serious. It can be funny. It can be both:



See how, even though it is serious and funny, it offers the artist's critique of the 'American Dream' and is full of emotion.

I really like the Ballad of Reading Gaol by Oscar Wilde:

''Yet each man kills the thing he loves
By each let this be heard,
Some do it with a bitter look,
Some with a flattering word,
The coward does it with a kiss,
The brave man with a sword!''


What I'm passionate about probably won't be good enough either.
Original post by writerSalmon
I guess I'll just stop writing. Thanks for the feedback.


if you're passionate about it try harder- don't be disheartened.
Original post by writerSalmon
What I'm passionate about probably won't be good enough either.


you'd be surprised.

what are you passionate about?
Reply 16
Original post by mrmicrosoft
if you're passionate about it try harder- don't be disheartened.


But I'm a bad writer
Original post by writerSalmon
But I'm a bad writer


yeah fine give up.

with a mentality like that, you won't get anywhere.
Reply 18
Original post by mrmicrosoft
you'd be surprised.

what are you passionate about?


Nothing, to be honest.
Original post by writerSalmon
Nothing, to be honest.


then write about how empty you are. there's defintely matieral there to write about.

but watevz, you've already said you're going to give up. How old are you btw?

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending